Community Participation And Collective Action In Uttarakhand Villages Essay

Educate Girls Globally ( EGG ) was founded by an economic expert A. Lawrence Chickering in 1999 who believed that instruction of the miss kid had a immense impact on both household every bit good as the national income. It was besides helpful in bettering wellness conditions, commanding population, and in diminishing political extremism. With grants from the Inter-American Development Bank, in 2002 Lawrence partnered with SBMA- a local NGO, in the province of Uttarakhand and implemented the plan through SBMA on a really limited footing in approximately 1,400 schools. EGG aims non merely at bettering registration of the misss but besides at their keeping and academic public presentation in authorities schools by act uponing the local community and authorities resources. This they achieve by instilling a sense of ownership amongst all the stakeholders.

1.2 Shri Bhuvaneshari Mahila Ashram- SBMA
SBMA was started in the twelvemonth 1976 by Swami Manmathan ( popularly addressed as Swamiji ) who, moved by the predicament of impoverished adult females and kids in the hills started SBMA as an refuge for them. The local people contributed their clip, money, and labor for puting up this topographic point. SBMA has its caput office in the Tehri territory of Uttarakhand in small town Anjanisain and subdivision offices in a figure of other territories of the province. SBMA runs several undertakings aimed at community development. But, the common characteristic of most of the plans is community engagement. SBMA believes that no community development enterprise can be a success unless the demand is felt by all the stakeholders involved and a sense of ownership is induced in them. This besides happens to be the manner SBMA was established by Swamiji and the manner in which he achieved many other aims as in the popular motions of Uttarakhand such as The University Movement, The Chandrabadani Movement, The Silkot Tea Estate motion, and the Bantha Water Movement.

We will write a custom essay sample on
Community Participation And Collective Action In Uttarakhand Villages Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

1.3 A People ‘s Initiative for Learning ( APIL )
The APIL plan was launched in the twelvemonth 2003 by EGG in association with SBMA which today reaches out to more than 1400 schools covering 80000 kids across Uttarakhand. APIL is a kind of run intoing evidences of the political orientations of both EGG and SBMA who believe in raising community engagement. EGG believes that bureaucratically run authorities schools are the ground for the failure of the instruction system since none of the take parting bureaus have a sense of ownership. SBMA, on the other manus, believes that the instruction system needs to be sensitized to the demands of the rural public so as to increase the registration and literacy of the miss kid. These two, non so different, ideas find their meeting evidences in the APIL- EGG plan wherein all those involved in leaving instruction and those at the having terminal actively take part to come up with a solution to work out the prevalent job of misss ‘ instruction.

2.0 More about APIL-EGG Program
2.1 Mission, Objectives, and Aim
SBMA ‘s mission is to advance primary and secondary instruction of misss in Uttarakhand through active engagement of the local community.

The Aims of the plan can be summarized as:

To better the quality of instruction in Government Schools, in order to supply better chances for misss.

To place and analyse the assorted factors impacting the registration, keeping and accomplishment in simple instruction of misss.

To guarantee community engagement in bettering simple instruction in general by ingraining a sense of ownership among the community members. ( hypertext transfer protocol: //, accessed: 27th February 2011 )

It aims at accomplishing these aims by arousing people ‘s engagement in the procedure of educational reforms to convey about answerability, equity and quality. It steadfastly believes that the present system has to go more sensitive and antiphonal to the modern-day demands of the misss so as to make an environment for better instruction chances. This, it plans to accomplish through self-governance so that the educational reforms that come about are non merely superficial but are those that have evolved from the grass roots level through duologue with all the parties involved. This will eventually take to the community pull offing the educational procedure and will fit them to turn to any lack in the local instruction system in the long tally therefore extinguishing the jobs that thwart misss ‘ instruction in the country. This will besides assist in marinading the quality of instruction in the govt. schools which is a major hinderance towards instruction of all. Apart from this, other jobs such as deficiency of substructure and basic comfortss are besides solved through a participatory attack.

APIL Approach towards Improving Education of Girl Child
The APIL-EGG plan was planned to be executed in three stages. The first stage purposes at informations aggregation on a figure of issues like the figure of school dropouts, available school substructure, and attempts to derive penetration on the prevailing norms and attitude of local people on the issue of instruction of misss. This stage operates in two stairss:

Measure: 1 School Information Campaign ( SIC )
The intent of SIC was data aggregation on

School- about available substructure, activities undertaken, installations etc.

The students- no. of pupils enrolled and the figure of dropouts ; & A ;

The local community ‘s attitude towards misss ‘ instruction.

During the SIC procedure, information was generated on substructure, installations in the school, handiness of learning AIDSs, authorities educational plan, small town instruction commission, and mid twenty-four hours meal strategy. Apart from this, information was besides gathered on the local community and other small town degree Institutions.

Measure: 2 The Gram Shiksha Sabha ( GSS )
Once the information was collected refering to the assorted facets of misss ‘ instruction, it set the phase for treatment with the small town instruction council ( GSS ) constituted by SBMA in the small towns. This council comprised members of the small town Panchayat, instructors, parents, Mahila Mangal Dals ( Women Welfare Groups ) , Yuvak Mangal Dal ( Youth Welfare Groups ) and other members of the small town. The treatments therefore facilitated involved a duologue between the community and the field workers to make a positive attitude towards the instruction of misss. The follow-up steps taken by the SMC after the small town meetings ensured sustainability of the procedure of educational reforms to some extent.

However, it is non possible to turn to all jobs and the demands of the misss by duologue entirely. Other factors such as basic substructure, quality of instructors, and socio-economic factors that prevent schooling of misss can non be solved by duologue entirely as these are beyond the horizon of the villagers. Dialogue was a mere instrument to do the misss realize the importance of instruction merely as it was a medium to do the community aware of their rights towards quality instruction. It is a agency to repeat to the villagers the fact that the duty of supplying quality instruction lies with the province and they need to asseverate their rights ( if it was the hapless quality of the instruction which was a hinderance to misss ‘ registration ) .

Once the informations and other relevant information were gathered from the community and the people were sensitized plenty, the plan moved into the 2nd stage. Here, small town specific programs for quality betterment of govt. schools were made. This stage involved the instructors, school staff, direction and parents to a greater extent to measure the effectivity of the inputs provided by their schools for the pupils. They are therefore able to see their defects and formulate policies and appraisal processs for the inputs that they provide to pupils.

Finally, the stage 3 is the execution stage wherein misss are provided with necessary instruction. The instruction is skill based for misss above 14 old ages of age and who dropped out of school or ne’er went to school while schooling is provided to those who are under 14 and either, were ne’er enrolled or dropped out early. The attack followed by SBMA to increase registration and keeping of misss in school draws thoughts ( though non deliberately ) from different theoretical accounts of corporate action wherein community is mobilized to co-operate mentioning assorted grounds.

3.0 APIL-EGG in the Backdrop of Various Collective Action Theories
3.1 Social Mobilization
As mentioned in predating subdivisions SBMA wanted to work out the job of misss ‘ instruction by affecting the local community and seeking solutions from them to undertake the job such that it would be a long permanent solution. Not merely the community but besides other interest holders such as the Panchayat, small town elders/learned people and the educational institutes were involved in the procedure of making consciousness amongst the multitudes about their rights and to demand development of instruction system in the country and the bringing of quality services by the instructors and other related governments. Whether this enterprise taken by SBMA will be able to prolong itself after the EGG plan comes to a stopping point is a inquiry that needs to be explored. SBMA may merely be moving as an external agent determining the outlook of people which may non last after the accelerator ( SBMA ) is removed. Besides, the deeply entrenched dreamy attitude of the school instructors towards instruction in small towns may return back when the community stops oppugning them.

3.2 Convergence of Like-Mindedness as a agency of Mobilization
The hapless quality of instruction and an apathetic attitude of school governments towards the lower strata of the society has been a hinderance non merely to instruction of the miss kid but to instruction in general. However, Peoples in rural countries have non voiced their concerns or have ne’er stood up for their rights merely because there was a clear dearth of a leader or a agencies of mediation between the general populace and the governments. Both parties had their ain secluded sentiment on the topic without either turn toing the existent job. SBMA ‘s EGG plan, as an external agent, has non merely helped in transporting the thought of demand for instruction of the misss into the community but besides has mobilized people to move jointly as a group to demand for their rights. We can see that while the demand for quality instruction was already felt by the rural societies it was the induction by the NGO that brought everyone together at one platform to demand resources from the school governments. Therefore, we see the convergence of likeminded people catalyzed by the presence of the external agent- the development organisation.

3.3 Corporate Cost v/s Individual Cost
No affair how hard the NGO may seek it would non hold been able to convey about this corporate behaviour among people if the villagers had greater involvement and lower costs involved in individualistic behaviour than in organizing the collective. The province of Uttarakhand is a comparatively new province with meagre resources. Govt. Schools form the anchor of primary and secondary school instruction in most of the topographic points with the private/public/convent schools being limited to the metropoliss. Furthermore, many of these private schools employ inexperient instructors or recent high school/ college pass-outs which puts the credibleness of these schools in serious uncertainty. In such a state of affairs, those who can afford prefer to travel to nearby towns or metropoliss for better chances of instruction for their kids. However, there is a huge bulk which is left buttocks and has small pick beyond the locally run Govt. schools. In such a state of affairs the demand for good schools is felt non merely for misss but for one and all.

Since, it is non possible for most of those left behind to direct their wards to the metropoliss due to pecuniary restraints, forming themselves as a corporate to claim their right to good schools is a better and more cheap an option. Therefore, the corporate cost is much less than the single cost and this forms the footing of the corporate action here.

3.4 Vision of Future
Besides, the vision of bright hereafter for their kids, something which they could non bask themselves, propels people to prosecute in the corporate and seek remedial actions.

3.5 Dialogue as a Tool for Mobilization
APIL makes usage of the power of duologue to make awareness amongst people about their rights and claims and about the importance of misss ‘ instruction. This is to be done at two degrees. First, the local community consisting the parents is to be made cognizant of their right to demand instruction. Second, the local administration body- Panchayat is made cognizant of the assorted plans that have been sanctioned for the local school and have non been implemented by the school governments.

However, this is non an easy undertaking. To strike a duologue with any community to whom SBMA is an unknown name is about impossible. It is of import that the local people have faith in the workings of the organisation without which the community may non come up with their jobs readily which may decelerate the development procedure. Therefore, SBMA had a important function to play in the sense that it ‘s continued presence in all these small towns in the past and deep engagement in the assorted development activities taken up here had brought it adequate celebrity and most significantly trustworthiness which was of premier importance. Since, people had adequate religion in the establishment of the organisation the procedure of originating duologue with the community and most significantly with the misss ( which happens to be a sensitive portion of the undertaking ) went on without much trouble. Therefore, the consciousness created by the NGO helped the mobilisation procedure.

Another of import facet of the plan was redressal of the grudges and jobs put frontward by people. This was achieved by taking the jobs to the local school governments. Here once more, the jobs were put frontward non as ailments neither was coercion used to acquire the governments to hold to the demands made by the villagers but was simply put frontward and their feedback sought on the same, common evidences were reached and alterations brought approximately.

3.6 Traveling from Mythical to Critical Consciousness
Before the exercising conducted by the NGO people in these small towns can be considered to be in a province of mythical/magical consciousness where they believed that they were resigned to their destiny and there was small that they could make to alter the position quo. They were unaware of their rights and as a consequence did non oppugn the unfairnesss bing in the society. The duologue, was a powerful tool used by the bureau to assist the villagers move from a province of charming consciousness to a naA?ve one and eventually to a critical degree of consciousness where they began to comprehend the jobs non as mere ‘accidents ‘ that struck them but as facts related to socio-economic contradictions. When they awakened to this fact they realized that forming as a corporate gave them the power with which they could transform things around them.

3.7 Extinguishing Dualism between Individual and Society
This besides helped them see themselves as an bureau which can convey about alterations in the society of which they were a portion. Equally long as they were trapped in the fabulous consciousness they saw themselves apart from the society and as an object of atrociousnesss and unfairness. But, rousing to the critical consciousness made them recognize that there was no duality or all right line dividing them from the society but instead it was a continuum and they were transforming the society every bit much as they were susceptible to be changed by it.

3.8 Institutionalization of the Procedure
To work out this job, it would be deserving sing the institutionalization of the procedure that SBMA has adopted to mobilise the community towards demanding resources on which they have right. Lack of institutionalization may ensue in this enterprise losing consequence with clip and finally going defunct like most of the undertakings by NGOs which show consequences merely till the NGO is operational in the country. Institutionalization is besides of import from the point of position of bettering quality of instruction the burden of which, to a great extent, lies with the instructors and governments. SBMA is rather an influential organisation in the province of Uttarakhand with about all major development plans being routed through it. As a consequence, the instructors in the Govt. schools may work towards the betterment of quality of instruction ab initio and may go on boulder clay they find the presence SBMA in the small town but may travel back to their old ways one time the NGO is non-operational. Therefore, ensuing in failure of the plan.

An instruction council, with representation of each of the interest holder groups, may be constituted to supervise the working of the schools and turn to the demands of the pupils and parents. Besides, this group should be a well infirmed one so as to be able to asseverate people ‘s right to quality instruction.

4.0 A Success Stories
Case Study1: Enterprises of SMC
Enterprises of SMC
A GSS was organized in small town Jissua of Kalsi block on 3/12/03. The meeting was attended by the small town caput, school schoolmaster, dropout misss and many others from the community. On sharing the information from their small town it was found that there were nescient about many facts and figures. The school edifice in the small towns had been sanctioned in 1997 but was still lying uncomplete since none took the enterprise. After the meeting it was decided by the members of SMC and others to instantly get down the building followed by registration of all the kids in the school. Two dropout misss Sharmila Sharma and Meera ( 13 year, 12 year ) besides got enrolled.

Case Study2: A Case of Village Haripur
Village Haripur in the Bhagwanpur Block of District Haridwar is a Tongya small town situated amidst the woods. As per the regulations and ordinances of forest section no building can be erected in these forest small towns and hence there was no school edifice. Due to this more than 80 kids could non acquire proper primary instruction. APIL organized a GSS in this small town and got the community mobilized to demand for the rights of their kids. As a consequence the Education Department was compelled to build a school edifice in the adjoining small town land Buggawala. Now this school is in map.


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out