Managerial Control Systems And Balanced Scorecard Project Accounting Essay

After a apparently test and mistake changing of scheme for Mobil Corporation ‘s U.S. Marketing and Refining ( USM & A ; R ) , Bob McCool, president of the company decided to originate Balanced Scorecard Project. This scheme is used with the purpose to reorganise and refashion strategic waies. Specifically, Balanced Scorecard is a set of steps for the director to measure company ‘s public presentation from four positions: fiscal position, client position, internal concern procedure, and inventions and larning position.

The president initiated the undertaking because their old schemes and prosodies were criticized to be chained in the yesteryear and non truly linked with schemes for the hereafter. The old schemes which are fixated on volume and borders at trader degrees and first-class fiscal analysis were non able to work out or at least pinpoint the job restricting the growing of the company. No efficient scheme for the company was recognized. Rather, fiscal analysis and accounting steps frequently mislead the directors to uninterrupted growing and invention.

We will write a custom essay sample on
Managerial Control Systems And Balanced Scorecard Project Accounting Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

On the other manus, BSC complements fiscal steps and operational steps for the benefit of client satisfaction, internal procedures and the organisation ‘s invention and betterment activities. These are drivers are operational steps which besides serve as drivers of future fiscal public presentation. Furthermore, the benefits of BSC include: proviso of direction study with competitory elements such as customer-orientation, short response clip and etc ; and helps to avoid sub optimisation and promote full accomplishment of organisational ends.

2. By taking Balanced Scorecard Strategy, USM & A ; R once more showed it test and mistake scheme. The scheme was randomly chosen without truly seeking to look into the scheme if suited to the demands of the company. However, the company compensated this by garnering consensus among other stakeholders of the company.

A critical component in the development of the undertaking is the ideas and sentiments of the directors and other of import entities within the company. The members of the BSC undertaking include: the president, Mr. Baker and other frailty presidents for all maps, division accountant, and directors of fiscal analysis. Expertness on the scheme adopted was provided by advisers from Renaissance Consultants. Workshops and interviews were done among the members of the commission and among the two types of clients: large franchised traders and 1000000s of clients. However, in malice of workshops and interviews conducted, it is implied that the scheme conceptualisation and goal-setting was top-down and non otherwise as claimed.

Another critical component that was satisfied by the company was the preparation of the existent scorecards aims. The squad acknowledged the demand to do these aims narrow and focused on specified facets of the organisation. Hence, the squad decided to hold eight bombers squads to heighten and polish the strategic aims and steps of the Balanced Scorecard Project. This is of import to the consideration of all facets of the company. Looking it foremost from the position of the lower places ( sub squads ) before subjecting it on the executive degree gave the undertaking some sense of underside to exceed attack of undertaking planning.

3. Through associating the Balanced Scorecard to compensation, the employees were able to accomplish at least 20 % fillip. Employee ‘s base wage mention point was reduced to 90 % of the competitory market rewards as antecedently set. The staying 10 % were achieved with mean public presentation based on three conditions: accomplishment of two corporate fiscal public presentation competitory ranking ; USM & A ; R Balanced Scorecard prosodies ; and concern unit constituent based on cardinal public presentation indexs. Furthermore, an extra 20 % was given to the employees who showed exceeding public presentation based on the mentioned conditions.

The chief advantage that I observe of associating Balanced Scorecard Project to compensation is a scheme of wage for public presentation, a compensation strategy based on satisfaction of assorted standards set by the company. The chief advantage for this type of compensation strategy is the motivational consequence to better public presentation of the employees and their several divisions. Knowledge that first-class public presentation will have wages can increase competition among employees and divisions. Nevertheless, competition will merely be favourable if the standards used will truly be based on end product, public presentation, and terminal consequences.

Furthermore, this strategy can besides assist the company to screen the employees and divisions which are extremely and low acting. This will assist the company to strategize and originate betterment of the low acting employees and divisions. The end product of the employees will be identified exactly and be rewarded consequently. It merely makes carnival for the high acting employees to be paid more than the low or mean employees. Furthermore, this will actuate employees to execute better because they know that their public presentation will be recognized and rewarded. It should besides be taken into history that employees differ in rate of public presentation and proficiency and it should be the extremely performing 1s that should be rewarded and given virtue.

On the other manus, there are besides downswings of associating scorecard to compensation. This may act upon the employees to pretermit empty-handed undertakings. With the purpose to make the mensurable ends, employees may be given to disregard unmeasurable and yet of import facets of the occupation. They may be given to concentrate on facets of the occupation that will heighten their payment assessment. Hence, attempts and other constituents for accomplishing such ends should be recognized and non the existent end product merely.

Furthermore, cost of compensation of the employees will ever be unsure as it will merely be known after the rating period. USM & A ; R may be vulnerable to budgetary cutbacks in times of economic crisis and may non afford such unsure costs. Limited salary budgets may non afford sufficient distinction between employees executing at different rates. Very low distinction may non be able to do to accomplish the coveted motive for higher public presentation and will merely develop mediocrity attitude among them.

4. In general, USM & A ; R used its Balanced Scorecard Process as a public presentation measuring system. The company ab initio used the Balanced Scorecard Process to replace accounting measurings, fiscal analysis and operating steps. These traditional measuring systems specify peculiar actions and step how the employees performed based on these actions. On the other manus, Balanced Scorecard public presentation measuring system pulls the employees towards the vision of the company. Balanced Scorecard is most necessary in mensurating company ‘s public presentation based on its missions and vision. The vision is specifically divided into four of import positions: fiscal, clients, internal concern, and organisational growing and acquisition.

Similarly, associating Balanced Scorecard to compensation is a agency of public presentation measuring system. It is a agency to mensurate public presentation and honor it consequently. For the USM & A ; R, this is an effort to utilize fiscal inducement to actuate the employees by associating attempts exerted to the wagess receives. The employees are expected to bring forth more so that they can increase their net incomes because the higher is the end product, the higher will be their compensation The end of public presentation measuring system can be looked into two positions. First, wage for public presentation is claimed to be an effectual sorting devise to place and pull the most capable appliers. Second, in the instance of the bing employees, wage for public presentation is an incentive strategy to maximise the public presentation and productiveness of the employees based on the four positions in the Balanced Scorecard Project.

Last, the Balanced Scorecard Project was used by USM & A ; R as a public presentation measuring system because the ends set in it are besides a measuring of the company ‘s public presentation. The accomplishment of the ends set in the Balanced Scorecard is a success of the company. On the other manus, failure to accomplish these ends is besides a failure of the company.

Hence, with these, Balanced Scorecard may be considered as a public presentation measuring system and non as a direction system.


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out