Benefits And Drawbacks Of The Balance Scorecard Accounting Essay

The cardinal thought behind a balance scorecard-type measuring system is that if the administration tracks the right set of taking indexs and gives them proper importance weightings, so net incomes will necessarily follow. Empirical grounds, peculiarly focused on client satisfaction, appears to back up the premiss that some non fiscal steps are significantly associated with future fiscal public presentation and contain extra information non reflected in past fiscal steps.[ 2 ]

The balance scorecard fosters a balance among different strategic steps in an attempt to accomplish end congruity, therefore promoting employees to move in the administration ‘s best involvement. It is a tool that helps the company ‘s focal point, improves communicating, sets organizational aims, and provides feedback on scheme.

We will write a custom essay sample on
Benefits And Drawbacks Of The Balance Scorecard Accounting Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

Every step on a balance scorecard addresses an facet of a company ‘s scheme. In making the balance scorecard, executives must take a mix of measurings that

Accurately reflect the critical factors that will find the success of the company ‘s scheme

Show the relationships among the single steps in a cause-and-effect mode, bespeaking how nonfinancial steps affect long-run fiscal consequences ;

Supply a broad-based position of the current position of the company

Enterprise, Board, and Executive Scorecards:

Board Balanced Scorecard:

Defines the strategic parts of the board

A tool to pull off the public presentation of the board and its commissions

Clarifies the strategic information required by the board

Board Balance Scorecard

Enterprise Scorecard

Executive Scorecard

Executive Balanced Scorecard:

Describes the strategic parts of an executive

A tool buttocks and honor the public presentation of executives

A cardinal information input to the board

Enterprise Balanced Scorecard:

Describes the endeavor scheme, steps, and marks

A tool to pull off the public presentation of the endeavor

A cardinal information input to the board


Research Analysis:

Research continues to demo that most companies tend to do determinations chiefly on fiscal proctors of public presentation. Boardss, moneymans and investors place overpowering trust on fiscal indexs such as net income turnover, hard currency flow and return on capital. Directors tend to back up the position that non fiscal public presentation information should merely be used internally.

Benefits and drawbacks of the balance scorecard:

The chief benefits are:

It can assist stakeholders in measuring the administration if steps are communicated externally.

It avoids direction trust on short-run or uncomplete fiscal steps

It can guarantee that divisions develop success steps for their division that are related to the overall corporate ends of the administration.

By placing the non fiscal steps, directors may be able to place jobs earlier. For illustration, directors may be mensurating client satisfaction straight as portion of the balance scorecard. If this canges, stairss can be taken to better it once more before client leave and it starts to impact on the company ‘s fundss.

Drawbacks are:

The unfavorable judgment of the balance scorecard is that direction are asked to run into so many different aims ( some of which might be conflicting ) that they lose all position. There is a hazard that maximization of stockholder wealth might be forgotten.

It frequently involves a significant displacement in corporate civilization in order to implement it.

It does non supply a individual overall position of public presentation. Measures like ROCE are popular because they handily summarise ‘how things are traveling ‘ into on convenient step.

Measures may give conflicting signals and confuse direction. For case, if client satisfaction is falling along with one of the fiscal indexs, which should direction forfeit?

There is no clear relation between the balance scorecard and stockholder analysis.

Strategy mapping-implementing the balance scorecard more efficaciously:

Strategy function was developed by Kaplan and Norton as an extension to the balance scorecard and to do execution of the scorecard more successful.

The stairss involved are:[ 4 ]

At the caput of the scheme map is the overruling aim of the administration which describes how it creates value. This is so connected to the administration ‘s other aims, categorised in footings of the four positions of the balance scorecard, demoing the cause-and-effect relationships between them.

The scheme map helps administrations to clear up, depict tna pass on the scheme and aims, both within the administration and to external stakeholders, by showing the cardinal relationships between the overall aim and the back uping scheme and aims in on diagram


Administrations have frequently found it hard to interpret the corporate vision into behavior and actions which achieve the cardinal corporate aims.

In pattern many employees do non understand the administration ‘s scheme, and systems such as public presentation direction and budgeting are non linked to the scheme.

Critical Analysis of BSC within different type of administrations:

The Balance Scorecard can be used to mensurate the public presentation of an administration. Traditionally public presentation was step merely in fiscal footings, but it is now recognised that fiscal steps entirely are non plenty, hence the development of the Balance Scorecard. There are different fluctuations of the Balance Scorecard that may be used since it facilitates internal public presentation measuring and therefore is designed by each administration to run into their demands, nevertheless most Balance Scorecards contain four positions: fiscal, client, internal concern procedure and invention & A ; larning positions. Each of these sections represents a different point of view on operation of the administration. Each of these contributes to the success of the administration ; in fact many argue that success in the first three of these positions leads to fiscal success. The Balance Scorecard develops schemes into operations.

The usage of Balance Scorecard is a going from company ‘s old patterns if they did non hold any systematic manner of associating its operations to its vision or of mensurating public presentation.

Analysis on Library Business:

In order to understand Balance Scorecard and the public presentation measures we take an illustration of a library which is in a little town with a population of 40,000 people live within a 15 mile radius of the town.

Its client would desire to cognize that they can borrow the latest books and DVDs from the library so as portion of Customer Perspective a step that could assist to supervise the library ‘s success in this country would be the figure of new points that had been added to the library within a specified clip period.

The library would besides necessitate to mensurate its ain efficiency of operations, peculiarly as it relies on authorities support and contributions. As portion of the Internal Business Perspective the library can mensurate its velocity in obtaining new rubrics. Recognizing demand, placing beginning, negociating a monetary value and puting an order all take clip. The smaller the sum of clip take the better will be client perceptual experience and the better value for money for the library.

The above both positions can convey the efficiency and client satisfaction for a normal library.

Evaluation of Balance Scorecard:

Balance Scorecard demonstrates that the accomplishment of fiscal aims is frequently the consequence of accomplishing other non-financial marks which lead to the fiscal marks being achieved. For illustration, if clients are happy with the merchandises and service being provided so this will frequently ensue in increased gross revenues which improve net incomes and hence fiscal aims are achieved.

Therefore by mensurating non-financial public presentation and taking action when marks are non achieved, the consequence will be improved fiscal public presentation. This is because the cause of fiscal public presentation has been reviewed, whereas fiscal public presentation indexs entirely do non place the causes of public presentation, merely the consequence of it.

BSC Analysis on Airline Business:

The figure of take-offs that are on clip is a step of the efficiency of the air hose in fixing the aircraft for a flight. Aircraft do non gain gross while they are standing on the tarmac. This is a step of efficiency of internal procedures ( Internal Business Perspective ) .

The figure of new paths operated by the air hose is a step of the invention of the air hose to develop new services for its clients. The greater the figure of paths the more client pick, which besides increases the figure of clients that would see air hose for their flights ( invention & A ; larning position )

Air line could utilize the figure of lost calls due to all of the telephone operator being busy. Customers will anticipate a speedy reply when they telephone and undue may ensue in the client pealing off before the call is answered. The negative feeling gained by the client may ensue in current and future concern being lost. ( Customer position )

BSC Analysis on Service Business:

The chief constructs of the Balance Scorecard are that an administration ‘s public presentation should non be measured on the footing of its fiscal consequences entirely. Other cardinal public presentation indexs are relevant to an administration ‘s success.

The Balance Scorecard typically identifies four quarter-circles of public presentation index that would be suited for most administrations, though each administration is free to find the public presentation indexs that are most relevant to its ain demands.

Many people could utilize the balance scorecard to mensurate its success in other countries of its concern. It is of import for service concerns such as colleges to understand the wants of its clients and therefore steps connected with the client position are of import. The college may detect that peculiar types of classs are demanded by their clients and this may take the college to develop new classs which can be measured utilizing the invention and larning position.

The college can besides look at how it operates its procedures both in relation to its staff and its clients. Improvements in these procedures could be used to better the fiscal consequences, possibly, because costs salvaging can be made.

BSC Analysis on Insurance Company:

The insurance company could mensurate the clip it takes for its staff to reply the telephone at call Centre section. This is a step of the effectivity of its internal concern procedures. The longer it takes to reply the call the more likely is it that possible clients will be lost because they do non desire to wait. If waiting clip is important, the client may besides discourage others from doing such call therefore losing insurance company even more concern.

The above illustration can be applied to most of the today ‘s concerns because most of the concerns offer the client service installations such as call Centres.

Link between BSC & A ; TQM ( Total Quality Management ) :

Entire quality direction ( TQM ) patterns have been implemented by houses interested in heightening their endurance chances by including quality and uninterrupted betterment into their strategic precedences.

Using fiscal and non-financial steps, the balanced scorecard ( BSC ) attack appraises four dimensions of steadfast public presentation: clients, fiscal ( or stockholders ) , larning and growing, and internal concern procedures.

TQM does non see employee satisfaction in its hunt for uninterrupted betterment, but the BSC does see employee satisfaction. Therefore, by following a BSC a house that has adopted TQM will get the better of this inadvertence which will in bend addition employee satisfaction and later steadfast public presentation.

The below tabular array shows the nexus between these two attacks[ 5 ]:

Key TQM-Related



Performance Prosodies

BSC Dimension

Executive committedness and direction competency

Employee sentiment study

Employee satisfaction

New techniques debut compare with rivals

Learning and growing

Internal concern procedure

Customer relationships

Customer-satisfaction study

Customer acquisition rate

Customer keeping ( or trueness rate )

% of the industry market portion

Number of client ailments

Warranty fix cost


Financial ( or stockholders )

Supplier relationships

Supplier-satisfaction study

Supplier keeping rate

Internal concern procedures


Labour efficiency compared with rivals

Rework/scrap rate

Cost of Quality ( % of sale )

Tax return on investing

Market portion

Internal concern procedures

Financial ( or stockholders )

Employee preparation

Employee-satisfaction study

Employee capablenesss

Spending degrees in dollars for employee development and preparation

Learning and growing

Open, less bureaucratic civilization and employee authorization

Customer-satisfaction study

Employee-satisfaction study

The grade of decentralization in corporate administration


Learning and growing

Monitoring quality plans ( zero-defects civilization )

Incidence of merchandise defects

Material and labour efficiency discrepancies

Percentage cargos returned due to hapless quality

Warranty fix cost

Internal concern procedures


Internal concern procedure betterment and fabrication invention

Investing in high engineering

Introduction of new direction ( e.g. JIT )

Gross saless growing

Internal concern procedure

Financial ( or stockholders )


Following interviews with senior corporate directors in 15 of Sweden ‘s largest multinational companies, 8 were found to follow CBSC. However, CBSC had small impact on control at the corporate degree. Corporate control was financially focused in all the companies: chiefly fiscal steps were of import, criterions were merely set for fiscal steps and wagess were mostly based on fiscal public presentation steps. Top direction ‘s demand for simpleness and comparison internally, and capital market force per unit areas motivated the fiscal focal point.

Life-size image ( 43 K )[ 6 ]


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out