He Efficiency Of Chelex And Qiagen Extraction Protocols Biology Essay

Deoxyribonucleic acid profiling has reached great highs in forensic scientific discipline with new technological promotions every other twelvemonth, which makes it possible to tie in the grounds with a peculiar individual. Deoxyribonucleic acid profiling techniques are widely used in human individuality proving for placing the suspect, paternity testing, designation of victim ‘s in mass catastrophe and designation of a individual ‘s individuality from human remains. Deoxyribonucleic acid profiling engineering is non merely used in human individuality proving but besides in wild life and preservation genetic sciences.

Deoxyribonucleic acid profiling is most frequently subjected to disagreement and figure of factors ; like the extraction protocol followed, beginning of the DNA ( blood, spit, seeds, tegument cells, perspiration, hair etc ) , taint of the sample, lucifer chance, Partial DNA profile, Low transcript figure, mixtures, etc can do ambiguity and the defense mechanism advocate frequently tend to raise inquiries on these issues.

We will write a custom essay sample on
He Efficiency Of Chelex And Qiagen Extraction Protocols Biology Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

Deoxyribonucleic acid profiling methods use the genotypic differences between the persons to place the subscriber. Profiling the full genome is a dashing undertaking to execute, hence for this ground: short tandem repetitions on the non coding parts of the genome are profiled. These tandem repetitions on specific allelomorphs of the non cryptography parts are said to be alone among persons, possibly the Deoxyribonucleic acid profile as grounds may non be declared as a 100 % lucifer with the profile of the fishy hence Forth, a random lucifer chance that some other individual unrelated to the suspect holding the same profile is calculated.

Finding a suited DNA isolation system to achieve a good profile is of import. The extraction process varies harmonizing to the type of biological grounds and besides on the measure of the grounds collected. The method of pick in a forensic research lab is one which can give sufficient measure of amplified DNA and a good quality profile.

2. Beginning of DNA grounds:

The efficiency of obtaining a full good quality profile besides depends on the beginning of the DNA sample. Though Deoxyribonucleic acid can be obtained from assorted beginnings like Semen, Blood, Hair, Bones, Teeth, spit, Sweat, Urine and tegument cells, but the focal point is chiefly imposed on the Deoxyribonucleic acid obtained from blood and spit and buccal swabs when roll uping mention samples from a suspect or victim. Chelex and Qiagen are best suited for samples obtained from buccal swabs, skin cells and blood.

Each nucleated cell has about 6pg of DNA, while liquid blood has 5000-10,000 nucleated blood cells per/ml. Blood is an first-class beginning of human DNA. Deoxyribonucleic acid is present in white blood cells of worlds, but non in ruddy blood cells which lack karyon. A little topographic point of blood, about 50 Aµl is sufficient plenty for PCR elaboration.

Buccal swabs are easy and a painless method to roll up DNA sample. They contain legion cheek cells which shed really often, which is a rich beginning of cellular DNA. Buccal Swabs besides contain considerable sums of spit in it, doing it even a good beginning of DNA.


4. Methods for DNA extraction:

The organic extraction methods like phenol trichloromethane method are inexpensive and efficient plenty to take PCR inhibitors but greatly cut down the sum of DNA. The other widely used techniques below are used in many forensic research labs in UK and besides in other parts of the universe.

4.1 Chelex method:

The Chelex is one of the easiest and simplest methods to utilize for forensic casework. It works efficaciously good when the sample measure is minimum even a “ pinpoint of blood ” . The extraction mechanism is simple and effectual based on cell lysis during warming and binding of Chelex rosin ( Styrene vinyl benzine copolymers ) to the Mg2+ ions forestalling the debasement of Deoxyribonucleic acid from DNase giving a individual stranded Deoxyribonucleic acid which is compatible for farther PCR analysis.

4.1.1 Advantages:

Cheap, dependable and fast.

Less figure of sample transportation between tubings, less opportunity of taint

Non risky chemicals used

Outputs individual stranded DNA, therefore compatible with PCR technique.

Efficient even when the sample sum is somewhat minimum than required.

4.1.2 Restrictions of Chelex:

One of the major disadvantages of Chelex is that it is non efficient in remotion of inhibitors.

Not suited for long term storage because the rosin loses its binding capacity with the metal ions.

Presence of Chelex rosin atoms even after removal measure may sometimes suppress PCR procedure.

Degraded Deoxyribonucleic acid is unsuitable for extraction utilizing the Chelex method because the warming may do breaks in the debauched Deoxyribonucleic acid.

Uneven distribution of rosin beads may besides impact the PCR procedure.

4.2 Qiagen:

The QIAamp extraction kit is much more rapid and fast method when compared with the Chelex and other organic extraction methods. The QIAamp kit uses a particular spin column which made of a silicon oxide gel membrane. Under high salt ( Chaotropic ) concentrations, the DNA binds with the silicon oxide membrane and Cells are lysed on add-on of Proteinase, and on farther lavation and whirling removes unwanted contaminations and inhibitors, while the Deoxyribonucleic acid is still adsorbed to the membrane. The Adsorbed DNA can be eventually eluted by rehydration with aqueous low salt solutions. The eluted DNA is dual stranded.

4.2.1. Advantages:

No toxic chemicals used

High quality outputs

Efficient remotion of contaminations and inhibitors

Can be used for assortment of samples like fresh & A ; frozen blood, bone marrow, Viral DNA and spit and other organic structure fluids.

Sample size of about 200 Aµl is sufficient plenty

4.2.2 Disadvantages:

Frequent Transportation of spin columns

The Deoxyribonucleic acid sometimes is non eluted decently from the silicon oxide membrane.

Or the Deoxyribonucleic acid is washed off during the washing process.

5. Q-PCR techniques:

Determining the sum of DNA in a sample is indispensable for PCR. Adding right sum of Deoxyribonucleic acid to the PCR elaboration is the primary indispensable measure for obtaining a good quality profile because PCR reaction is really sensitive, excessively much Deoxyribonucleic acid to the reaction can do over elaboration while minimum sums consequences in a hapless profile. Both the methods mentioned below plants on the basic mechanism of PCR.

PCR, the amplicons are designed in such a manner that the smaller 1s gets amplifies preferentially because the STR allelomorphic remain as the mark

5.1 The place brew methods:

Home brew methods are dependable and cheap but at the same clip it is clip devouring because the readying and add-on of each constituent of the mixture is done manually. There are high opportunities of taint ; hence excess quality control steps should be taken. One of the major drawbacks of place brew based PCR methods is that the positive control is added externally. Furthermore the primers designed are sometimes non compatible with the sequences in the allelomorphic population.

5.2 Plexors:

Plexor is commercially made available by the ‘Promega ‘ company. The advantage of Plexor with other “ Home brew ” methods is it is extremely sensitive and it can quantify both autosomal homo Deoxyribonucleic acid and besides the male specific DNA at the same time for samples of even 3 pg/ul of DNA. Plexor measures the lessening in fluorescence of the dye as the PCR merchandise is synthesized unlike the other place brew Q-PCR methods where, increase in fluorescence is detected. Real clip package such as the Plexor Analysis package detects and analyzes the fluorescence informations. The kit besides contains internal positive and negative controls unlike the place brew PCR methods where, the controls are added manually to the mixture. Three different dyes are used for quantification, the FAM dye is used to observe the human autosomal Deoxyribonucleic acid, CAL FLUOR ORANGE 560 dye is used to observe the Y – chromosomal Deoxyribonucleic acid, CAL FLUOR ORANGE 610 dye used to observe Internal PCR control while, IC5 dye used as the mention dye.

6.PCR Amplification:

The PCR reaction allows specific elaboration of DNA sequence of involvement, in a forensic instance work the tandem repeated allele sequences are targeted and amplified. The success of the PCR is based on the choice of the primers in context of its usage. The consequence is a standardization curve which shows the concentration of DNA in each of the tubing against the standard curve.

6.1 Powerplex:

The Powerplex 16 kit amplifies alleles in the venue Penta E, D18S51, D21S11, TH01, D2S1358, FGA, TPOX, D8S1179, vWA, Amelogenin, PentaD, CSF1PO, D16S39, D7S820, D13S317 and D5S818. The allelomorphs are differentiated from one another by their size difference due to electrophoresis and the repetition sequences within the allelomorphs are distinguished from one another by different staining techniques. All 16 venues are amplified at the same time.

6.2 Allelic ladder:

The allelomorphic ladder is a aggregation of different allelomorphs often occurred in a given population, which are straight added to the amplified DNA sample and with the internal size criterion before cataphoresis.The principal behind the usage of allelomorphic ladder is that during the cataphoresis separation the sample fragments separate along with the allelomorphic ladders and the allelomorphic ladders are differentiated from the sample DNA fragments by the package with their fluorescent ticket, this makes it convenient to denominate which allelomorphs are amplified.

7. Capillary Electrophoresis:

Electrophoresis designed particularly for STR analysis under denaturized status is the capillary cataphoresis. It uses dimethyl polyacrylamide as the matrix and high electromotive force doing the separation rapid. The capillary cataphoresis used for this faculty was the ABI PRISM 310 GENETIC ANALYZER which has a optical maser excitement beginning, a fluorescence sensor and car sampling station that holds sample. Sample injection, cataphoresis and informations aggregation are all automated and controlled by a computing machine. The sizes of the Deoxyribonucleic acid fragments can be calculated by including an internal size criterion.

8. PCR Artifacts:

8.1 Stutter extremums:

Stutter extremums appear before or after true allelomorphs and typically hold highs less than 15 % of the next true allelomorph otherwise called as parent allelomorph. Stutter may dissemble minor subscribers. The stammer extremums are largely 1-4 Bp lupus erythematosus in length than the parent allelomorph. The ground for the happening stammer merchandises might be due to the slippage of DNA polymerase during the reproduction procedure. When stammer extremums are accidently called as allelomorphs by the package, the profile is interpreted as a mixture profile.

8.2 Micro-variants:

Micro-variants are infinitesimal differences in the STR which are regarded to be rare. This could happen likely due to mutants in the primer adhering site thereby no elaboration of an allelomorph would happen

8.3 Mixture:

A mixture is identified by detecting more than two allelomorphs in any venue. Noise and stammer must be disregarded to place a true mixture. The package helps in distinction of an allelomorph with the stammer extremum. Mixtures can be identified easy with the presence of two or more allelomorphs in a given venue, but sometimes with issues like allelomorphic dropout, heterozygote instability or cover of allelomorphs, makes the reading and allele appellation really complicated and intricate.

8.4 Spikes / Pull ups:

A big extremum in a coloring material which pulls up extremum of another coloring material systematically in the same part, illustration: a bluish extremum pulls up a green extremum which in bend pulls up the xanthous extremum. Spikes may happen due to the extra dye, dust atoms or air bubbles in the capillary tubing.

8.5 Off ladder allelomorph:

Sometimes all the allelomorphs happening seldom in a population may non be present in the allelomorphic ladder, such allelomorphs are called non called by the package therefore known as Off ladder allelomorphs. The same rule applies when the allelomorph falls outside the prescribed allelomorphic parts.

8.6 Issues with PCR suppression:

The samples obtained from a offense scene are ever non pure. It is frequently found mixed with some other organic structure fluids or with other substances like works stuffs, textile dyes, leather, or many be chemical substances ; PCR suppression could be because there is mixture of one or more of these substances with the Deoxyribonucleic acid sample. The suppression may impede the DNA elaboration, cell lysis and even the add-on of bases because of which the allelomorphs are non amplified as it was supposed to be. The profile appears like a profile of that of a degraded Deoxyribonucleic acid which makes the reading hard.

9. Q-PCR consequences:

“ Home Brew ” Plexor

Method used Quantity of DNA Method used Quantity of DNA

( ng/ul ) ( ng/ul )

Chelex saliva 0 Chelex saliva 2.04

Chelex blood 0.08984 Chelex blood 0.231

Qiagen saliva 0.0608 Qiagen saliva 5.02

Qiagen blood 0 Qiagen blood 0.102

9.1 Discussion of the consequences:

Other DNA extraction methods were non used for comparing because merely Chelex and Qiagen methods were used to obtain a DNA profile ; therefore forth comparing of the efficiency of other methods can non be established.

Regardless of the sample beginning and the method of DNA extraction protocol, the Plexor worked good when compared with the Home brew method. This may be because the multi-mix contains all the size criterion, appropriate controls, the primers and dyes, which minimized taint and pipetting mistakes. Plexor is a commercially available kit, the reagents and the primers used were validated, which makes it execute better. The place brew method more likely may non hold appropriate primers and so non validated as in the kits.

With the Plexor multiplexing system, observing both human and male Deoxyribonucleic acid in every sample will assist you do critical determinations about whether to utilize an autosomal Y STR system without blowing critical sample by executing multiple quantification analysis.

The measure of DNA besides depends on the measure of the sample retrieved, and besides its beginning. It is surprising that the measure of DNA taken from blood had less sum of Deoxyribonucleic acid when compared with that of spit. This likely would be due to the difference in the sum of sample collected from the giver.

The other grounds might be due to the presence of any inhibitors in the reaction mixture which might impact the consequences ; for blood the of course happening inhibitor is heme. The buccal swabs are rich in DNA, and do non incorporate of course happening inhibitors but may incorporate bacteriums. Apart from cheek cells, the spit besides contains DNA therefore doing the beginning of DNA richer when compared with blood.

The ground why Qiagen did non execute good when compared with Chelex may be due to ground that Deoxyribonucleic acid remained edge to the silicon oxide membrane and did non elute during the lavation, thereby doing merely less measure of DNA available for the PCR reaction.

9.1.1 Sample 82 profile:

The sample 82 is obtained by the Chelex spit extraction protocol and is over amplified. Over elaboration may be due to the presence of extra DNA than the needed sum. The PCR reaction is sensitive, and therefore even little surplus DNA sample would take to over elaboration. Due to the over elaboration many off ladder allelomorphs were observed and Due to this, the profile would frequently be misinterpreted as a assorted profile. Even little stammer extremums were amplified and were called as allelomorphs by the package. The allelomorphs in the venue 10 and 13 were less amplified when compared with the allelomorphs of other venue. The presence shutter values and off ladder allelomorphs did non really impede the illation of the profile because the allelomorphs were surely over amplified than the stammer extremums and the off ladder allelomorphs. The off ladder allelomorphs were present in about every venue ; this could surely be due to over elaboration.

9.1.2 Sample 83 profile:

The sample 83 corresponds to the profile obtained from a blood swab and the Chelex extraction was followed from DNA extraction from blood.

A good quality profile except for the allele D5S818 was obtained. The sum of DNA added to the PCR elaboration mixture was 4.3 ul with that add-on of 1 ng/ul to the PCR mixture is achieved. The profile did non incorporate any outstanding spikes except for few stammer extremums happening merely before the extremums of the allelomorph. The allelomorphs for the venue D5 was non called because the allele elaboration was much lesser when compared with the elaboration of other allelomorphs. If the threshold value was decreased to include the minor allelomorphic extremums, so many other stammer extremums would be called as allelomorphs. For the venue D8 the elaborations was far lesser, and besides for the FGA venue, it seems to be tri allelomorphic due to the shutter values greater than the threshold, but the allelomorph 25 holding the maximal tallness, is merely called excluding 20 and 24 allelomorphs. One off ladder was observed for the venue D18 but did non impede the reading of the profile. For the CSF loci the lone one allelomorph 10 was called the allelomorph 13 was non called by the package this may due to hapless elaboration of that allelomorph.

9.1.3.Sample 84:

The sample 84 corresponds to the profile obtained from the buccal swab and Qiagen extraction protocol was used to pull out DNA. The profile had no allelomorphic extremums except for many extremums which were characteristic of noise and shutter extremums. The ground for non acquiring a profile could non ascertained, because this merely contradicts the sum of DNA obtained from the Q-PCR consequences where the sum of DNA nowadays was more than required. The ground for non acquiring a profile may be due to pipetting mistakes during the add-on of DNA sample to the PCR reaction mixture.

9.1.4.Sample 85:

The sample 85 corresponds to the profile obtained from the Blood swab and QIAamp extraction protocol was used for the DNA extraction. The sample 82 besides yielded a complete profile except for the fact that it was over amplified. This may due to add-on of surplus DNA than the needed sum, Since PCR is really sensitive, and it resulted in over elaboration of the DNA sample. Artifacts such as shutter extremums and off ladder allelomorphs were observed due to over elaboration. Even minute extremums which could hold resulted due to little proficient defects were even pulled up due T over elaboration, because the threshold maintained was merely same as for the other samples.

10. Decisions:

The profiles for the sample 82 and 84 are non included for comparing because one is over amplified which does non give much of accurate information with presence of many artifacts and for the sample 84, a Deoxyribonucleic acid profile was non obtained.

The samples 83 and 85 are compared to see which extraction protocol yielded good quality profile and how the Q-PCR consequences find the quality of the profile. The profile consequences shows that sample 83 had minimum artifacts, while sample 85 had many PCR related artifacts.

Though the sample measure obtained from the Q-PCR was lesser when compared with the other Chelex sample, it worked better giving about a complete full and good quality profile with fewer artifacts

The extraction protocol for sample 83 was Chelex and Qiagen for sample 85. Both the methods Chelex and Qiagen work expeditiously though both have their ain restrictions. Bearing the restrictions of the protocols and besides other assorted factors, the DNA profiling reading is done consequently.

Literature Reappraisal:

1. A. Barbaro, N. S. , P. Cormaci, L. Saravo ( 2004 ) . “ DNA profiling by different extraction methods “ International Congress Series 1261: 562-564.

This survey aimed to compare the efficiency of different DNA extraction utilizing commercial kits and the ability of each method to give dependable DNA profiles.DNA samples from liquid blood, old blood discolorations, coffin nail buds, seeds discolorations and hairs.

The QIAamp lit worked so good with an first-class extraction method and purification with hints of inhibitors, though loss in DNA occurred around 30 % .

While even the Chelex extraction method seems to work good with low cost therefore its commonly used for samples from coffin nail buds, seeds, blood discolorations, possibly there is no separate measure unlike the Qiagen to take the inhibitors, . “ Finally the paper concludes stating that the right pick of the DNA extraction method and an accurate Deoxyribonucleic acid quantification are really of import measure in the analytical process to guarantee optimum consequences “ .

2. V. Castella, N. D.-S. , C. Brandt-Casadevall, P. Mangin ( 2006 ) . “ Forensic rating of the

QIAshredder/QIAamp DNA extraction process “ Forensic Science International 156: 70-73.

This paper aims to measure the efficiency of QIAamp the commercially available kit by comparing the efficiency of QIAamp with Chelex and Phenol – Chloroform with assorted DNA samples from blood, spit, and cotton swabs, and coffin nail buds etc. Merely 61 % of the samples yielded conclusive consequences Chelex and Phenol Chloroform methods were used, but for QIAamp 82 % of the samples were successful. This paper besides suggests the usage of QIAshredder column in concurrence with the QIAamp system to farther better the recovery of Deoxyribonucleic acid from blood and spit. ” Overall, the usage of QIAamp was more successful than the Chelex and Phenol-Chloroform methods and therefore provinces that the QIAamp is efficient when the samples contained smaller sums of DNA, and besides for samples which contained inhibitors.

( Luke Forster 2008 )


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out