Nation Building Essay

State-buildingis defined as the procedure of utilizing the power of the province to organize a common national individuality. [ 1 ] The Singapore Government enacted several touchable constructions including defense mechanism, lodging and economic system for the intent of state edifice. These facets are priceless and were of good purpose at the initial phases, but over clip it can be argued that though they remain important, they may halter nation-building attempts due to the deductions that rose.

Public lodging policies is important in Singapore’s state edifice attempts to instil a sense of belonging and racial coherence through promoting assorted communities of changing ethnics and easy achievability of lodging for all income degrees therefore supporting the state since one owns a interest in the state. [ 2 ] Quotas on the racial composing were imposed in a public lodging ( HDB ) estate to forestall the formation of racial enclaves and advance multiethnic bonding. It was undeniable that lodging policies are important in state edifice attempts as place ownership in Singapore is more than 90 % , and the portion of rental lodging is really low. These province policies have really of import for societal stableness and edifice the sense of nationhood. [ 3 ]

We will write a custom essay sample on
Nation Building Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

However over clip, due to the slack in-migration policies, it led to a spike in demand in public lodging. Since public lodging has supply draging demand by nature due to Construct to Order flats which are merely built 3-4 old ages after demand has been estimated through purchases by prospective householders, the monetary values of public lodging will increase as lodging is operated on a free market footing with small intercession from the province itself, doing it to be unaffordable particularly to new households. In fact, harmonizing to statistics from the HDB, in 2008, it built merely 3,183 new flats when the authorities welcomed over 90,000 lasting occupants ( PRs ) and 20,000 new citizens in the same twelvemonth. [ 4 ] Harmonizing to statistics from HDB, resale level monetary value index has rose 28 per centum from 155.0 ( Q1 2010 ) to 198.5 ( Q1 2014 ) [ 5 ] meaning an addition in HDB monetary values.

National Service ( NS ) is important in state edifice as it forced draftees from all walks of life to populate with each other and portion common experiences during their NS yearss and to further among the people a continued committedness to the defense mechanism of their common place [ 6 ] and pledge to protect it ‘with our lives’ . [ 7 ] The significance of NS has non lessened over clip, as public support for NS remains and NSmen of all ages holding a chiefly positive position of NS harmonizing to an IPS survey held in 2013. [ 8 ] NS is besides viewed as an of import trait of being Singaporean, illustration being about 70 % of Singaporeans polled in an Institute of Policy Studies ( IPS ) study said that holding a male kid who had completed NS is an of import feature of being ‘Singaporean’ . [ 9 ] However despite the significance of NS, it has several defects that if non addressed will halter state edifice attempts. The systemic favoritism of Malays, whom are kept from functioning in countries of the military considered sensitive ( eg. Signal units ) [ 10 ] and slow publicity compared to their Chinese opposite numbers, with the first non-Chinese officer reached flag rank merely at 2004. [ 11 ] This is contrary to the original purpose of NS being a cardinal pillar of state edifice by conveying everybody of different ethnicities and background together, as it intentionally discriminates the minority race. This contributes to a continued perceptual experience of second-class position among the cultural Malay population, which farther worsen the divide between the Malays and the remainder of the population, potentially raising racial tensenesss which hinders state edifice and endanger to rupture apart the racial harmoniousness attempts made by the province. The segregation of recruits by their instruction degree, which affects their military chances as eligibility for leading places via developing under bid schools are determined by one’s instruction degree over one’s military capablenesss defeats the intent of conveying everyone from all walks of life with an equal chance to win and take ownership of the state. In return the less privileged and educated will comprehend themselves to be inferior to the educated, and even take to resentment of their manque higher-ups, which will do disunity between societal categories, rupturing the societal fabric apart.

Economic growing was important in state edifice, as it ensured the endurance for the newly-independent Republic and served as the infrastructural footing for the eventual building of a state [ 12 ] , and forms the primary national individuality before other tools. However, the relentless chase of economic growing was non without its negative deductions, as the authorities adopted broad in-migration policies to pull ‘foreign talent’ , promoting foreign investing by actively courting GLCs and foreign companies to put up here, which led to an inflow of aliens, herding out the employment market as they could accept lower wages which are attractive to employers. Due to this, some citizens feel that they are no longer Godheads of their ain state as the state itself is being progressively “taken over by aliens, and the Government governs more for the benefit of foreign capital and endowment than it does for the local equivalent.13The loss of sense of ownership of the state, and the broadening of the income spread that follows, goes against the end of state edifice, as people are divided and non brought together by the prosperity which came from economic growing and national individuality is diluted as a consequence. This is farther exacerbated by the fact that traditional vicinities, familiar edifices, graveyards and other societal landmarks, and even green infinite are eliminated in order to do room for rich aliens, farther lending to a sense of disruption and loss of individuality. [ 13 ] By actively wooing foreign investing into Singapore, Singapore has a hazard of going a transeunt province, with aliens coming into Singapore with the exclusive purpose of doing money and holding no desire to be portion of the state itself which fosters the impression of Singapore being simply a stepping rock and non a place which 1 has a interest in. Since the national individuality is formed chiefly on economic advancement, it is transeunt and it does non further a sense of belonging, should one decide to go forth Singapore for greener grazing lands.

In decision, defense mechanism, economic growing and lodging are still important in the state edifice procedure, but if left unbridled, they will impede state edifice attempts due to the negative deductions they bring despite of the well intentions the Government had ab initio. The Government has already acknowledged issue and tackled several of these issues. Examples being nominal grasp of Malays in the armed forces, holding the first Malay brigadier-general in 2009, taging a important milepost in Malay integrating in the military [ 14 ] ; presenting assorted chilling steps in the lodging market in a command to take down lodging monetary values and kerbs in foreign quota [ 15 ] in order to lower dependance on foreign endowment.

( 1132 words )


  1. Karl Wolfgang Deutsch, William J. Folt, eds, Nation Building in Comparative Contexts, New York, Atherton, 1966
  2. Smidt-Jensen, Soren, and Signe Cecilie Jochumsen. “ SINGAPORE’S SUCCESSFUL LONG-TERM PUBLIC HOUSING STRATEGIES. ” THE INTERNATIONAL FEDERATION FOR HOUSING AND PLANNING. hypertext transfer protocol: //’s-successful-long-term-public-housing-strategies # .VEzqpPmUe0c ( accessed October 28, 2014 ) .
  3. Leong, Chan-Hoong, Wai Wai Yang, and Henry Ho. “ Singaporeans ‘ Attitudes to National Service. ” Singaporeans ‘ Attitudes to National Service 1 ( 2013 ) : 34.
  4. Choong, William. “ Difficult truths about Singapore’s defense mechanism. ” IISS. hypertext transfer protocol: // voices/blogsections/iiss-voices-2013-1e35/march-2013-6eb6/hard-truths-about-singapore-7dc7 ( accessed October 29, 2014 ) .
  5. Simon Elegant, “Not a Question of Loyalty, ”Time Asia Online, February 18, 2002. Retrieved April 26, 2005, from
  6. Kwok Kian Woon and Mariam Ali, “Cultivating Citizenship and National Identity” , Singapore: Re-Engineering Success, eds. Arun Mahizhnan and Lee Tsao Yuan, Singapore: Institute of Policy Studies and Oxford University Press, 1998, p. 113.
  7. Linda Y.C. Lim & A ; Lee Soo Ann ( 2010 ) “Globalizing State, Disappearing State: The Impact of Foreign Participation in the Singapore Economy” in Terence Chong, ed. , Management of Success: Singapore Revisited, pp. 139-158. ( Lim & A ; Lee_Gobalizing State.PDF )

Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out