Management Control System As A Package Commerce Essay

The purpose of the this essay introduces the direction control system as a bundle in the different typologies which is proposed by Merchant, K. Van der Stede, W. and Malmi, T. & A ; Brown D with illustrations of Barclays Bank PLC foremost. Subsequently, discourse the manner of coaction between bundles. Last, analyses critically the challenges of implementing MCS as a bundle.


We will write a custom essay sample on
Management Control System As A Package Commerce Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

Management control system is an integrated technique which concentrates and treating information to measure, consequence and carry on the public presentation of organisational resources. Management controls systems play a polar function in ruling the organisation ‘s schemes to heighten the competitory advantage and do the influence of the end accomplishment. Management control system ( MCS ) as a bundle is a aggregation or set of controls and controls systems ( Malmi 2007 ) . The thought is proposed over 30 old ages by Otley ( 1980 ) . The inevitableness of development confirms MCS should work together non in isolation. There are more grounds prove it. First, usage MCS as a bundle, the function of MCS will be transformed or advanced to be more indispensable. Second, MCS as a bundle is a good manner to accomplish increased organisational public presentation. Furthermore, Fisher ( 1998 ) supported that without linkage between MCS, the eventuality variables of isolation of MCS utilizing may take to erroneous decisions. In other words, the map of an bing MCS bundle may do an influence on a new MCS ‘s utilizing. Therefore, analyzing and using the new system separately can impact the truth of consequences. Besides, if the elements do non conflict between direction control systems, MCS can non merely complement or replacement each other, but besides perfect map, such as personal controls and cultural controls.

Barclays Bank PLC is established in 1965. It is one of the biggest concern bank with the perfect direction control systems. It is suited illustration to exemplify two typologies of MCS as bundles in the modern-day literature. The typologies of Malmit. , & A ; Brown. , 2008 afforts a sufficiently wide. It involves five bundles which are be aftering, cybernetic controls, wages and compensation controls, administrative controls and cultural controls. Planning is an ex-ante signifier of control ( Flamholtz et al. , 1985 ) . To command the behaviour and attempt, it formulates the criterions and ends in functional country. Additionally, be aftering makes certain the operation in an orderly mode on the footing of the expected ends. Action planning and long scope planning are two facets of planning. Action planning means the action and ends can be implementing and achieved during 12 months or less. Obviously, Long scope planning demands long clip to implement the action and recognize the ends. For case, in 2012 Barclays set a 2015 Citizenship Plan. It set out how we will play our portion in get the better ofing the challenges confronting the planetary economic system and in reconstructing assurance in the fiscal services sector during the 3 old ages. Green and Welsh ( 1988 ) defined cybernetic control as “ a procedure in which a feedback cringle is presented by utilizing criterions of public presentation, mensurating system public presentation, comparing that public presentation to criterions, feeding back information about unwanted discrepancy in the systems, and modifying the system ‘s bearing ” . Four systems are included in, which identified by other research: Budgets ( Bunce et al. , 1995 ; Hansen et al. , 2003 ) ; fiscal steps ( Ittner and Larcker, 1998 ) ; non-financial steps ; and Hybrids which include fiscal and non-financial. To actuate the employees working hard, the wages and compensation control is a utile agencies. Barclays provides the wages for public presentation inducements, private health care, tax-exempt portion strategies, kid attention verifiers and up to 30 yearss holiday a twelvemonth. Cultural control is a system to restrict member ‘s behaviour through the belief, sometimes beyond the directors ‘ control. It involves three parts: value-based controls ( Simons, 1995 ) , symbol-based controls ( Schein, 1997 ) , and kin controls ( Ouchi, 1979 ) . There are three degrees of value-based controls, the first degree is that if your value is peculiar and met the value of organisations, you are the individual they are happening. The 2nd degree is your value is socialized and you can transform it to suit the organisation value. Last, you do non take a firm stand personally. Symbol-based control is that the organisation will set up peculiar fixed and current assets, such as edifice work and relax infinite. Clan control creates value and employable accomplishments in the socialisation procedure. The professional preparation may come from organisation division or preparation centre. “ Core of Barclays ” is five organisational values, Barclays put frontward, which is Keep smiling, Own it, Work together, Think smart and 100 % energy. Training, support and development are provided to assist employees suit the value by the human resource section. Administrative controls control staff by persons or group. It is a procedure to supervise whether a undertaking or activities operates. Organization design and construction, policies and process and administration construction are the three facets.

The another typology was proposed by Merchant K. , & A ; Van der Stede W. , ( 2007 ) , they support that MCS system contains 4 bundles which are consequences controls, action controls, forces controls and cultural controls severally. Result controls reassign the employees ‘ attending from procedure to ensue. On the one manus, it makes an influence to action, to accomplish expected end, the system selects the most suited procedure for them. On the other manus, organisation creates meritocracies. Organization rewards the endowment and difficult working employees alternatively of the long term of office. It causes the employees concentrate on the proper on the job country selecting and public presentation. The concluding public presentation determines whether they can obtain the wages. The application of consequence control is limited. Merely in this circumstance, which is employees ‘ action can impact the consequences and the consequences can be measured efficaciously, can the control be suited for. Planning and budget belong to fiscal consequence control system, nevertheless, Malmit T. , & A ; Brown, D. , proposed planning is an single bundle and budget is regarded as a portion of cybernetic control. Action control is constituted by four basic signifiers: behavioural restraints, preaction reappraisal, action answerability and redundancy. Constraints employees behavioural are of great importance to the security company such as a bank. Behavioral restraints, hence, include two facets which are physical and disposal. Lock the desk, set the watchword of computing machine and door and curtail determination doing authorization is the agencies of behavioural restraints. Preaction referee can look into the planned action during or before the execution of the program. The action may be accepted, denied or asked for modify. Action answerability means employees should be accountable for their actions if they know definitions of actions and can acquire wages or penalty for the actions. Redundancy, an expensive control, involves set uping more employees in one station to avoid a loss from the contingent accident and guarantee the undertaking can be achieved expeditiously and absolutely. Policies and processs, which belong to administrative control in another typology, are the parts of action control. Harmonizing to the personal features, forces controls encourage employees engage in self-monitoring which is an expressive to actuate people do their uttermost. Training, choice and arrangement employee and occupation design are forces control belonging to human resources in Barclays, nevertheless, developing and occupation design are frequently linked to administrative controls, and choice is an point of cultural controls. Training does non hold a clear board. It can be regarded as policies and processs of administrative control or cultural control. Organization put force per unit area on the employees who detached the organisation regulations and value, are called cultural control. The more emotional ties, the stronger cultural controls are, such as group wages, puting the proper tone at the top and intra-placement. Group wages should be included in wages and compensation bundles in another typology. Comparing the two typologies, there non merely is differences, but besides portions the similar. On the one manus, a battalion of organisations concentrate on determining their peculiar civilization and believe cultural control can do a great influence on the organisational behaviours. On the other manus, wages and compensation are the most efficient method to actuate workers to make a better occupation. The two typologies pay most attending to develop the cultural controls and wages and see it as an single bundle.

Presents, more organisations implement MCS as a bundle, the more research workers focus on how the direction control packages operate harmonious and mutual. Mikko Sandelin did series researches the yoke among cultural, forces, action and consequences controls on the footing of typology of Merchant & A ; Van der Stede. There is a instance of Barclays to turn out how the forces and cultural controls work together good. As with any company, professional and difficult working employees make certain the organisation ‘s normal operation and stable growing. As for the human resource section of Barclays, a peculiar civilization which can fit the Barclays civilization is the imperative criterion for engaging alternatively of the academic grade and work experience. To prove whether yourself value against their value, Barclay website affords a civilization tantrum quiz. The inquiry about:

“ Own It ” , for illustration, is one of the five values in “ nucleus of Barclays ” : Your overhear a squad member covering with a ailment and recognize that you are responsible for the mistake being discussed. What will you make?

Barclays finds a individual who can take duty for the mistake and explicate why it happened to your squad. After the employment, the section will supply a series preparation to assist you fit their helter-skelter civilization better. If person still can non suit it, he will be dismissed. The illustration shows the harmonious coaction between forces and cultural controls. The equivalent is a comparative frequent subject of treatment. Result controls and cultural controls motivate employees to carry through their possible by honoring. It proofs that a company can acquire the ultimate equal province through different control bundles. Assorted control systems composite more control bundles, the map of control bundles flexible joints on the internal consistence such as a mutual connexion between the designs of two control systems. It was suggested by two researches can be accomplished by informal controls or formal control systems

It is ferocious market competition environment that many companies implement the MCS as a bundle randomly to vouch the accomplishment of ends, whereas, the restriction appeared in the procedure of execution. Most significantly, the challenge is no MCS can be pledged avoiding the mistake, particularly on the complex aggregation of MCS. An honorable mistake will do a large impact on the holistic operation. A overplus of companies attempt to modify the hazard of error, and the interior decorator should turn out that impropernesss in the system will non take topographic point. Therefore, director must pay attending to the hazard of edifice and keeping MCS as a bundle. Then, extended budget direction system may non be perfect or fit the alone circumstance of company. Further, some houses scarcity the accurate and nonsubjective public presentation rating systems. Furthermore, the unjust inducement and restraint mechanisms will excite dissatisfaction of employees and work without direction. Last but non least, any bundles have the control job such as deficiency of way, motivational jobs and personal restrictions.


In drumhead, we can acquire a clear position of the direction control system as a bundle. It is the tool that examination and proctors the behavioural to accomplish the ends of an organisation. Cultural controls and wages are the concerns of two typologies, but, the specific categorizations are different. The bundles can work harmoniously with each others. However, the company has to be confronted with the challenges of implementing direction control system as a bundle, such as colored inducement and restraint mechanisms.


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out