Criticism On Traditional Costing Accounting Essay

Johnson and Kaplan ( 1987 ) , the authors of Relevance Lost: The Rise and Fall of Management Accounting have addressed the jobs aroused from the application of Traditional Costing System ( afterlife, TCS ) . They proposed the usage of Activity-Based Costing ( afterlife, ABC ) as the solution to the TCS failings.

1.1 Criticism on Traditional Costing

The TCS as being criticized by the declared writers, is said to be giving incorrect signaled to the directors. As the effects, the directors wrongly promote the sale and enlargement of merchandises that do non lend much net income to the company. The chief unfavorable judgment is the TCS derived consequences in contrast than what it was supposed to be. For illustration, the system showed merchandise to be profitable when in world it is non ( Otley, 2008 ) .

We will write a custom essay sample on
Criticism On Traditional Costing Accounting Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

The TCS plants on by delegating the operating expense or disbursals to each merchandise, services or procedure based on the per centum of direct labour or stuff cost ( Narong, 2009 ) . This is chiefly where the job starts. As the indirect and operating expense disbursals maintain on increasing, the TCS failed to integrate the disbursals as they apportioned the cost towards the production volume instead than on the activities. For illustration, when the company bought-in merchandises, it might be regard as holding small or even no operating expense at all. The directors overlook the being of operating expense costs that might increase because of the bought-in for illustration, bill clerks and shopkeepers. The directors might bear down these costs on the bing merchandise where this will pull strings the pricing and net income of the bing merchandise subsequently on.

The TCS works closely with general leger ‘s chart of histories ( Narong, 2009 ) . Therefore, following the classification of the history ‘s chart, the disbursals are allocated. The directors can merely explicate the cost of labour, stuff and other nevertheless, they are unable to warrant whether the production procedure are effectual, profit-making or non. They are besides unable to clearly hold on the existent cost attached to the procedure as their position is limited merely to what is shown in histories chart.

2.0 Activity-Based Techniques

2.1 ABC

2.1.1 Explanation of ABC

The ABC was introduced in order to work out the trouble refering TCS. The chief issue here is how TCS continually shown misrepresented information to the directors which finally would take to wrong determination devising.

ABC led the directors to cipher the existent cost from the beginning to the terminal of the production procedure, something that could n’t be achieved by TCS. Baines ( 1992 ) stated that ABC is driven by the information on costs of the activities undertaken. Information needed can be collected utilizing such methods like historical analysis, inside informations of activities entering and studies. As the information needs to be collected on regular footing, ABC convinced the directors on uninterrupted betterment and accurate costing systems.

The footing of the technique works on by disaggregating overhead resources into activity cost pools and a figure of allotment bases. Once the allotment bases ( i.e. cost drivers ) have been identified, the entire cost of the activity will be divided by the activity degree of the allotment base. The entire operating expense charges derived from these activity cost pools will so be divided by one-year demand ; ( say in a signifier of batches ) to obtain the cost per unit. Due to the high degree of truth in geting the merchandise cost information, the merchandise cost derived by utilizing ABC, is more accurate than the traditional system.

2.1.2 Criticism of ABC

Kaplan and Anderson ( 2004 ) commented that the job of ABC happens due to the conventional application of the technique. The information aggregation thru study and entering footing may be suited for little scene ( like, a section, little mill or shop ) nevertheless it does non able to function the intent accurately on larger graduated table. See a company that holds 1000s of workers, to roll up informations, analyze and measuring the information would be clip devouring. As ABC requires the system to be updated on a regular basis, the rating of informations going more and more inaccurate as the clip base on ballss by for larger corporation. To analyse and roll uping the information, larger corporation may necessitate to engage excess workers who have the required cognition. This causes ABC to be regard as both clip and cost consuming. These failings have been acknowledged by both Kaplan and Anderson.

ABC involves high capacity of subjective information for illustration in placing activities, allotment bases, and sum consumed in each activities. Ray ( 2012 ) stated this as subjective arbitrary cost allotment. This will merely establish on the judgement made by the directors from the collected information. Data collected from staffs and clients may and may non be accurate, sing on how they answered the studies or inquiries asked. Ray besides stated that when there is a alteration in production volume, ABC does non able to foretell the hereafter returns, doing it inappropriate for decision-making.

2.1.3 Development of ABC

In 2003, Kaplan and Anderson introduced the Time-Driven Activity Based Costing ( afterlife, TDABC ) with the intent of get the better ofing the unfavorable judgments directed to the conventional ABC. This is chiefly refering the cost and troubles in implementing and retaining the theoretical account ( Gervais, Levant and Ducrocq, 2010 ) . TDABC is said to be a straightforward attack as the theoretical account merely necessitate to see the unit cost of used resources and the estimated clip to execute an activity.

The distinguishable advantages of this theoretical account is that it eliminates the demand to interview and long phases of delegating resources costs to activities before really able to delegate these resources to be objects. By extinguishing the long and item processs the company is able to salvage on their resources in footings of money and clip which is something that is difficult to carry through with conventional ABC.

As per the name suggest, TDABC uses clip equations to manage different type of orders that besides varies in the sum of clip taken to treat. Rather than utilizing separate activity to specify and manage each transactional activity the theoretical account suggests a simpler method ; the usage of clip criterions. All that it needs to be concern on is the criterions remain consistent with patterns and are on a regular basis updated. The clip equation is used in order to accurately find the sum of resources each group consumes. Let say that there is an extra demand of merchandises, the users of TDABC merely need to add the extra clip required to treat the order to the basic established equation. Due to this simplistic method, TDABC is much preferred as compared to conventional ABC.

2.2 Activity-Based Management ( ABM )

2.2.1 Explanation of ABM

As ABC measures the cost and public presentation of activities, ABM works on by supplying analysis towards the cost drivers, activity, public presentation direction ( Institute of Management Accountant, 1998 ) . Gupta and Galloway ( 2003 ) stated the motion of ABC to ABM really involved the shifting of cost-assignment position to treat direction position. Using information derived from ABC theoretical account, ABM concentrates on conveying and using the information in order to advance uninterrupted betterment and assisting the house in doing right determinations in both operating and strategic degree. What is interesting about ABM is that it is non merely provides public presentation measurings based on fiscal mentality, but besides on non-financial point of view.

Therefore, specifying public presentation steps of a company might differ from a rival in the same industry. Certain company would prefer to utilize non-financial facet as the whole public presentation step system, while others would concentrate on physical steps. What is of import here is to implement a step that does non merely concentrating on mensurating public presentation but besides provides controls, public presentation rating and motivates the workers. Correct execution of public presentation step helps the company to categorise non-value added activities. CIMA ( 2001 ) defined this as the activity that does non lending or making value to the house. Once identified, the company will concentrate and analyze on this activity to hunt for the critical causes. Finally, these causes will be eliminated.

2.2.2 Criticism of ABM

The issue arises here is that direction may necessitate multiple public presentation steps in order to be able to reflect activities of the company. Problems in placing the right steps might be one of ABM restrictions. This attack is instead subjective. Even after a step had been identified, how to measure this step in order to guarantee that it is right reflecting company ‘s aims?

2.3 Activity-Based Budgeting ( ABB )

2.3.1 Explanation of ABB

ABB focuses on making budget to help the activity-based theoretical account of an organisation. It involves structuring the organisation ‘s activities and procedures in line with analysis produced by ABM ( Neely, Bourne and Adams, 2003 ) . ABB chiefly will concentrate on operational budget followed by fiscal budget. This is known as the Closed Loop Model ( Hansen, Otley and Van der Stede, 2003 ) . In operational cringle phase, estimated demands are converted into activity demands utilizing the activity ingestion rate. This will so be converted into resource demand based on resource ingestion rate. Based on demands consumed, available resources ( such as workers ) will be assigned to carry through demands. During the fiscal cringle, cost assigned on resources, procedures and merchandises will be determined. This assignment will be based on the informations constructed by operational cringle. As such, fiscal balance is derived when the fiscal consequences lucifer with the predetermined informations.

Data accommodation may take topographic point in any one phase if the program leads to disagreements or instability. Hansen ( 2011 ) confirmed this statement in his recent work. He agreed that the flexibleness to respond to unexpected events ( for illustration sudden addition in demand ) is the most of import characteristics of ABB. The alone attack of ABB of sing operational budget foremost so fiscal budget helps it to convey the information and aims of the budget efficaciously to the employees. More significantly, inclusion of batch, installation and other related cost drivers makes it easier to observe inefficiencies and be after the budget system in a manner that it can turn to the jobs expeditiously.

2.3.2 Criticism of ABM

4.0 Decision


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out