A Comparison of Roles of Women in Both Japanese and American Society Sample Essay

The modern-day universe is altering really quickly in assorted domains of life. World economic systems are altering dramatically and globalisation is rapidly going an ineluctable phenomenon that everyone is going more and more cognizant of. Consequently. it is acquiring more and more of import to believe about what the hereafter holds. As a pupil go toing a woman’s college. I am cognizant of the functions that adult females have held in this state. and it is really of import. particularly as I begin to believe about my calling waies and hereafter. to calculate out where my topographic point in the universe will be in merely a few old ages. As markets change and political and economic power displacements. the functions that adult females play in these assorted spheres may non be as easy determined as most may believe. Further. aside from the menace of the unknown for adult females in American society. since globalisation is going more and more of import. it is imperative that I non merely understand my function as a adult female here in America. but besides the functions of adult females in states around the universe. Aside from my deep involvement in Japan. after researching the functions of adult females in Nipponese society. I have found that the functions of adult females. although they seem to be really different. do hold some similarities.

This paper will show a comparative survey of the functions of adult females in Nipponese society and American society. In order to offer a comprehensive expression at the state of affairs. a history of the functions of Women in both societies will be provided and an observation of current social functions of adult females in each state will be described. Since Japan and the United States interact on each other in assorted ways. it will be interesting to research what major functions of adult females in their several society drama and how such functions are altering. In order to offer some sensible anticipations of what social functions of adult females will be like in the hereafter. this paper will besides research the causes of the alterations in women’s social functions in these states.

We will write a custom essay sample on
A Comparison of Roles of Women in Both Japanese and American Society Sample Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

Before analysing the function of adult females in Nipponese society. it is of import to believe about where the social norms that people are subjected to come from. Proverbs play a important function in many civilizations throughout the universe including the Nipponese civilization and they besides contribute significantly to the Nipponese manner of life. In her book Asiatic Folklore Studies. writer Hiroko Storm explores how adult females in Nipponese society are perceived through traditional Nipponese Proverbs. Storm studied 817 Proverbss and discussed what they reveal sing traditional Nipponese attitudes toward adult females. Of these Proverbss merely 29 of these spoke positively of adult females and the other negative 1s dealt with the unwanted features of adult females or their laden state of affairs. Harmonizing to Storm. traditional Proverbs about adult females can be classified into two classs: adult females in general which includes lower status. stupidity. changeableness. ill-nature. garrulity. failing and assorted and adult females in specific functions or state of affairss which includes married womans. female parent and girl in jurisprudence. widows. cocottes. intelligent adult females and beautiful adult females. ( Storm 168 )

These classs were created prior to World War II and it is of import to observe that the position of married womans was significantly lower among the upper category. In lower category households where the household earned money as husbandmans or merchandisers. hubbies and married womans worked together to gain a life so the wife’s place in the household was of import. In the latter half of the nineteenth century. the Meiji authorities changed the political and societal construction of Japan in an effort to catch up with the more advanced states of the West ( Storm 170 ) However. during this clip period they were non concerned with the place of adult females.

The first motions toward human rights for adult females in Japan began after the Meiji Restoration in 1868. Unlike in America. during the late nineteenth century protagonists of woman’s rights did non recommend for political inclusion or vote rights. They were contending for reforms in the patriarchal society that allowed for the subjugation of adult females. Woman’s instruction was one of the first things that protagonists worked toward and it was slightly easy achieved because policy shapers believed that instruction was of import for the saving of the province because it would fix misss to go effectual married womans and female parents capable of bring forthing diligent. loyal boies. Although these were non the same thoughts that protagonists had the handiness of instruction allowed for more promotions for adult females in Nipponese society. Prior to the late nineteenth century. patriarchal cultural patterns such as harlotry and polygamy subjected adult females to mistreat and sexually familial diseases. During this clip major promotions were made in this country every bit good.

As a adult female who is a portion of American civilization but who is really interested in Nipponese civilization. I thought that it would be good to research a comparing between adult females in both societies. Western states have a certain image of what adult females in Japan are similar and although this image may be true to a certain extent. after reading an article written by Seth Friedman. ” Women in Nipponese Society: Their Changing Roles. ” I learned that there are two distinguishable Nipponese societies. public and private. and adult females play different functions in both of these societies. In the private household function adult females are frequently rather dominate and more dominate than the male members of the family. The adult females in Japan are really dedicated to their households and it is really of import that they raise kids who function is society good. Because of the Confucian influences on the Nipponese civilization that emphasizes the supreme place of the male. and a hierarchal power construction the function of adult females in public Nipponese society is different.

Throughout much of my research I found that the information was slightly dated. For illustration. the information on how adult females are perceived through Nipponese Proverbs was based on research that was done in 1989. In an attempt to happen more updated information. I decided to concentrate on a subject that is really current and is impacting societies across the universe every twenty-four hours. Globalization is the theory related to the turning interconnection of the universe.

When most people think of globalisation. they think about the enlargement and interconnection of the world’s economic systems. nevertheless. globalisation besides affects societies socially. culturally. and politically. As the universe becomes more closely linked together. it is of import to analyse how assorted societies are altering and recognize what the causes of those alterations are. One group that is frequently over looked when analysing the effects of globalisation is the civil on the job force among Nipponese adult females. As a consequence of societal and political globalisation. there has been a development of feminism which included the increased saliency of non-state individualities. the opening up of chances for effectual political activity at a local degree. a raised international profile of women’s rights. and the potency for militants to utilize international jurisprudence to organizer transnationally. ( Bishop 2002 ) Although. adult females in Japan do hold potency to make authorization through globalisation. it is of import to observe that the Nipponese authorities includes a political party and trade brotherhood system that efficaciously excludes adult females. In order to make their feminist ends Nipponese adult females have had to accommodate and adjust their schemes to the bing national and international establishments every bit good as notice how globalisation is in fact altering these establishments every bit good. In this subdivision I would foremost wish to look at the function female labour workers have traditionally played in party and trade brotherhood political relations in Japan.

Nipponese adult females have been able to keep political power in the yesteryear. In Japan’s first post-war election in 1946. 39 female deputies were elected. However. when the Japanese political system was reformed and the Liberal Democratic Party had control. their precedence was Japan’s economic growing. and because election tactics consisted largely of set uping strong links with the corporate elect adult females were largely excluded. ( Bishop 2002 ) As clip progressed. adult females faced challenges in elections besides because adult females were frequently merely elected if they had the support of a trade brotherhood and adult females merely make up 28 per centum of trade union members in Japan. ( Miura 2001 ) Further. when the figure of Diet seats decreased in the 1970s and with electors reluctant to vote for adult females it became more hard for adult females to derive places.

One of the differences between the American women’s rightist motion and the Nipponese feminist motion. when it comes to political representation. is that while Nipponese adult females were runing for equal labour rights from the 1950s-1970s. they received small attending because the subject was merely non a high precedence subject in Nipponese society. This was partially because Nipponese women’s labour market engagement at this clip was less than in Europe and the US and as a consequence. Nipponese adult females were less witting of the gender-based division of paid labour than their western opposite numbers. ( Bishop 2002 ) Along with deficiency of action from the authorities. gender functions in Nipponese society have besides played a function in the unjust labour conditions for Nipponese adult females. In the mid-1980s the Nakasone authorities cut instruction. public assistance. and environmental disbursement for twenty-four hours attention centres and school tiffins. These were occupations that were frequently held by adult females and these cuts were damaging to the manner of life for these adult females. Many of them were forced to go forth their occupations or give up societal activities. Electoral and parliamentary establishments in Japan are male-dominated and the policies that are frequently pursued are non good to female workers.

Despite the troubles adult females have to confront as clip has progressed adult females have been able to derive some benefits. There are many women’s groups that lobby the authorities and through United Nations intercession there was an addition in feminist activities and an increased consciousness of gender equality issues throughout the general population. Between 1988 and 2001 there has been increased representation of adult females in the Diet and local assemblies which is a mark that Nipponese electors are more willing to accept female politicians. ( Bishop 2002 ) As adult females become more active in Nipponese political relations. they are going more rambunctious in assembly and although they are frequently criticized for their un-lady like ways these adult females are opening doors for adult females everyplace throughout Nipponese society.

Harmonizing to the theory of institutional dynamism. one of the accelerators for establishments to go dynamic is that alterations in the socioeconomic context or political balance of power produce a new state of affairs where old establishments begin to function different terminals as new histrions gain a bridgehead within them. ( Bishop 2002 ) In Japan local authoritiess have come to be title-holders of enterprises towards gender equality as supported by women’s webs. feminist deputies gain representation. There have been several policies to assist better the place of adult females in society. One of the most of import policies was the Basic Law for Gender-Equal Society which was passed in June. 1999. The basic end of this jurisprudence was to clear up basic constructs related to formation of a gender-equal society. Under this jurisprudence. the cardinal authorities. local authoritiess and Nipponese citizens are required to do attempts to travel toward accomplishing gender-equality in all countries of society. This jurisprudence has been enacted in many ways. For illustration. in Tokyo the local authorities can bespeak private companies to describe on the position of their execution of gender equality. ( Hashimato 2001 ) In the Gifu prefecture research was conducted on the sexual division of labour in the workplace and at place and in Fukui City functionaries concentrated on bettering women’s political engagement. ( Bishop 2002 )

Feminist groups along with the United Nations have besides worked to go through many other Torahs that have been influential. Japan has besides acquired a big sector of organisations with the ends of fixing adult females for political relations. Moriya Yuko believed that adult females would be empowered if they entered the determination making-fields they were frequently excluded from and in 1996 she set up the World Women’s Conference Network which aimed to advance international exchange among adult females and she besides founded a school for draw a bead oning female politicians. The school’s end is to hold 50 per centum of the representatives be adult females and the school is successfully get downing to make that end. Although Japan is doing major moves toward female equality in political relations. in 2000 the United Nations Gender Empowerment step. which records women’s engagement in political and economic decision-making. ranked Japan and 41 out of 70 states judged to hold high human development ( Bishop 2002 ) and as a consequence adult females in Japan still have many challenges to get the better of.

Nipponese Feminist Motions

In order for alteration to happen in a society at that place has to be an issue that people feel profoundly plenty to work toward work outing. These was the state of affairs for adult females in both American and Nipponese societies. Because of its position as an Asiatic state. many Americans have a strong disassociation to the state. They think that the Nipponese expression otherwise. believe otherwise. and have no relation to anything in American society. However. after researching both feminist motions in the states it is clear that the states are non so different after all. During the Nipponese feminist motion. there was a major accent on women’s organisations because Nipponese cultural patterns frequently construction activism and political engagement along gender lines which frequently prevents adult females from take parting. Harmonizing to Florence Passy. writer of a paper on socialisation. enlisting. and the structure/agency spread. she believes that the organisations or webs fill a critical spread between construction and bureau in that they socialize and build single individualities ; recruit persons who are sensitive to a peculiar political issue. and let them the opportunity to take part ; and determine individuals’ penchants before they decide to fall in the motion. In short. these organisations are responsible for enrolling adult females with similar involvements and fixing them to be active and informed participants in the political sphere when it comes to get the better ofing the challenges adult females face. ( Passy 2000 )

Similarly to the feminist motion in the United States in the 1880s Nipponese adult females participated in workplace work stoppages and so in the 1920s an active women’s right to vote motion emerged that successfully got a Bill passed in the House of Representatives that gave adult females the right to vote in 1930. nevertheless. it was non ratified due to the Manchurian Incident in 1931. and confirmation was indefinitely postponed. Other groups were created but none of them were successful in go throughing major statute law.

There were two major groups during the Nipponese post-war women’s motion. The Nipponese Communist Party Central Conference on Working Women motion supported the Marxist thought that the subjugation of adult females could be solved with the accomplishment of a socialist society and they concentrated on forming adult females into trade brotherhoods. instead than protesting against the more complex conditions of adult females in station war Japan. This motion is still active today particularly when it comes to runing for the rights of parttime workers. The other group was really composed of multiple women’s groups called Fujin Kaikan which was more conservative and the adult females organized non-challenging cultural activities. such as taking linguistic communication or cookery categories. ( Bishop 2002 ) Again. although these groups were successful they did non make any major alteration and none of their activism became high profile.

October 21. 1970 is when activism about women’s labour rights truly came into public consciousness. The adult females of the Women’s Liberation Movement held a March where they protested a scope of issues and chanted mottos such as. “Mother. are you truly happy with your married life? ” and “A homemaker and a cocotte are raccoons in the same lair. ” ( Bishop 2002 ) The adult females who were apart of this motion were immature female workers and pupils who had been active in the New Left. anti- Vietnam War motions who were upset with the fact that during this motion work forces seemed to be hypocritical in the fact that they rejected authorization but merely permitted adult females militants to make things such as typing during the motion.

Although participants in this motion were frequently ridiculed and attracted small public understanding when they did things such as processing in pink helmets demanding the legalisation of the contraceptive method pill. they did raise consciousness about economic growing taking to women’s greater engagement in the work force and established academic women’s surveies. In the 2nd half of the seventiess. groups emerged that were more straight focused on working within the authorities system and influencing authorities policies and actions. These adult females were more likely to be attorneies. Diet members. labour motion militants and members of political parties and as a consequence these groups were considered more legitimate in the eyes of the general public and among elites when the United Nations International Women’s Year forced the Nipponese authorities to move on the job of gender favoritism.

Over the old ages many more women’s groups were created and multiple conferences were held with assorted governmental organisations to raise women’s rights consciousness. Books have been written about the motions. women’s centres have been built and many adult females are still active participants in some of these groups today. Many use their meetings for self-enlightenment. instruction. aggregation and distribution of information. audience. studies and research and to interchange positions about the ends of the assorted groups. In an interview with Komatsu Makiko. an militant for women’s labour issues and the writer of the 2nd of all time adult females surveies textbook in Japan. after go toing the United Nations conference in Nairobi where the Forward Looking Strategies for the Advancement of Women was passed. she said that go toing the conference introduced her to feminism in other states. that she was profoundly impressed and had come to deeply see the relation between multi-culturalism and human rights. ( Bishop 2002 ) During the clip of the Nipponese women’s movement’s there were many other women’s motions were traveling on around the universe. In fact. the first UN conference on gender equality took topographic point in Mexico City in 1975. Another state that had a really powerful women’s motion was the United States.

Similarly to the women’s motion in Japan. the American women’s rightist motion had a slow start and there were many efforts at reform before assorted groups were successful. After the American Revolution the rules or autonomy and quality were non carried over to the rights of adult females. There were really few educational chances. adult females were non allowed to vote and adult females could non have belongings. Women began to actively voice their deficiency of equality in the 1830s. Many of them were a portion of the antislavery motion and while they were contending to stop bondage they realized that they faced subjugation themselves. Angelina and Sarah Grimke’ along with Elizabeth Cady Stanton are considered the laminitiss of the women’s motion. Stanton is considered one of the most polar people of the motion because she helped be after the first women’s rights convention in Seneca Falls in 1848 and she besides drafted the Declaration of Sentiments which asserted the axiomatic truth that all work forces and adult females are created equal.

Some of the ends of the convention included reforming matrimony and divorce. spread outing belongings rights for adult females. and most significantly procuring the right to vote. Throughout the remainder of the century. Stanton. along with Susan B Anthony. worked on stressing the right to vote and so they gave control to the National American Woman Suffrage Association run by Carrie Chapman Catt who believed that the right to vote could be won on a province by province footing. Over the old ages leading in the motion was passed down to many different adult females and they all worked to accomplish the assorted ends of the many organisations that were created with an accent on women’s rights. Under Alice Paul and the National Woman’s Party adult females gained the right to vote through the 19th Amendment in 1920.

During World War II. many adult females were forced to travel into the work force and after the terminal of the war many of them had become excessively accustomed to working and did non desire to lose the benefits of a payroll check and employment. This led to an addition accent on women’s labour rights. similar to what Nipponese adult females were working toward. Second Wave Feminism began in the sixtiess and continues to be presently. In the 1960’s with the publication of Betty Freidman’s The Feminine Mystique adult females who were discontent with their social functions were given a voice and in the Third wave feminist motion is believed to hold started in the 1990s.

The motion started as a response to what adult females thought were the failures of the 2nd moving ridge. The category differentiation that exist in American society causes the gender individuality marker of female to be broken and this creates separate groups of adult females who believe they are contending and working toward different things. For illustration. the jobs of white in-between category adult females are non the same as the jobs that an Afro-american low-class adult females faces and these jobs should non be attempted to be fixed with the same solutions. Presently in America there are still women’s release organisations that work toward equality for adult females in general. The chief differences between the women’s release motion in Japan versus the motions in the United States is that the organisations had to work within different social and cultural norms. nevertheless. their overall ends and ways of making these ends were really similar.

The construct of globalisation has played a immense function in Nipponese women’s motion. With the aid of the United Nations. Japan was able to work with other states and organisations around the universe to better women’s rights and do certain the rights they fought for in Japan are experienced by Nipponese adult females throughout the universe. For illustration. in 1995 the Asia-Japan Women’s Resource Center was established in Tokyo to supply a footing for the activities of the Asian Women’s Association. an organisation that communicates with groups elsewhere in Asia to prosecute in joint activities around the issues of migratory adult females. harlotry and trafficking of Asiatic adult females. Asiatic brides and international matrimonies. and adult females workers employed by Nipponese transnational companies. ( Bishop 2002 )

The support of other states has decidedly helped maintain impulse for women’s rights motions traveling. In fact. in 1996 Nipponese women’s groups were able to work with the United States National Organization of Women in 1996 to assist them battle sexual torment in the Nipponese Mitsubishi Motor Company. It has been said that the instance could non hold been won if the groups had non come together. Both of these illustrations show how the interconnection of the universe has made it possible for Nipponese and American groups. along with women’s rights groups throughout the remainder of the universe. to pass on and join forces on work outing the jobs that many of them portion.

Women’s rights motions have worked to successfully to derive adult females rights to make everything from being able to take part politically to having land in both Japan and the United States and these motions are still actively working to derive adult females equal rights today. Because of the societal norms that exist in both states. but particularly in Japan. adult females had to prosecute methods that were sometimes unconventional to do their voices heard and they found that organizing groups and organisations were the most successful. The effects of globalisation have aided in doing rigorous policies and making a better circuit of communicating that women’s rights organisations across the universe can utilize to better their schemes and dockets. Equality for adult females has improved significantly over the centuries in both Japan and the United States and as a adult females interested I prosecuting callings in both of these states I look frontward to the alterations that will go on to be made and to seeing what function I will play in these alterations.

Plants Cited

Storm. Hiroko. “Women In Nipponese Provebs. ” Asiatic Folklore Studies 51. 2 ( 1992 ) : 167-182. JSTOR. Web. 12 Feb. 2012.

Bishop. Beverley. “Globalization and Women’s Labour Activism in Japan. ” Electronic Journal of Contemporary Nipponese Studies. 2 ( 2002 ) : n. pag. Web. 12 Feb. 2012.


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out