Fat Talk: What Girls and Their Parents Say About Dieting Essay

Fat Talk: What Girls and Their Parents Say About Dieting

About all misss in their teenage old ages detest their organic structures and diet enthusiastically. The focal point of the book Fat Talk leads the individual who is reading or the one conducting probe to believe of the endurance of misss, supplying attacks into how their parents have a treatment with them sing their transforming organic structures. Black miss ever have a high respect for their mother’s powers in take a firm standing on taking the right diets while on the other side white misss portray their female parents single fat confab, male parents painful badgering and the mode in which their female parents at times go on a diet together to fly the household annoyance, loose thighs every bit good as full hips. Most misss evade repasts to avoid weight addition that their parents find incorrect. For several decennaries, adult females have viewed themselves contrary to what people expect of themselves. Rather than adult females sing themselves as couples or spouses to the work forces, adult females view themselves in footings of their gender or as physical objects. They are much concerned about their sexual visual aspect as they seek to fulfill the self-importance of their male opposite numbers. Therefore, they define themselves harmonizing to their sexual or physical characteristics. They have resulted into taking steps of seeking to cut down their sizes as they aim at accomplishing the theoretical account size considered best by many. The reappraisal of this book will delve much deeper in discoursing about what misss and parents feel about dieting and the organic structure as a societal object.

We will write a custom essay sample on
Fat Talk: What Girls and Their Parents Say About Dieting Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

The book starts out as an debut of the three old ages study that Mimi Nichter conducted following about 100s of adolescent misss. Nichter, a medical anthropologist, studied the discourse of dieting among adolescent misss in Tucson, Arizona. She explains in her book why she uses misss as the focal point of her survey and she brings about facts and statistics to discredit the populace of the images that misss are obsessional dieters that are generated by civilization and media. She used a diverse sample of misss from different cultural background ; 70 % Anglo, 10 % Latina, 5 % African American, Asian, and Native American, but the last 15 % did non give their ethnicity ( Nichter, 2000 ) . Nichter besides took her survey, interviewed many female parents of teenage misss, and describes the household influence. Nichter goes on and state the narrative of many adult females who speak of their female friends in respects to their weight. She so comes to the decision that weight to these adult females defines your beauty and beauty is a trade good ( Nichter, 2000 ) . If a adult female does non see herself beautiful so she will non be able to pull a mate and organize a relationship. Therefore, it was no surprise to Nichter when 50 % of the misss interviewed viewed themselves as corpulence. Nichter so, through many in-depth interviews on dieting in adolescent misss, comes up with the decision that dieting like any other facet of “being teenager” is an experimental procedure and these misss do non really watch their thermal consumption ( Nichter, 2000 ) .

Nichter so attempts to see household as a context for organic structure image. She explores the impact that parents and siblings have on these misss in respects to their self-image. She shows that much of which the misss learn and take in approximately organic structure image comes from inside their place. For illustration, when a girl’s female parent begins to speak about her “fat talks” , her dissatisfaction with her weight and the manner she looks, in forepart of her girl, the girl so learns those things from the female parent and begins to hold a negative organic structure image about herself ( Nichter, 2000 ) . However, female parents are non the lone 1s to fault. Fathers of these misss, merely every bit much as theirs female parents, can hold a sedate impact on the lives of their girls. If a girl’s male parent makes a negative comment about her female parent or her organic structure image so that miss so goes the remainder of her life thought she is unattractive ( Nichter, 2000 ) . This goes back to the thought of being able to pull a mate. In the book, one of the misss Nichter interviews goes to speak about how her male parent separated from her female parent merely because she was non externally attractive anymore ( Nichter, 2000 ) . This takes a great toll on misss and their perceptual experience of self-image and parents need to be cognizant of the consequence that it has on their girls.

Another of import construct Nichter found was how different cultural backgrounds influenced stripling organic structure image. As noted in the beginning, Nichter studied about 5 % of African American and Native American misss. The African American misss that she interviewed had a more positive organic structure image than the Anglo misss did. The African American misss perspective on dieting and “fat talks” is different from that of the white misss in that they because their female parents teach them organic structure positive ideal so they grow up to be more satisfied with their visual aspects ( Nichter, 2000 ) . Near the terminal of the book, Nichter tries to raise some consciousness of the media’s influence of beauty, and to assist advance healthy feeding and more activities among high school misss ( Nichter, 2000 ) . Although Nichter provides some suggestions on advancing organic structure positive images and behaviours, it is really limited as to what she suggests to these misss parents.

Given the context of Mimi Nichter’s book, Fat Talk: What Girls and Their Parents Say About Dieting, and if I were to put it into one of the theoretical subdivisions of medical anthropology I would put it in interpretive/ significance centered anthropology. I placed this book in interpretative because with interpretative anthropology it centers its attending on the experiences of those who are perceived agony and focal points on personal histories of the sick persons ( talk, 2015 ) . This field of anthropology focal points largely on single experiences that Nichter references in her book when she interviews the misss about themselves and their households. Interpretive medical anthropology besides surveies how medical beliefs and behaviours create a system for pass oning and sing significance in life ( Lecture, 2015 ) . Throughout the book, Nichter shows how the thought of “fat talks” are going more of a societal norm to teenage girl society.Fat Talkis really similar to hebdomad 12s readingTelevision,Disordered Eating,and Young Women in Fiji:Negociating Body Image and Identity During Rapid Social Change, written by Anne E. Becker, because it refers to the same constructs as that inFat Talk.The reading explains the negative organic structure image these adult females learn from their society and how in order to be accepted or to experience beautiful the adult females of Fiji take portion in eating upsets merely to experience thin and socially acceptable. This is same for Nichter’s book because these adolescent misss engage in dieting wont to be able to pull a mate and experience externally beautiful.

I found the book Fat Talk: What Girls and Their Parents Say About Dieting, to be an easy read and would see it acceptable for other audiences to read other than merely anthropologists. I besides found it to be really relatable. This is because being a miss, I myself used to prosecute in unsavory dieting wonts back in high school merely because my female parent said I was non as thin and beautiful as my sisters. Therefore, when Nichter says that households of these misss have a great impact on their visual aspects she is right. Many households need to be cognizant of this impact and should seek to make a organic structure positive family so that their kids do non prosecute in unhealthy dieting and ever seek to retrieve to state their childs that they are beautiful non count how you look. Nichter does a great occupation of voicing her sentiments and findings to that of the concerns of adolescent misss and their dietetic patterns.

Plants Cited

Nichter, Mimi. Fat Talk: What Girls and Their Parents Say About Dieting. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2000

Notes from Lecture 2015***


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out