Exploring links between education and ethical maturity in accountants Essay

The work of Gray et Al ( 1994 p.51 ) refering the nexus between accounting instruction and ethical adulthood focuses preponderantly on the ethical and rational failures that occur amongst established accounting practicians. The literature suggests that a important factor responsible for such failures is the inability of methodological analysiss and techniques within modern-day accounting instruction to provide comptrollers with the necessary rational and ethical adulthood to map in the existent universe. This amounts to proposing that whilst accounting instruction provides accounting pupils with a thorough cognition of interventions and calculating techniques, small lucidity is assigned as to how persons should react in state of affairss which may take to the creative activity of contention. In the instance of Enron which has frequently been cited as the largest audit failure in recent history ( Bratton, 2002, P.61 ) , it could be suggested that while Arthur Andersen as the hearers carefully followed technically precise accounting processs, ethical adulthood was clearly missing taking to the use of sound processs to misdirect investors. Gray et Al. ( 1994, p.51 ) propose that the solution to such jobs exists within societal and environmental accounting nevertheless, the nature of this statement is non supported with the presence of conclusive grounds. As a consequence, this work will concentrate upon the specific nature of moralss and ethical adulthood ; the interaction between moralss and accounting ; and the possible hereafter developments in accounting instruction that could help new alumnuss in going more ethically witting.

Over the past decennary, a rush in both involvement and investing in developing moral instruction plans has occurred in the purpose of easing the feature of moral opinion. Moral judgement concerns how people define one or another class of action in a state of affairs as morally right ( Schlaefli et al, 1985, P. 319. ) Moral opinion as suggested by the work of Kohlberg ( 1969 ) and Piaget ( 1965 ) has been shaped and has evolved through the development and apprehension of justness, and as this degree of cognition deepens, an persons ‘ method of measuring a state of affairs will alter. Institutional pedagogues who believe in the ethos of such theories have aided the sequence of moral opinion development by offering legion educational experiences. Surveies that have reviewed moral instruction plans ( Enright, Lapsley, & A ; Levy, 1983 ) have indicated that such plans are influential in the publicity and development of moral opinion. The work developed by Kohlberg ( 1969 ) entitled the ‘theory of moral development ‘ suggested a phase sequence theoretical account, which defined a series of concluding degrees and development phases ( Ponemon, 1993, p. 187 ) . The theoretical account was responsible for suggesting that persons will come on upwards through three sustained degrees. The initial degree was termed “ pre-conventional morality ” , with patterned advance to the 2nd degree termed “ conventional morality ” and so eventually to the 3rd phase of “ post-conventional morality ” ( Kohlberg, 1984, p. 824 – 839 ) . Since the formation of the above phase sequence theoretical account, a figure of research workers have attempted to build reliable psychometric instruments to measure an persons ‘ degree of ethical logical thinking ( Colby and Kohlberg, 1987 ; Rest 1979a ) . Based upon these concepts, surveies have examined accounting professionals in footings of ethical and moral development. An illustration of such work is that of Ponemon ( 1990 ) who carried out a cross-sectional and longitudinal survey, reasoning a strong negative nexus between comptrollers ‘ place within the house and the degree of ethical logical thinking possessed. The findings suggest that “ differences in ethical behavior are likely to reflect differences in socialization ; therefore different places in a house ‘s hierarchy are likely to breed different ethical propensities ” ( Ponemon, 1990, p. 206 ) . This was further enhanced with the suggestion that “ ethical values that are encouraged by the CPA are inconsistent with higher degrees of ethical logical thinking ” . It may hence be inferred from this that degree of ethical development within those that enter the accounting profession is hindered ( Ponemon 1990 ) . An account provided to warrant this decision is that moral development topographic points far excessively much of a strain on present accounting instruction techniques for pupils. A solution therefore proposed is that ethical instruction within accounting should be substituted by “ formal classs and advocates that foster the highest degree of ethical logical thinking ” ( Ponemon, 1992a, p. 32 ) .

We will write a custom essay sample on
Exploring links between education and ethical maturity in accountants Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

Despite these findings nevertheless, the individualism of each pupil may be overlooked. In conformity with the theories established by Kohlberg ( 1969 ) , some pupils may possess an ethical duty to their fellow equals or educational establishment and as a effect will take to collaborate ignoring the economic inducements to make so otherwise. The moral development by pupils may nevertheless be more intricate than suggested by Kohlberg ( 1969 ) as demonstrated by the theoretical account of moralss and morality as formed by Rest ( 1979, p.18 ) . The footing of this theoretical account rested on the impression that ethical behavior was comprised of four characteristic psychological procedures. This included: moral sensitiveness ; moral opinion ; moral motive and moral character. Moral sensitiveness is concerned with the reading of a state of affairs and the consciousness sing relevant moral factors and there possible deductions. This peculiar concept besides analyses the consequence of assorted possible actions and the consequence that such actions would hold on the relevant parties involved. Moral judgement entails contemplation in respects to the assorted possibilities relevant to different classs of action and doing a judgement sing which of the available actions would be the most morally justifiable. The concept of moral motive incorporates the prioritisation of peculiar moral values over other straight viing concerns whilst taking duty for the result that arises from taking the moral class of action. Finally, moral character is the schemes that aid moral pick and includes characterological temperaments that engender effectual action ( Walker, 1953, p.553 ) . Most of the accounting ordinances to day of the month hold had the inclination to concentrate strongly on moral opinion and moral motive and therefore provides the footing of most accounting instruction course of study. The logical thinking cited behind this is that if comptrollers can be given an absolute graduated table on which to judge morality, combined with the appropriate motive to make the right thing for the investors that rely on them, so they will hold the ability to act ethically. This is nevertheless criticised by Chan and Leung ( 2006, p.436 ) proposing that moral character and moral sensitiveness, which are merely as important in ethical behavior are ignored. Moral sensitiveness in peculiar is important when comptrollers are runing in environments that may take to the creative activity of complex or controversial fortunes. Indeed, Chang and Leung ( 2006, p. 436 ) confirmed that accounting pupils possessing a strong degree of both moral and ethical sensitiveness were better placed to place ethical issues and sort the cardinal ethical quandary they were presented with. This research is besides responsible for foregrounding the nature of intercessions within accounting moralss as a agency of heightening moral and ethical sensitiveness and therefore ethical adulthood. The deduction therefore is that the nexus between accounting instruction and ethical behavior constructs as defined by Rest ( 1979, p.18 ) are strong.

Another ethical conceptualization that is of important importance in seeking to understand the nature of moralss and ethical adulthood within accounting is Pincoffs ( 1986 ) work on the virtuousness theory. This peculiar work provides the suggestion that virtuousnesss are attributes that provide hardy evidences on which to establish ethical opinions, and therefore specify the set of criterions that govern ethical behavior. In conformity with Mintz ( 1995, p.247 ) , despite the nature of accounting itself being both conceptually impersonal and nonsubjective, the demand for virtuousnesss and ethical adulthood is important due to the possible client and commercial force per unit areas that are capable of making a struggle of involvement for the comptroller. In order to abstain from such struggles of involvement whilst keeping the ability to concentrate attending on the duty towards investors and the populace, comptrollers require several virtuousnesss including honestness, nonpartisanship, unity, dependability, fidelity and trustiness. These virtuousnesss are nevertheless improbable to be adopted one time the history is qualified and leaves the schoolroom, with professional houses puting greater accent on obtaining and maintaining clients instead than the rigorous conformity with ethical virtuousnesss. As such, an accounting house will frequently back up an person who chooses to do an ethical determination that may trouble a client but will non actively promote them to make so. Unless comptrollers hence learn the virtuousnesss required within a schoolroom environment, they are improbable to of all time larn them at all.

Buchan ‘s ( 2005, p.165 ) supports the instance further for the importance of ethical behavior and ethical adulthood amongst comptrollers with the treatment of the theory of planned behavior and its impact on the behavior of comptrollers. The consequences of this literature signify that the attitudes, subjective norms and moral sensitiveness of comptrollers had a strong influence on their response to ethical quandary experienced during their line of work. in peculiar, the attitudes of the comptroller in respects to the importance of moralss had a important impact on both their ethical and behavioral connotations. Accountants who possessed an attitude that placed moralss as a comparatively minor concern were far less likely to do objectively ethical determinations in comparing to those who viewed moralss as a cardinal portion of accounting. This once more emphasises that even in a notionally nonsubjective and impersonal profession such as accounting, the attitudes and subjective norms possessed by comptrollers are extremely of import in guaranting that efficient determination devising is happening. In add-on, the importance of moral sensitiveness helps to back up the consequences of Chang and Leung ( 2006, p.436 ) , and lends support to Gray et Al ( 1994, p.51 ) environing the importance of ethical adulthood for comptrollers.

These theoretical statements environing the importance of moralss and ethical adulthood for comptrollers is favoured by Eynon et Al ‘s ( 1997, p.1297 ) empirical findings environing “ the demand to keep the public trust in the unity of the accounting profession ” . More specifically, Eynon ‘s et Al ‘s ( 1997 p.1297 ) study of practising comptrollers illustrated that comptrollers require the demand for a high degree of moral concluding abilities in order to be effectual. Such moral concluding abilities can be seen as a combination of the moral opinion and moral sensitiveness abilities in Rest ‘s ( 1979, p.18 ) theoretical account of both moral and ethical development. Eynon et Al. ( 1997, p.1297 ) besides demonstrated that many accounting practicians and peculiarly those working in little houses had lower moral concluding abilities than could be expected for other professionals. Furthermore, the literature besides showed a direct nexus between the completion of moralss classs at universities ( and other larning environments ) and the deepness of moral development and ability possessed by the comptrollers. This in combination with grounds in respects to the importance of ethical adulthood leads us to oppugn why accounting classs do non include compulsory ethical preparation for all prospective comptrollers.

The reply to this may be seen in Baker ‘s ( 2006, p.663 ) treatment in respects to some of the key footings that are used in accounting including constructs such as “ economic world ” and “ impersonal representation ” . These peculiar constructs mentioned are cardinal to the attack taken by most recognized criterion puting establishments including the International Accounting Standards Board and the Financial Accounting Standards Board. Their peculiar stance suggests that fiscal histories should offer a impersonal illustration of the existent and nonsubjective economic world that an administration may happen itself in when it is fixing the histories. This nevertheless fails to detect that the impression of economic world is in itself extremely subjective with diverse investors sing a company ‘s economic state of affairs in many different ways. Indeed, Baker ( 2006, p.263 ) argues that presently used economic based accounting ordinances are frequently implemented utilizing a subjective logical thinking by the standard scene organic structures, depending on what they see as their regulative intent. This may go forth comptrollers in places when a company is following the missive of the accounting criterions, but arguably scoffing their spirit.

This issue suggested above does non look to be a recent manifestation, but instead appears to be an result of the determination by the IASB to ‘professionalise ‘ accounting around the universe ( McKinnon and Janell, 1984, p 19 ) . As a portion of this, the International Accounting Standards Board has continued to seek to harmonize planetary accounting ordinances and create planetary, nonsubjective and impersonal methods of accounting, leting for the greater comparing of investings across states. In the purpose of making professionalization within accounting, both the criterion compositors and accounting establishments have continuously argued the instance for functioning the public involvement and behaving in a mode that is both ethical and impartial in their activities. These claims are nevertheless slightly undermined by “ the educational procedures and the socialization experiences of consecutive coevalss of comptrollers who are non encouraged to reflect upon the profession ‘s societal duties ” ( puxty et Al, 1994, p.77 ) . More specifically, most sanctioned classs within accounting and the text editions used to help the acquisition within these classs fail to explicitly see the ethical duties of comptrollers, and tend towards merely automatically following the recognized ethical guidelines without inquiry. Harmonizing to Puxty et Al ( 1994, p. 77 ) this attack taken towards accounting instruction fails to supply accounting pupils with the necessary grade of ethical adulthood to truly justice complex state of affairss that fail to suit exactly into the agreed guidelines.

In add-on to this, Sikka et Al. ( 2007, p. 3 ) note that the standard scene organic structures have been slow to react to the assorted figure of corporate dirts, such as WorldCom and Enron, proposing that comptrollers can play a extremely partizan function within some companies. The failure to adequately educate pupils around the importance of moralss and societal duty means that standard compositors fail to present on their promise, and their ethical duty to function the populace involvements ( Needles, 1989, p. 23 ) . Sikka et Al. ( 2007, p. 3 ) claim that this is mostly in portion due to the failure of present accounting instruction and accounting patterns to travel beyond the comparatively dry proficient and instrumental position of accounting. This implies that a new signifier of accounting instruction is required that is based on constructs and theories within societal accounting in order to bring forth ethically and socially brooding comptrollers.

The statement proposed above has been recognised by a figure of writers and has received a degree of much greater exposure in mainstream accounting literature following the prostration of Enron and its hearers, Arthur Andersen. Molyneaux ( 2004, p. 385 ) discussed the assorted possible methods in which moralss and morality could be successfully integrated into accounting instruction in order to supply comptrollers with the necessary degree of ethical adulthood to avoid these jobs in the hereafter. The treatment by Molyneaux ( 2004 ) specifically focuses attending on the demand to incorporate ethical instructions into the full class, instead than the add-on of a standalone moralss class to bing course of study, which would give the feeling that moralss is somehow optional or does non play every bit much a cardinal portion as the proficient facets within accounting.

It is deserving observing nevertheless that the IASB and the International Accounting Education Standards Board, IAESB, have started to do advancement within this country. Their accomplishments to day of the month are nevertheless slightly limited, with the chief focal point being on the release of assorted information documents and advisory paperss that are intended to excite argument on the inclusion of ethical considerations and classs in the current accounting course of study ( Cooper et Al, 2008, p. 405 ) . This must be considered as an of import measure to take and provides grounds that the inclusion of ethical considerations is a must within accounting instruction in order to make effectual and ethically mature comptrollers. Failure nevertheless exists with the insufficiency in turn toing the cardinal job environing the deficiency of integrating bing between the proficient and the ethical sides of accounting.

Another cardinal issue that is impeding the inclusion of moralss in accounting course of study and besides forestalling the development of societal accounting instruction methods is the deficiency of nonsubjective resources that accounting talks and pedagogues are able to give to including moralss in their accounting classs ( Frank et al, 2010, p. 132 ) . As the instruction of moralss do non organize a necessary demand in most accounting classs, most establishments fail to hold professors dedicated to learning this peculiar country, taking to discrepancies in learning on a class by class footing. Despite the huge array of exemplifying stuff that is available for professors who wish for the inclusion of moralss within their classs, the deficiency of uniformity makes it harder for the profession as a whole to develop a certain degree of ethical criterions. This arguably creates an about round job in which the deficiency of ethical consciousness amongst accounting alumnuss hinders the development of sufficient impulse to hold in what ethical subjects and considerations should be integrated throughout the course of study.

Indeed, Jennings ( 2004, p. 7 ) argues that the move towards societal accounting is the lone method of supplying the ethical adulthood and consciousness required to forestall against the return of the corporate dirts witnessed. This is based upon the claim that without a strong ethical instruction, both comptrollers and hearers will be unwilling to dispute inaccuracies in describing determinations and unjust readings of companies. Jennings ( 2004, p.7 ) furthers this by proposing that there is no demand for any greater hold to be, given the sufficient volumes of stuff on societal accounting that could be utilised for the creative activity of societal accounting preparation classs. As discussed supra, every bit shortly as such classs become implemented, they will go self reenforcing as fresh alumnuss come ining the workplace will non merely back up their spread but will besides go presentations of their effectivity. It may hence be inferred that what is required is for a standard scene organic structure, authorities or legislative authorization to do a move towards societal accounting instruction. Once such a move has been made, the construct will garner impulse and will accordingly go the new accounting criterion.

In decision, the grounds listed clearly supports the statement provided by Gray et Al. ( 1994 ) in respects to the links between accounting instruction and the ethical adulthood possessed by comptrollers. This nexus has been clearly demonstrated through the three separate theoretical accounts and theories identified: Rest ‘s ( 1979 p. 18 ) theoretical account on moral and ethical development ; Pincoffs ( 1986 ) work on virtuousness theory and Buchan ‘s ( 2005 ) treatment implementing the theory of planned behavior. All of these peculiar attacks lead to the indicant that comptrollers must develop their degree of ethical adulthood in order to be successful, with full ethical adulthood merely happening when ethical constructs are included within the accounting course of study. Unfortunately nevertheless, the literature besides highlights that the on-going “ professionalization ” that is happening within accounting combined with the pursuit for impersonal representations of economic world are forestalling the inclusion of moralss within accounting instruction. Furthermore, this adds to the hazard of accounting crisis. It appears that societal accounting is a extremely relevant method when it comes to raising the degree of ethical consciousness and could accordingly work out many of the jobs that are associated with the deficiency of ethical adulthood amongst comptrollers. In add-on to this, the ego reenforcing nature of societal accounting instruction could assist it to distribute really rapidly once it has been officially introduced. Unfortunately nevertheless, in malice of the turning degree of demand by faculty members and practicians, there are still small or no marks of any efforts to follow societal accounting, nor of any important efforts to include ethical considerations in formal accounting course of study.


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out