Ideal woman in Kincaid’s short story “Girl” Sample Essay

In an enterprise to specify an ideal adult female. we compare two Literature plants which are the Kincaid’s short narrative “Girl” and Jane Martin’s drama. “Rodeo” . Comparing these two plants. we see two contrasting definitions of an ideal adult female as they are brought out in different scenes. In the Kincaid’s short narrative. “Girl” . we notice for case that a miss should populate a low life that is respectful to all the people and avoid have oning in such a mode that they could look as a slattern. On the other manus. to the contrast of this. in the Jane Martin’s drama. “Rodeo” . we meet a really mercenary miss who wears in such a mode that is attractive to work forces so that she can derive material things. This essay will be comparing between these two. in a command to specify an ideal adult female.

Ideal adult female in Kincaid’s short narrative “Girl”

We will write a custom essay sample on
Ideal woman in Kincaid’s short story “Girl” Sample Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

In the Kincaid’s short narrative “Girl”’ a female parent is giving advice to her girl at a really high velocity. It is pretty certain that the female parent does non even gasp through the whole session. She tells the miss about populating a nice life that is admirable to everyone. about cooking in her place. about maintaining herself clean. about how to manage work forces and besides how to maintain repute from one amazement to the other. This is in a command to do her girl grow into an admirable ideal adult female to everyone. Although the topographic point where all this takes topographic point is non mentioned in the whole narrative. through the word beat and the miss particulars. portray that this takes topographic point in the West Indies. Merely twice that the girl butts in to the mom’s watercourse of advice. One of the cases is where she was supporting herself. “ but I don’t sing benna on Sunday at all and ne’er in Sunday school” . and the 2nd portion is where she is presenting a inquiry that leads to the terminal of the text. Here were are acquiring the penetration that an Ideal adult female should ever be really acute to listen and non disrupt when another individual is speaking to her. The other thing is that an ideal adult female should ever maintain her words down when speaking to her seniors.

In this narrative. we get the thought that an ideal adult female should ever be really difficult working. In an advice. we see the girl being told that. “We don’t merely intend the make-up and the high heels. We mean cleaning the house. The whole house. And looking delicacy while making it” . This was meant to demo the girl. in the attempt of seeking to go difficult working. she should non merely strive hard to be good looking physically. but all her environment should look clean as good. In this narrative besides. it is clear that being a adult female is synonymous with housework and besides maintaining the dwellers of the house clean and besides the environment. A adult female. who does non accomplish this end harmonizing to this narrative. will be fundamentally perpetrating a societal self-destruction. This is why these things that the female parent tells the girl to make so as to maintain their lady card are ever passed from the female parent to the girl in the signifier of a motherly advice. So besides to be an ideal adult female the narrative suggest that one has to execute these functions of go throughing these advice to their girls.

In the “Girl” gender is taken to be a really large trade merely as it is in the existent life. A miss should ever seek every bit much as possible to forbear from that so as to avoid the danger of going a slattern. This is a non to make thing for any ideal adult female. It seems like anything from walking amusing to manner malfunction can take you to this. In this narrative. the female parent seems to cognize this from her personal experience. and in many occasions. she had the word slut thrown to her way. So in order to model the miss and salvage her from this state of affairs. she gives her this advice that would see her go an ideal adult female. All the ladies should walk this tightrope of appropriate gender carefully so that they could go better married womans and ideal adult females from the mom’s advice.

There is besides the category and societal standing position in this short narrative that an ideal adult female should posses. This has been there since manner back when person was required to hold manner more glistening stones than everyone else. In this narrative. it is non the glistening stones entirely. but the quality of the adult female table scene. the colour of one’s tegument along with the evenness of the hem. In the colonial times where the British civilization was ever valued over the native 1. the Antigua of a descent miss like the Kincaid are seen at the underside of the hierarchy. If they allow themselves to be rung down one more clip. so they will be seen to be out of the conference. So a miss O instead a adult female should ever keep high criterions. It is really clear in this narrative that it is really easy to lose your societal standing and besides really hard to remember yourself out of these state of affairss. So it is of import for one to be ever careful non to lose the societal standing. Hence to be an ideal adult female. we should listen to the mom’s advice.

In this narrative besides. we see the female parent learning the miss about the traditions. A tradition is important as it is said that it is how people keep their balance. It will assist the miss to voyage the universe. And do things easier for her to turn as an ideal and an unsloped adult female. She should be really careful here as tradition could be outdated. kick dense and smothering. Tradition will assist the miss to turn to go a proper lady and accordingly go an ideal adult female. Traditions will besides assist a lady to maintain any bad fortune from happening her.

Ideal adult female definition in Jane Martin’s plays “Rodeo”

On the other manus. to the reverse of all these advices in the “Girl” . the drama by Jane Martin. “Rodeo. we see it dominated by the desire to get material things. For case we notice a miss by the name Lurlene going unsuitable for the Rodeo as she did non dress like a show miss and besides wear material things. Besides in the scene gap. there are several stereotyped props that are used to portray the cowpuncher image. beer imbibing and difficult working with a feature of playing music as an added touch. In most scenes. people are familiar with these sorts of traits being presented by work forces characters. But to the contrary. we find a tough smart and opinionated adult female with a distinctively state name by Lurlune with a typical cowpuncher sort of moniker by Large eight. By delving into the true character of this adult female. one will recognize that she is non different from the mean adult female in today’s work force. The lady is merely experiencing the favoritism and defeat and besides the push out of the lone life style that she comprehends by “them” ( 1967 ) . This is a contrary character to the mom’s advice to the miss. who advised her to avoid amusing dressings so that she could non be identified as a slattern. This was due to the altering traditions.

The most apparent similarity that can be noticed in these two is the alteration in the traditions. The ma in the short narrative “Girl” . had warned the “Girl” to be more careful to the alterations in the traditions. In the drama. we find Large eight holding a batch of jobs seting to the employed alterations. Although she is non accommodating really good to the arriving patrons. she is non all that comfy with the alterations in the frock codifications. She does non even though comprehend that dressing adult females in fancy outfit would be a scheme of pulling audiences when the rodeo is simply supposed to be about the drives. Her believe is rooted in the thought that it does non count what one dresses but instead how she rides. She notices that the “Big crowds” ( 1667 ) is largely made up of the metropolis people in “designer denims and day-glo Stetsons. ” ( 1667 ) there ain’t barely no spread people. no farm people. ” ( 1667 ) any more. As “these” came into the athletics and take over. it was like a little company being overtaken and assimilated by a large company.


In these two literature plants. the definition of an ideal adult female is all the same but in different scene. In the short narrative. “Girl” . it portrays the antediluvian times when the adult females were constrained by many factors and the work forces were considered as the lone staff of life victors with the adult female being simply a domestic worker. In the drama “Rodeo” we see that the scene was in the revolutionized universe where the adult male and adult female are all bread victors and they all struggle to do their universe better through all agencies.


Kincaid’s short narrative “Girl”

Jane Martin’s drama “Rodeo”

Beginning papers


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out