The aim of this paper is to research the responses of commercial Bankss sample informations on the consequence of concern procedure reengineering factors on organisational public presentation. Consequently, instruments cogency, dependability and so, the informations normalcy were examined through panel of expert in both academic and pattern. The sample of the informations received from the commercial bank sections was analyzed with assistance of SPSS package. The consequences show that the instruments are dependable and the information for preliminary survey demonstrate sensible normalcy. The research explored and validated the instrument of the assorted experiences of bank public presentation as a consequence of concern procedure reengineering factors implementation most of which factors were antecedently ignored.
Cardinal words: Factors of concern procedure reengineering, Information engineering capableness, Organizational public presentation, Banks, Pilot trial, Nigeria.
The progressive globalisation of fiscal markets required market participant to do alterations on their operational procedures beyond local competition to planetary fight. The full banking industry should concentrate on accomplishing service fight that would better their public presentation sweetening in both domestic and international market. Attempts by the Bankss on market cleavage resulted to re-direction of the fiscal services scheme for net income sweetening. Advanced baking service and personalized banking portifolio direction are germinating as the market consolidates due to amalgamations and acquisitions of Bankss and up-to-date scheme.
Performance betterment attempts are aimed at a complete realignment of internal and inter-department procedures. In contrast to the tendency in recent old ages, the focal point is no longer on cutting costs entirely, but instead on at the same time bettering ser- frailties to clients. Not merely must treat go more efficient, they must be made more customer-friendly as good. Attempts are being made to reassign attacks that have proven effectual in other industries, peculiarly fabrication, to the fiscal sector. Industrialization is the phrase for hiking public presentation by using industrial methods. The importance is to emphasize on the entire redesign of multi-functional procedures that deliver goods or services to the client and the system of measuring used to measure the public presentation systematically with the entire, socio-technical attack and the human factors approach to re-engineering upon which the construct of authorization is based ( Peppard, 1995 ) . Today ‘s companies operations requires best patterns, aimed at measuring themselves the extent to which they are following with their corporate aims. The company must concentrate its attempts on improved effectivity, by bettering client service, cut downing costs, and bettering its concern procedures ( Norris et al. 2001 ) . Performance measuring has become a cardinal tool for guaranting that, the different procedures that make up a company ‘s concern are kept on path, in order to measure both the efficaciousness and the operational efficiency of the concern processes.
The aim of the pilot survey is to acquire a feedback and usage to set and better informations aggregation of the larger survey every bit good as to accomplish the undermentioned specific intents:
To enable the research worker set up contact with organisations before the existent informations aggregation procedure of the chief survey
To find the cogency and dependability of the concepts
To anticipate any challenges that may originate during the chief survey informations aggregation.
A pre-test of the questionnaire was conducted in order to enable us to prove the dictions ; inquiry sequences of which format best suit the respondents and to alarm the research worker to possible jobs countries that may be caused by the questionnaire. Therefore, pre-tests are conducted to reply inquiries about questionnaire such as the followers: 1 ) Can the questionnaire format be followed by the respondent? 2 ) Does the questionnaire flow of course? 3 ) Can respondent reply the inquiry easy? 4 ) Which alternative signifiers of inquiries work best? Pre-testing besides provides the agencies to prove the sampling process, whether efficient or non. Therefore the benefit of carry oning a pre-test of questionnaire is to better the cogency and dependability of the instrument steps. Zikmund, ( 2000 ) highlighted the purpose of carry oning cogency as to guarantee that instrument measures what is supposed or intended to mensurate.
A pilot survey is considered to be like little experiment to prove the logistics and garnering information prior to the larger survey ( Gay, Mills and Airasian, 2006 ) . It is conducted in order to better the quality and efficiency of the larger survey. It is done to uncover lacks in the design of the proposed larger survey process that can be addressed before clip and resources are expended. Thus this will give the research worker to expect and set to possible jobs during the full graduated table research. Among the major concern of pilot trial is the instrument cogency and dependability. Validity of mensurating instrument is the extent to which the instrument is mensurating what it is suppose to mensurate while Reliability measures the extent, to which an instrument is error free, consistent and stable ( Sekaran & A ; Bougie, 2010 ) . Therefore the paper presents the consequence of pilot trial with respect to the cogency, dependability and preliminary probe on concern procedure reengineering execution in Nigerian Bankss.
Given the fact that this is a pilot survey of an on-going research, a few samples of Nigerian Bankss and fiscal establishment was indiscriminately selected. The sample size of a pilot survey is within a scope of few respondents ( 15-30 ) but can be increased well ( Malhotra, 2008 ) . Hence, a sum of 105 transcripts of questionnaire were personally distributed and 100 were returned out of which 3 were non decently completed and were non considered for analysis. Prior to the distribution of the questionnaire, the bill of exchange transcripts were ab initio submitted to experts both faculty members and professionals for face cogency and content cogency severally. Sekaran and Bougie ( 2010 ) argued that the most popular trial of point consistence dependability is Cronbach ‘s alpha coefficient. Hence, Cronbach ‘s alpha trial is employed in this survey to mensurate internal consistence dependability of the instrument. The information was analyzed utilizing SPSS version 14 for Windowss. The pilot trial procedure was completed within the period of four hebdomads.
Measurement of Variables and Instrumentation
Questionnaire is considered to be one of the most appropriate informations aggregation instrument for study research ( Askia, 1999 ) . Hence structured questionnaire, which consists of closed-ended inquiries, would be used. However, in order to guarantee the version of the questionnaire is done decently, the research worker had conducted face cogency before a pilot trial of the instrument. The altered questionnaire would mensurate the influence of the research independent variables: BPR factors – alteration direction ; I.T substructure ; processes redesign, with a chairing factor of information engineering ( I.T ) capableness and dependant variable – organisational public presentation ( Financial and not fiscal ) . The five-point type evaluation graduated table was used in mensurating responses to the inquiries. Five-point evaluation graduated table indicates that interviewer prejudice tends to diminish and informations quality tends to increase. The center on the graduated table gives answering independency and opportunity of showing their positions ( Krosnick & A ; Fabrigar, 1997 ) . Many literatures found that graduated table between 5 to 7 points were more dependable and valid than shorter or longer graduated tables ( Krosnick & A ; Fabrigar, 1997 ) . However, Dawis, ( 1987 ) ; Garland ( 1991 ) ; and Hughes, ( 1969 ) suggested that the determination lays mostly on the penchant of the research worker and there can be no individual best method in scale building, one may be better for one research job but non be good for another.
The cardinal variables contained in the survey are: Change direction ; Process redesign ( Innovation ) ; Use of Information engineering ( I.T ) substructure ; and organisational public presentation. All the construct/variables are uni-dimensional except the alteration direction and I.T capableness which are multidimensional and were measured harmonizing. The questionnaire designed in this survey consists of six ( 4 ) chief subdivisions. Sections 1 are the demographic informations holding five ( 5 ) inquiries that required the respondent to supply background information and type of BPR execution in the organisation. Sections 2 are the independent variables consisted of 30 one ( 31 ) statements about BPR factors. Section 3 are the chairing variable I.T Capability consist of 30 ( 30 ) statement about the association of IT capableness with superior public presentation. Section 4 of the questionnaire is the dependent variables consist of 20 ( 20 ) inquiries sing organisational public presentation in footings of both fiscal and non fiscal.
Consequences of Validity and Reliability Trials
Reliability trial: there are assorted types of dependability trial ; the most common method used in many surveies is internal consistence dependability ( Litwin, 1995 ) . Cronbach ‘s alpha was the common trial employed in the old surveies to prove the internal consistence dependability. The Cronbach ‘s coefficient alpha trial was conducted to mensurate the internal consistence dependability. It stated that an instrument, that scores 0.60 is considered to hold an mean dependability criterion, while a mark of 0.70 and above indicates that the instrument have high dependability criterion ( Hair, Anderson, Tatham, & A ; Black, 1998 ; Sekaran, 2003 ) . ) . A pilot survey was conducted and the consequence of the survey is summarized in the tabular array 1.0 below:
Summary of the dependability analysis of concept
Seven ( 7 )
One ( 1 )
One ( 1 )
Five ( 5 )
Two ( 2 )
To measure the dependability of the concept, the mean correlativity ( Cronbach ‘s alpha ) in the graduated table was used. The cut off point of 0.70 was applied as the footing of credence. The ground is that, in general, reliabilities less than 0.60 was considered to be hapless, those in the scope of 0.70 are acceptable and those over 0.80 are good ( Sekaran, 2000 ) . Cronbach ‘s alpha can be considered as a absolutely equal indicant of the internal consistence, and therefore of dependability ( Sekaran, 2000 ) . It is the mostly by and large applied index. The by and large agreed upon most acceptable value for Cronbach ‘s alpha is 0.70, although it may diminish to 0.60 in explorative research ( Hair et al. 2007 ) . The consequences of pilot trial show that the Cronbach ‘s alpha of the concept ranges from 0.825 to 0.920. Since the consequence of the dependability was more than 0.70, none of the points was dropped from this pilot survey. Furthermore, dependability analysis would be performed during the chief survey for a larger sample size.
In add-on to accomplishing the dependability, cogency normalcy of the informations, the preliminary ( pilot ) probe was conducted to determine the degree of concern procedure reengineering ( BPR ) execution in Nigerian Bankss. Analysis of questionnaire demographic subdivision sing the inquiry on the attempts of Nigerian Bankss execution of assorted reengineering operational procedures in station consolidation period revealed the consequences shown in the tabular array 2.0
Summary of consequences on re-engineered operational procedures by Nigerian Bankss
In Percentage as at 2010
TYPES OF BPR Processes
BPR1: Recognition Risk operations procedures:
BPR2: Domestic operations procedures:
BPR3: International operations processes: Valid: Yes
BPR4: Branch operations procedures:
BPR5: e- Banking procedures:
Beginning: Developed for this research
The consequence indicated that the sample Bankss in Nigeria had implemented concern procedure reengineering on the assorted procedures: 78 per centum of the Bankss implemented the related to electronic banking services such operational minutess of cash/cheques received and payment through ATM, POS, cards dealing and others ; 67 per centum of the Bankss studied have restructured and improved their operational procedures as a consequence of the synergisms of the consolidation of Bankss operational services streamline for efficient and effectual service bringing ; 61 per centum of the respondent reengineered their recognition hazard operational procedures of loan procedures, consumer loan assessment analysis, expense, disposal and rendering of periodic returns to the regulative authorization was restructured utilizing information engineering package ; while, 50.5 per centum of the respondent confirmed to hold redesign their domestic and international operational procedures of minutess severally. The restructuring of the local and internal operational procedures involved some sort of inventions and value added services to the assorted procedures such as check glade and colony, interbank transportations, remittals for payment of measures, fund transportations both local and international payment through Money Gram, Western Union Money transportation, Wire transportation through SWIFT and gap of missive of recognition.
The Central bank of Nigeria audited one-year history and study CBN, 2008 revealed that Nigerian Bankss have successfully reengineered their operational service by deployment of assorted electronic banking channels including the globally unafraid bit and pin engineering, point-of-sale ( POS ) and cyberspace banking services. The e-payment skyline grew further in twelvemonth 2008 as all its service sections recorded important betterments. The development was traceable to a figure of factors, including: 1 ) the deployment of more ATMs by the Bankss, 2 ) the acceptance of majority salary payments by many establishments, 3 ) an increased use of debit cards and increased public consciousness. POS minutess increased in both volume and value footings by 150.2 per cent, severally. The growing of this section of the market was attributable to the addition in the figure of establishments and merchandisers utilizing the POS web for services, such as lottery tickets, airtime peddling, measure payments, and financess transfer, among others. In the same vena, the figure and value of payments through the nomadic telephone in 2008 improved by 630.3 per cent. The development was due to the addition in the figure of Bankss offering the service, every bit good as the turning public assurance in e-payments. Web based ( cyberspace ) minutess increased significantly in volume and value footings by 77.3 and 135.8 per cent as a consequence of the addition in the figure of Bankss offering the service. The figure of merchandisers accepting such payments over clip had improved both in efficiency and security as there have been immense investings by Bankss in their e-business sections. The e-banking section has witnessed enormous growing in all payment channels ( cyberspace, nomadic banking, ATM and telephone banking ) presently in usage as is apparent in the figure of ATMs and POS machines deployed over 8,000 and 12,400 machines severally. The use and credence of these channels of payment will go on to increase across the state. The e-banking platforms have delivered increased profitableness, improved client trueness, enhanced capacity of bing merchandises and improved visibleness to the Bankss who are puting to a great extent in them.
Data Distribution: Most of the illative statistical techniques require the fulfillment of normalcy premise ( Pallant, 2001 ; Tabacknich & A ; Fidell, 2007 ) . Normal information is the 1 that is symmetrically bell-shape with the greatest frequence mark in the center and a smaller distribution on the utmost terminals. Normality can be observed by utilizing value of lopsidedness and kurtosis. The informations normalcy can be indicated by the value of lopsidedness and kurtosis. Skewness has to make with regularity of a distribution, symmetrically form and kurtosis related to degree of peakedness of the distribution ( Tabacknich & A ; Fidell, 2007 ) . A distribution is said to normal when the values of lopsidedness and kurtosis are equal to zero ( Tabacknich & A ; Fidell, 2007 ) . Many writers suggested that absolute values of uni-variate lopsidedness greater than 3.0 seem to depict highly skewed informations ( Chou & A ; Bentler, 1995 ) .The value for the lopsidedness of all the concept is between -0.570 to +0.047 ; kurtosis values range from -0.434 to +0.629 and Statistical scope of the concept between +9.20 to +51.0.
The chief intent of pilot trial survey is to look into the dependability and cogency of the instrument of an on-going research before beginning of the full graduated table survey. Therefore, the decision of this survey is to procure the statistical aims at this phase. The practical and theoretical parts of the variables would be reveled after the chief survey is conducted. The pilot survey trade with the content and face cogency of the instrument that led to paraphrasing of some points and aggregation of few samples for dependability analysis. The dependability analysis consequences indicated that the Cronbach ‘s Alpha of all the concepts were above the bench grade of 0.70. Besides, the normalcy trial utilizing lopsidedness and kurtosis indicates that the information is moderately normal.
Askia, N. ( 1999 ) . Research methodological analysis in the behavioural scientific disciplines. Lagos: Longman Nigeria Plc, Nigeria.
Babbie, E. ( 1990 ) . Survey research methods. California: Wad worth Publishing.
.CBN. ( 2008 ) . Central Bank of Nigeria Annual Report and Account every bit at 31st December. Capital of nigeria: Central Bank of Nigeria.
Dawis, R. V. ( 1987 ) . Scale building. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 34 ( 4 ) , 481-489.
Garland, R. ( 1991 ) . The center on a evaluation graduated table: Is it desirable? Marketing Bulletin, 2 ( may ) ( 66-70 ) .
Gay, L.R. , Mills, G.E. , & A ; Airasian, P. ( 2006 ) . Education research: Competences for analysis and applications ( 8th ed. ) . Upper berths saddle River, New Jersey: Pearson Education International, Inc.
Hair, J. F. , Black, W. C. , Babin, B. J. , Anderson, R. E. , & A ; Tatham, R. L. ( 2006 ) . Multivariate informations analysis ( Vol. 7 edition ) . New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Hughes, G. D. ( 1969 ) . Some confusing consequence of forced-choice graduated tables. Journal of Marketing Research, VI ( May ) ( 223-226 ) .
Krosnick, J. A. , & A ; Fabrigar, L. R. ( 1997 ) . Planing evaluation graduated tables for effectual measuring in studies. In L. Lyberg, P. Biemer, M. Collins, E. De Leeuw, C. Dippo, N. Schwarz & A ; D. Trewin ( Eds. ) , Survey measuring and procedure quality. New York: John Wiley & A ; boies, Inc.
Litwin, M.S ( 1995 ) . How to mensurate study dependability and cogency. Thousand Oaks, California: Sage Publication
Malhotra, N.K. ( 2008 ) . Necessities of selling: An applied orientation ( 2nd ed. ) . Australian: Pearson Education.
Niessink, Clerc and new wave Vliet ( 2004 ) , The IT Service Capability Maturity Model, retrieved March 24, 2004 from hypertext transfer protocol: //www.itservicecmm.org.
Norris et Al. 2001
Pallant, J. ( 2001 ) . SPSS survival manual: A measure by usher to data analysis utilizing SPSS for Windowss. Maidenhead, UK: Open University Press.
Peppard, J. ( 1996 ) . Broadening visions of concern procedure re-engineering. Omega, 24 ( 3 ) , 255-270.
Sekaran, U. ( 2000 ) . Research methods for concern ( 3ed ) . New York: New York: John Wiley & A ; Sons, Inc.
Sekaran, U. & A ; Bougie, R. ( 2010 ) . Research methods for concern: A accomplishment edifice attacks ( 5th ed. ) . Chichester: toilet Willey & A ; Sons Ltd
Tabacknich, B.G. & A ; Fidell, L.S. ( 2007 ) . Using multivariate statistics ( 5th ed. ) . Boston: Pearson Education Inc.
Zikmund, G. W. ( 2000 ) . Business research methods: 7th erectile dysfunction.