Internal Audit Is An Independent Appraisal Function Accounting Essay


Internal audit is an independent assessment map set up by the direction of an entity for the review of the internal control system as a ministry to the entity. It objectively investigates, buttockss and studies on the sufficiency of internal control as a dedication to the appropriate, economic and effectual utilize of resources. Besides, internal audit is a direction duty as to retain the internal control system and to guarantee that the entity ‘s resources are suitably made used in the mode and on the activities planned. It besides includes the duty of the internal hearer for the bar and sensing of fraud and other illegal Acts of the Apostless. In Malaysia, internal audits are governed by The Institute of Internal Auditors Malaysia ( IIA Malaysia ) , and complied with International Professional Practices Framework ( IPPF ) .

The drumhead buttockss that the attempt of the Institute of Internal Auditor ( IIA ) in bettering the professional position of both the subject of internal auditing and the IIA itself. Over the last half-century, the Institute of Internal Auditor ( IIA ) has already put a batch of attempts in raising professionalisation of internal auditing. The IIA has set up the gear of a formal professional model but several factors arise to barricade the professional “ undertaking ” , the most important of the factor is the absence of monopolistic to rule the subject. The IIA confront two options in the hereafter. It may wish to go on farther along the manner of set uping a formal professional model. Alternatively, the IIA in its modern signifier may be ideally placed for a new, post-professional universe from the traditional, antiquated professional establishments seems sick equipped.

We will write a custom essay sample on
Internal Audit Is An Independent Appraisal Function Accounting Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now


What is a profession? Macdonald ( 1995, p. 1 ) offers a utile working definition of professions as “ businesss based on advanced, or complex, or esoteric, or arcane, cognition ” . The definition decidedly determined cognition as a cardinal composing in professionalism. However, knowledge entirely is an inadequate of the definition of professionalism. It lacks a societal legitimacy since it has absence of an institutional model and an acceptable ethical footing. The societal legitimacy of a profession therefore has to be derived from the mode that a cognition base is institutionalized and ethically framed. In drumhead, a profession is defined as an business based on advanced, complex, or esoteric cognition, backed by a societal legitimacy deducing from both an institutional model and a believable ethical footing.

The Institute of Internal Auditors ( IIA ) is a non-profit professional organisation dedicated to the promotion and development of the internal audit profession. The mission of the Institute of Internal Auditors is to qualify a “ dynamic leading ” for the planetary profession of internal auditing such as to recommend and advance the value that internal audit professionals add to their organisations, provide the comprehensive professional instruction and development chances, criterions and other professional pattern counsel and enfranchisement plans, and even research, disseminate, and promote to the practicians and stakeholders knowledge refering internal auditing and its appropriate function in control, hazard direction, and administration. Furthermore, IIA besides has seting more attempts on to educate the practicians and other relevant audiences on best patterns in internal auditing, and even to convey together internal hearers from all states to portion information and experiences. In add-on, there are some certifications are offered by the IIA. The Certified Internal Auditor ( CIA ) is the primary professional appellation offered by the IIA for internal hearers and is a criterion by which persons may show their competence and professionalism in the internal audit field. While the other certifications offered by the IIA includes Certification in Control Self Assessment ( CCSA ) , Certified Government Auditing Professional ( CGAP ) for authorities public presentation scrutinizing and authorities hearers, Certified Financial Service Auditor ( CFSA ) , and Certification in Risk Management Assurance ( CRMA ) .


Sawyer and Vinten suggest that there are some jobs about the designation of internal hearers as true professionals. Degrees and enfranchisement may non make it. After all, merely physicians can compose prescriptions. Merely lawyers can subject legal Jockey shortss. Merely certified public comptrollers can attest to fiscal statements, but anyone can subscribe an internal audit study ( Sawyer and Vinten, 1996, p.34 ) . There is no uncertainty that the chief drive force behind the increasing professionalisation of internal auditing has been the IIA. Therefore, the IIA has established three elements of a proto-professional model consisting with the definition of a profession: an independent expertness, an institutional model and a public service ethos.

For the first proto-framework of an independent expertness, IIA have identified a believable cognition footing as a requirement in the definition of a profession. The importance of an intellectually robust epistemology of internal auditing is a repeating subject in the subject ‘s literature. Second, the institutional model of a profession long pillows and formalizes its theoretical footing that delivers enfranchisement, a sophisticated literature ( including seriess ) , research activities and written criterions. Examinations and enfranchisement remainder on the premise of the being of a organic structure of cognition that can be taught and tested. Research activities assume that there is a organic structure of cognition to be investigated, and a developed literature suggests that there is a sufficiently consistent organic structure of cognition to be communicated to a broad audience. Third, a public service ethos should to be embodied in a codification of moralss. An ethical foundation is indispensable for a profession, and the IIA ‘s aspirations to professional position have therefore needfully involved ethical considerations. The IIA ‘s Code of Ethics in puting out criterions of behavior, is an effort to claim institutional moral authorization for the IIA and for internal auditing.

To heighten professional position of internal auditing has non developed from the IIA ‘s creative activity of a proto-professional model entirely. It is besides assisted by international corporate administration enterprises that have endorsed the importance of internal auditing, the IIA has made a powerful claim for important position for both itself and the pattern of internal auditing.

Although touchable advancement in all these countries has been considerable, a figure of factors appear to keep the potency for a to the full blown professional “ undertaking ” which should has been the IIA want to set about one. Five beginnings of failing in internal audit ‘s professional position are suggested: symbolism and mythology, short term term of office, established rubric, ethical via media and, exclusivity which is the most serious.

Symbolism and mythology can make a sense of mystique and aloofness crucial to a profession ‘s societal legitimacy. However, the IIA and internal auditing are weak in the field of symbolism and mythology, and there is no obvious image that identifies the internal hearer as a professional. There is no symbolic image in internal auditing to compare with. The 2nd possible failing is about the station of internal hearer can be little more than a transeunt place on the manner to occupations in other parts of the endeavor. The short term term of office in internal auditing places may gnaw the professional position of internal auditing, by downgrading the intrinsic value of the subject as a rewarding and believable calling. In the affair of established rubric for the internal auditing, there is a considerable argument over the appropriate rubric for the internal hearer. Some of them propose rubrics of internal audit as “ control confidence adviser ” or “ concern procedure adviser ” . The deficiency of lucidity over professional appellation is a possible failing in set uping the professional legitimacy of internal auditing. Furthermore, the perceptual experience that internal auditing was compromised in the surpluss of the new public direction ( NPM ) for the late 20th century with a instead hardheaded managerialism besides may be possible beginning of failing in the ethical position of internal auditing.

All of the failings above are all possible retraining factors on the farther development of the professional position of internal auditing. However, exclusivity is indispensable to the professional undertaking, and this may be the most of import modification factor on the farther professionalisation of the subject. The IIA does non hold restrictive or monopolistic control over countries such as the enfranchisement of internal hearers and definitions of internal auditing. The internal hearers do non bask the monopolistic privilege or of even a clearly defined legal power of activity appear to be the most important brakes on any farther professional “ undertaking ” the IIA may wish to set about.

In a decision, the IIA still has non yet reached a “ regulatory deal ” with a province to obtain a legal power within which it can put the footings of mention. In the absence of monopolistic or quasi-monopolistic rights, comptrollers and others are freely roam into internal scrutinizing district and the IIA finds itself viing with alternate beginnings of authorization. However, the IIA may still bolster its professional position by hammering stronger links with other professional organisations and by go oning its impressive and esteemed publication programmes, an country in which the organisation has already distinguished itself as an indispensable beginning of authorization on internal auditing. In add-on, traditional professional establishments progressively appear antiquated in a post-modern universe characterized by portfolio callings and multi-disciplinary activities. The IIA in its current signifier could be good positioned to thrive in this new, “ post-professional ” environment.


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out