Developing A Conceptual Framework Is An Impossible Possibility Accounting Essay

With the society altering and economic system development, a figure of states have enhanced common good cooperation. Meanwhile, the development of territorial economic system and planetary economic system has been accelerated. Accounting theory guides the development of economic system to some extent. In other word, the hunt for accounting rules or a general theory of accounting were get downing, and efforts to use scientific method and back uping methodological analysiss to accounting. ( Mathews & A ; Perera, 1996, p. 19 )

Tony Tinker who use the term “ extremist accounting ” as a label for his positions. He thinks theories are “ arms of societal struggle. ( David Solomons, 1991 ) Tinker gives his sentiment that accounting theory is non merely a realistic inactive public presentation, are besides the agent of altering world. Fringy socialist provide accounting a bias the world of the state of affairs. ( Tinker, 1985, p. 28 ) About the accounting of the societal function, he thinks accounting pattern besides helps consequence economic exchanges. Accounting statement are used in taging determinations. ( Tinker, 1985, pp. 83-84 ) Accounting has been changed that he as an informational trade good to promotes exchange. Even accounting has to responsible for the defects of economic system. However, David Solomons as a neutralist is non agree Tinker ‘s positions. He thinks that accounting must be neutrality in fiscal coverage. Although prefect neutrality may be hard to accomplish, if people stop looking for is really foolish. ( Solomons, 1991 )

We will write a custom essay sample on
Developing A Conceptual Framework Is An Impossible Possibility Accounting Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

Knowledge is the beginning of stuff, and memory, ground, testimony, self-contemplation, religion, perceptual experience and intuition besides affect the cognition. Furthermore, cognition could as the foundation of theory. The scientific discipline is really of import for develop theories. Scientific method is based upon some discrepancy of initiation. The most simplified signifier of the inductivist doctrine is that based on naif inductivism which based all scientific concluding upon observation. Navie inductivisim claims to be the footing of scientific discipline because observation and inductive logical thinking are nonsubjective and the consequence will be nonsubjective Torahs and theories had been found by Mathews & A ; Perera. ( 1996 cited in Chalmers, 1982, p.2 )

For farther apprehension of cognition, it leads us to recognize that the human bureau and the restrictions position by position are cardinal in the coevals of cognition. Our cognition can make no more than make a weak and instead uni-dimensional representation of that universe. Although accomplishments in engineering may convert us that we are much more knowing than we really are, our apprehension of cognition ever falls short in stand foring the world. ( Morgan, 1988 )

During the societal alteration and frequent economic activities, accounting may be extremist or suppression of societal and economic alteration. Accountants as information supplier to impact economic activities. Harmonizing to Solomons, he thinks that comptrollers can be called journalists, because they should describe the intelligence, non do it. ( Solomons, 1991 ) In add-on, there are many hard economic jobs that need planetary coordination and cooperation. For illustration, transnational companies to transport out economic activities ; planetary currency trade and consolidating international fiscal statement. Therefore, we need perfect accounting criterion and theory.

However, developing Conceptual Frameworks for Financial Accounting and Reporting is the requirement and foundation of international consistency of accounting criterions. Conceptual model is based on international consistency of accounting criterions to look.

‘ A coherent system of interconnected aims and basicss that can take to consistent criterions and that prescribes the nature, map, and bounds of fiscal accounting and fiscal statements ‘ ( FASB, 1976, p.2 )

As the planetary economic system developing, a figure of conceptual models ( CF ) have been built and completed in the USA, UK, Canada and Australia. The Financial Accounting Standards Board ( FASB ) in the United State, which developed one of the first CF in accounting, is a recent and major conceptual model in the universe. In footings of the resources devoted to it, and the length of clip over which this undertaking extended, the FASB ‘ s CF is possibly the major CF undertaking so far undertaken. ( RUTH D. HINES, 1991, page 313 )

The conceptual model for fiscal accounting is a graded and logical system that is composed of a series of explains fiscal accounting and the basic construct of fiscal accounting for the application. Furthermore, CF besides is to modulate and steer the accounting criterions of theoretical footing is a portion of accounting theory.

Because of development of economic and the market have evolved after the 1970s, traditional accounting theory inflicted serious impact and unfavorable judgment. It has to construct up a normative and incorporate conceptual model, which is suited for new economic state of affairs, to steer accounting standard, therefore work out bing accounting jobs which has ne’er involved by bing accounting criterions. From December 1976, FASB progress conceptual models for fiscal accounting and coverage foremost, and so them through a list of research and acquire some positive consequence.

Since FASB released “ the construct construction of fiscal accounting and coverage: Elementss of fiscal statements and its measuring ” in 1976. This is the first clip to proclaim CF and its relevant study. Other states start to look into and research the conceptual model and obtain some accomplishments. For this survey, China starts comparatively late, has non yet formed a more systematic accounting particular theoretical research system.

For the characteristic in different states, the characteristic of U.S CF can be summed up as the followers:

First, FASB foremost to develop CF and about all subsequent development in mainly states were affected by FASB. Second, there are about market value, historical cost appraisal, etc five measurings. Third, there are nine elements of fiscal coverage such as assets, liabilities, cost, etc. Fourthly, the ways and purposes of fiscal coverage. It is to supply serviceable information for economic decision-making. Last, dependability and relevancy as chief qualitative features of fiscal coverage.

The Accounting Principles Board was replaced by the FASB in 1973. After that FASB introduced the Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts ( SFACs ) which research conceptual model for fiscal coverage. There were seven fiscal studies published from 1978. The SFACs were really normative in inchoate phase. However, when FASB released the NO.6 SFACs, which point out its clear in the content of the paper: non merely applicable to endeavors, besides apply to nonprofit organisations, to replace NO.3 SFACs. The SFACs can non wholly suited for all the accounting criterions.

Furthermore, some other point of view every bit same as prove that SFACs non really suited for all accounting criterions. Such as, Nussbaumer ( 1992, page 238 ) said: aˆ¦ the issue of SFAC 5 ( Dec. 1984 ) marked the greatest letdown of the FASB ‘s undertaking for the CF. It did nil more than describe present pattern ; it was non normative at all. The acknowledgment and measuring issues, which the FASB promised to cover with in SFAC 5, were non settled, and measurement issue was sidestepped aˆ¦

In the same manner, harmonizing to Craig Deegan ( 2010, page 217 ) , Miller ( 1990 ) objected that the FASB conceptual model in accounting ab initio supplied much needed alteration to accounting. For case, SFAC NO.1 explicitly put fiscal study users ‘ demand at the head of consideration. However, when SFAC NO.5 was issued, ‘momentum was lost when FASB did non hold sufficient political will to confront down the counterreformation and endorse expanded usage of current values in the acknowledgment and measurement stage of the undertaking ‘ ( Miller, 1990, page 32 ) . All in all, FASB have to face a series of jobs to develop the conceptual model.

There are some different of the CF between the USA and the UK. A study had been issued by the Accounting Standards Steering Committee of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales ( ASSC ) in 1975. Although the study helps to put up the UK Government Green Paper which did non turn to jurisprudence, it had some of import influence in accounting patterns. In 1991, the UK Accounting Standards Board prepared a undertaking to develop a conceptual model. This undertaking is chiefly to convey into correspondence with FASB and IASC model.

The characteristic of UK conceptual models as follow:

First of all, true and just position is meats of fiscal coverage. Second, the fiscal studies were provided the economic decision-making information to users. Third, accounting and fiscal information are base for other entities. Fourthly, approximately qualitative features, when relevancy and dependability repel each other, so take the manner which can acquire max relevancy of information. Last, approximately historical cost system, current value and assorted measuring.

About the true and just position in accounting, there is no definition of it in accounting criterions, scrutinizing criterions or other professional dictums. No 1 knows what it means and really small academic analysis has been done on its function in accounting. ( Walton 1993 ) David Alexander said the beginnings of TFV. There are a figure of sum-ups and analyses of the history and literature of the true and just position in accounting in Chastney ( 1975 ) , Rutherford ( 1985 ) and Walton ( 1991 ) . Edey ( 1971 ) described true and just as ‘a term of art- a proficient term ‘ . The words ‘true and just ‘ are likely to mean that the histories give a true statement of aspects. aˆ¦ Associate ‘facts ‘ with ‘actual net income ‘ and ‘actual values ‘ . He does non recognize that ‘profit ‘ and ‘value ‘ are abstractions. aˆ¦a method of computation that could be followed in pattern. The true and just position has potentially a function to play in procuring the position of the profession. At a superficial degree, the true and just position is the overall aim of fiscal study.

There are some benefits of developing a CF harmonizing to Mathews & A ; Perera ( 1996, p. 108 ) , Chye ( 1984 ) has identified a CF for fiscal accounting as a necessary foundation for the development of a set of by and large accepted accounting criterions. First, CF can better the efficiency of puting accounting criterion and assist the FASB to salvage the clip. Second, conceptual model is general and normative, and it suited in any endeavors to work out jobs of accounting criterion. Third, CF have certain restraints to put accounting criterions. Last, utilizing a common set of fiscal cognition will increase the understanding and assurance in fiscal statements.

However, the impossibleness of developing a CF includes: set up and develop a CF is clip devouring and expensive. Peoples frequently found that some accounting theories in CF are non conforming to the existent state of affairs. CF provides excessively much counsel and some struggle between a CF and accounting criterions.

Solomon islandss ( 1991 ) as a neutralist provide some sentiments include: Accountants are similar journalists to describe intelligence, non do it. Accounting can impact societal exchange, but can non alter it. He besides states a contention that CF is a defence against political intervention by other involvement group. In other words, CF ‘s development is a political action.

In decision, development of accounting fiscal conceptual model was base on cognition, image and idea. Through analyze accounting jobs and sum uping the cognition, people build up the CF. accounting can assist users to work out and do determination with related fiscal jobs. The CF can supply the most effectual and direct theoretical and proficient support to put accounting criterions. Harmonizing to Deegan ‘s ( 2010 ) sentiment, the CF could give counsel when no suited and peculiar accounting criterions in being. Therefore, developing the conceptual model has a batch of jobs but it is inevitable to develop conceptual model.


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out