Problem of obtaining interviews Essay

Reconsidering Work-Life Balance Arguments

The job of obtaining interviews is a known job that ‘s good documented within diary and research paper. After reading Kamenou ‘s paper it was apparent that the same jobs are happening to her every bit good. This job might hold arisen because of the nature of the administrations being researched. The administrations being researched are private commercial companies which tend to be more protective over how the administration maps ( Harris ET AL 2008 ) . Commercial companies normally run in a fast paced environment with work done by the least sum of employees possible to see profitableness. Research done by Thomas ( 1995 ) and Brannen ( 1987 ) show that there is a inclination for administrations to prioritize and if something has arisen which is more of import than easing the research, the administration will inquire for the research to be conducted at another clip. This might be the instance with Kamenou ‘s trouble in accessing resources from administrations. As one of the administrations stated that it was reconstituting, to travel around such issues normally research workers try to see that the research would be conducted at the appropriate times, when the company ‘s employees are non busy.

Research done by Hirsch ( 1995 ) and Puwar ( 1997 ) showed that when the research worker and the administration demo a common involvement in the research subject there is a higher chance that the administration would ease the research. The research itself could assist the administration publicize how capable they are on certain Fieldss or even larn about a peculiar field from the research worker, hence a common involvement in the research subject is normally good to the administration being researched.

The administration that withdrew from the research harmonizing to Kamenou considered themselves leaders in diverseness. This would intend that the research subject is so of involvement to the administration and that easing the research might turn out that the administration implements procedures that better diverseness in the administration. The fact that the administration was non willing to ease the research might be due to them concealing something or the methods used by Kamenou to achieve interviewees were non decently thought out anterior to the research being done.

Wray and Gates ( 1996 ) show the importance of achieving resonance with the administration, if Kamenou would hold established resonance with the administration that withdrew from the research non merely would the opportunities of achieving interviewees would hold risen but there was a possibility that the research would hold been enriched with critical information, as the interviewees would unwrap information that might cast light about patterns that goes against the motto that the administration is a leader in diverseness.

Interviewees within administrations might happen it difficult to belie at that place higher-ups as that might be them their occupations or it might demo that the interviewee does non hold trueness for the administration. The administration that withdrew might hold considered that hazard and did n’t desire to their repute being tarnished by a research conducted on the company. Knowledge of the administration being researched might besides assist in the obtaining of information from the administration. A survey done by Hirsch ( 1995 ) shows that research workers with greater insider cognition of the administration felt more confident in deriving information or acquiring interviewees. The administration that withdrew from the research was a fiscal company. Fiscal companies normally are really protective about there repute as it is cardinal in procuring new clients. If Kamenou would hold approached the fiscal establishment in a manner that is more friendly and apprehension of their function as a fiscal establishment and how repute is of import, she would hold had a better opportunity in procuring interviewees.

A survey done by Spencer ( 1982 ) suggests that administrations may curtail entree to the administration because they perceive it as a hazard, which might ache the administration ‘s repute. Even if the administration does advance a diverse work force that does non intend that all the employees in the company are traveling to be happy by the manner they are treated. This particularly holds true to large administrations where some minor issues are difficult to command. For illustration some sensitive cultural minorities might comprehend there is some minor racism in the topographic point where they work but it is non a large of an issue and the administration cant take action. If the research worker was to interview some employees that perceive racism in the work force, they might demo their uncomfortableness and that would in bend hurt the repute of the administration.

Personal networking can be one of the easiest ways in accessing an administration Carr and Worth, ( 2001 ) the result of the interview can besides turn out to be more enriched as seen in Kamenou ‘s ( 2008 ) survey. When formal entree has been granted there might be an component where the administration has asked the employees non to unveil certain information about the company or there might be an component of fright where the employee does non desire to unwrap information that would endanger their occupations. In contrast if the employee were a friend, resonance would hold been build between the research worker and the interviewee, which would do the interviewee more unfastened and honest about the issue. Harmonizing to Spradley ( 1979 ) People who feel comfy, safe, and valued are more extroverted than those who are treated simply as beginnings of information.

Although this difference between interviewees obtained by formal agencies and interviewees by personal networking, can be negated by seeking to set up resonance with the interviewees, who are obtained through formal entree by the research worker. It might be worthwhile to seek to derive trust from employees as they might unwrap information that might non be known. Spradley ( 1979 ) recommends that some informal conversation within the interview should be conducted to avoid the nature of an question, personal information can be exchanged in order to look for connexions between the research worker and the interviewee could keep good resonance. Once the interviewee feels comfy, more information can be uncovered.

Interviewees may most probably have at that place ain docket in the interview ( Simsek et al 2000 ) if the research worker does non cognize anything about the interviewee it would be difficult to cognize if the interviewee was concealing something or seeking to portray a specific state of affairs in a peculiar angle that might be misdirecting. There will ever be an component where the interviewee will keep back information that might expose a portion of them that they do non wish to unwrap to the populace. LeCompte Et Al ( 1999 ) . Similarly if the research worker has a personal relationship with the interviewee, its easier for the research worker to bring out the docket which the interviewee might hold. A manner around this job is if the research worker keeps the subject every bit unfastened as possible, leting the research worker to see what the interviewee defines as relevant. For illustration the interviewee might experience that diverseness in the administration is non something of import and hence give the feeling that the administration is making a good occupation. ( Simsek et al 2000 )

In the paper the writer does n’t look to depict her ego much or how she thinks she has affected the research being done. Upon farther reading there is a little paragraph speaking about her function as a lector, the universities that she has studied in and interestingly her research involvements which are largely about diverseness and transverse civilization issues. She has besides worked as a senior research officer on the Mainstreaming Equalities undertaking in the societal justness division. This might intend that the research worker thinks strongly about the issue of transverse civilization issues and that she might be bias in her research towards seeking to cast issues on how cultural minorities are mistreated in the work force. ( Stapleton, 1984 ) .

A survey made by Speer ( 2002 ) shows that the research worker can be a dirty force. Her presence and the manner she acts with the interviewee can impact the quality and the cogency of the informations obtained and the decisions that can be drawn about it. Another factor to see is age and gender. Females are looked at as unintimidating and in some fortunes more understanding so their male opposite numbers ( Troman, 2000 ) . From the research workers name we can deduce that she is a female from cypress as one of the misss in the qualitative research faculty has said. This shows that she is an cultural minority every bit good. A survey by Oackley, ( 1979 ) showed that it is really advantageous if a female is researching other female issues as she would be able to pull out more interesting information from the interviewees.

Another advantage Kamenou has is she is an cultural minority and because of that she has uncovered information that might be difficult for a white male to pull out. For illustration, looking at the canned books one Indian male said: “ I had dressed really much in a western manner. If I chose to dress in more traditional apparels, I am non rather certain how co-workers might see that. They might be frightened by it, threatened by it. ” This might demo that there is trust between the research worker and the interviewee, as he is uncovering personal sentiment on how his co-workers would see him if he has been more traditional that he might non portion with other research workers or even his friends. As a Muslim male my ego I can associate to some of the adversities that some Muslim females are kicking about in the survey. This might be an advantage for me while carry oning the research to demo more of the societal deductions the Muslim females are traveling through in a western universe.

Laskarina Holidays

The procedure of roll uping informations before organizing a hypothesis is called grounded theory. Pieces of informations such as events, newspaper articles or even word of oral cavity are taken and analyzed to see if there is a possible phenomenon where a hypothesis can be made ( Corbin and Strauss, 1990 ) . The gathered informations can be used to construct up a theory or anterior theories can be modified ( Pandit, 1996 ) for illustration the first research inquiries were “ why was Laskarina so successful? How did the house set up such a strong trade name individuality? What was it like to work for Laskarina? ” From reading the booklets, “ Laska Greener ” was a term that popped out therefore inquiries can be asked on the ethical motives of the company, how they are assisting the environment and if they are implementing it or non.

Grounded theory helps when carry oning interviews, the research worker will be able to inquire deeper more relevant inquiry to the interviewee. Rapport is more easy established as the research workers goes in to the organisation with comparative subjects that concern the researched. The research worker hence understands what is go oning in to the organisation and a “ positive perceptual experience of the subject being studied may be seen as of import incentives for research engagement ” ( Wray et al 1996 ) . The research workers could so obtain critical informations that is relevant to the hypothesis being formulated because of the informations aggregation prior to carry oning the research.

Data aggregation prior to research can besides heighten the dependability of the findings, while questioning people normally have different positions on what is go oning in an organisation or some people omit information that might demo the organisation in a negative visible radiation. Data obtained prior to the survey can be compared to informations that has been obtained and the cogency of the informations can be enhanced by set uping a relationship between the informations obtained prior to the survey and after the survey. “ Validity is enhanced by set uping causal relationships whereby certain conditions are shown to take to other conditions, as distinguished from specious relationships ” ( Pandit, 1996 )

Therefore informations aggregation prior to research can enrich the research with more valid and dependable information nevertheless the process can be clip devouring as there might be a immense sum of complex informations that has to be analyzed. ( Pandit, 1996 ) This though might non hold been the instance with Laskarina Holidays at it is a little organisation that is non complex.

Narrative representations can be ready to hand tools to construe and exhibit natural informations in a simplified manner. ( Alveeson/Deetz 1996 ) Equally utile as natural information is, non holding any narrative representations might non allow the writer turn out his point, natural informations might be equivocal and readers might hold different readings of the text. ( McGaughey, 2006 ) . The narrations in bend simplify what the writer is seeking to state into of import classs, which were what the quest of research is about. ( Wilkinson Et Al, 1998 )

The narrations in the Laskarina research paper gaining control a batch in footings of Laskarina as an administration as it describes laskarina in three chief angles that other perceivers of administrations would most likely want to read about if they are making research on administrations. These angles would assist the reader have a deeper apprehension of a complex or ill understood phenomenon ( McGaughey, 2006 ) .

The three narrations focus on Laskarina as an administration in an economic position in the sense that it is a profit-seeking administration. With 10,000 vacations sold and a turnover of 5m lbs it is apparent that Laskarina Is a profitable company, a high degree of repetition clients proves how effectual their scheme is at maintaining the company profitable. The other narrative focal points Laskarina in a morality position, which shows to what extent does the administration attempt to maximize its net income? Will it be at the extent of being un-ethical? Laskarina proved to be a comparatively ethical administration. The scope of philanthropic activities that the administration undertakes proves that either the company autos about what people say about the administration or the proprietors genuinely do care about the Grecian islands they operate in.

Laskarina is looked at from a pleasance point of position as good, where employees are asked about how happy they are working for Laskarina. This narrative is interesting as it shows how successful the proprietors of Laskarina are on constructing the work environment in which their employees work in based on narratives ( narrations ) that motivate employees on working harder and merchandising merchandises that they believe in.

Although narrations are utile they can besides restrict the angles that a reader can look at an administration. Some readers might for illustration want to see how competitory Laskarina is or how Laskarina tantrums in with its rivals. With narrations doing economic, morality and pleasance in the administration clearer it is besides film overing what is in between. Another job is that the narrations may switch the reader ‘s focal point from the administrations activities into the writer ‘s representations. ( Atkinson et al 2005 ) readers might be forced into holding the same sentiment as the research worker.

After reading diaries on ethical quandary caused during research it became evident that the consideration to protect the individuality of research respondents appears to hold become cardinal to the design and pattern of most ethical research ( Grinyer 2002 ) . Reading through a Case Study of Laskarina Holidays it was evident that the ethical quandary faced in the research was the protection of individualities of different respondents. The British Psychological Society emphasises the importance of namelessness by saying in their codification “ Participants in psychological research have a right to anticipate that information they provide will be treated confidentially and, if published, will non be identifiable as theirs. ” ( Robson, 1995 ) . Since the debut of the Data Protection Act ( 1998 ) which came into consequence on 1 March 2000, the consideration of namelessness and privateness is no longer merely a affair of moralss ; it can besides hold legal deductions. ( Grinyer 2002 ) .

While the interviewees names in a Case Study of Laskarina Holidays were kept anon. . Some of them were identifiable by their places or in the instance of the proprietors their individualities were non hidden at all. Harmonizing to Barnes ( 1979:39 ) is that informations should be presented in such a manner that respondents should be able to recognize themselves, while the reader should non be able to place them. Protecting the individuality of the researched and moving ethically is n’t something as clear cut as most people think. Dingwall ( 1980 ) states that ethical codifications or demands are inherently equivocal ; a research worker will happen it difficult to cognize if they have acted ethically or non. A survey done by Goodwin et Al ( 2003 ) put her in a same state of affairs where she was researching physicians in a infirmary. The writer has worked in that same infirmary for five old ages so she has established resonance with all the employees and a batch of them considered her as a friend. However as a research worker she found that the physicians would speak about confidential information in forepart of her and she did n’t cognize weather they did so because they thought of her as a friend or if they did n’t mind this piece of information to be put in the information aggregation. Ultimately she decided to drop the piece of informations.

Wolcott ( 1995 ) suggests that this ambiguity can be dealt with by seting the moral issues on “ the tabular array ” and discoursing them with the people being researched. Some persons would desire their names or individualities shown in the research paper as they feel that they loose ownership of the informations when their individualities are hidden. ( Grinyer 2002 ) .

Another ethical quandary in the research paper is the repute of the administration itself. Ian and Kate Murdoch proprietors of Laskarina Holidays decided to travel their offices near Gatwick. This has caused hurt to the loyal employees of the company who decided to go forth Laskarina, some of them even felt betrayed by the company. ( Humphreys et al, 2005 ) After the move the company went bankrupt. This information might hold tarnished the repute of Laskarina but it was information that has to be shown. One can reason that it can be unethical to ever demo a colored rose-colored image of administrations. ( Goodwin et al, 2003 ) .

After the bankruptcy Ian Murdoch claimed that the company went insolvents due to cheap plane tickets to other alien topographic points and high competition. Administration proprietors seldom divulge every individual piece of information that lead to the failure of the administration particularly when this information depicts the administration in a negative visible radiation.

( Word Count: 2988 )

Mentions

• History of Gendered Fieldwork Relations in Ethnographic Work on Stress in Teaching ‘ , in G. Walford and C. Hudson ( explosive detection systems ) Genders and Sexualities in Educational Ethnography Volume 3, pp. 209-30. Oxford: JAI.
• Alveeson, Mats and Deetz, Stanley ( 1996 ) Critical Theory and postmodernism attacks to organisational surveies, ( pp191 – 217 )
• Atkinson, P. and Delamont, S. ( 2005 ) ‘Analatyc Prespectives ‘ , in N.K. Denzin and Y.S. Lincoln. Handbook of Qualitative Inquiry, 3: 324-345
• Barnes J. ( 1979 ) Who Should Know What? Penguin, Harmondsworth.
• Brannen, P. ( 1987 ) Working on managers: some methodological issues. In Moyser, G. , Wagstaffe, M. ( explosive detection systems ) . Research Methods for Elite Studies. London: Allen & A ; Unwin.
• Carr, E. , Worth, A. ( 2001 ) The usage of telephone interviews for research. Nurse research 6: 511-525.
• Corbin, J. , & A ; Strauss, A. ( 1990 ) . Grounded theory research: Procedures, canons, and appraising standards. Qualitative Sociology, 13, 3-21
• Dingwall, R. ( 1980 ) . Ethical motives and descriptive anthropology. Social Review, 28 ( 4 ) , 871-891.
• Goodwin, D. Pope, C. Mort, M. and Smith, A. ( 2003 ) Ethics and Ethnography: An Experiential Account. Qualitative Health Research, 13 ( 4 ) 567-577.
• Grinyer, Anne. ( 2002 ) The Anonymity of Research Participants: Premises, Ethical motives and Practicalities. Social Research Update Issue ( 36 ) .
• Harris, Ruth. Kelly, Daniel. Hunt, A. Jane. Plant, Hilary. Kelley, Kate. Richardson, Alison. Sitzia, John. ( 2008 ) Accessing elect nurses for research: contemplations on the theoretical and practical issues of telephone interviewing, Journal of Research in Nursing 2008 ; 13 ; ( 3 ) 236-248
• Hirsch, P. ( 1995 ) Tales from the field: acquisition from research workers ‘ histories. In Hertz, R. , Imber, J.B. ( explosive detection systems ) . Analyzing Elites Using Qualitative Methods, pp. 72-79. Thousand Oaks, California: Sage Publication
• Humphreys, Michael. Gurney M. Paul. Brown, D. Andrew. ( 2005 ) Narrative, individuality and alteration: a instance survey of Laskarina Holidays, Journal of Organisational Change Management,18 ( 4 ) 312-326
• James P. Spradley ( 1979 ) The Ethnographic Interview Wadsworth Pub Co ( pp 7-156 )
• Kamenou, N. ( 2008 ) Reconsidering Work-Life Balance Debates. British Journal of Management, 19 s99-s109
• LeCompte, D. Margaret, Schensul, J. Jean, ( 1999 ) Designing and carry oning ethnographic research, AltaMira Press ; 1 edition ( pp 9-13 )
• McGaughey, S.L. ( 2006 ) Reading as a method of enquiry in IB: Re-presentations of the ‘born planetary ‘ . Management International Review, Special Issue on Qualitative Methods in International Business, 46 ( 4 ) , 461-480.
• Oakley, A. ( 1979 ) Becoming a Mother. Oxford: Martin Robertson.
• Pandit, R. Naresh ( 1996 ) The Creation of Theory: ? A Recent Application of the Grounded Theory Method. The Qualitative Report, Volume 2, Number 4
• Puwar, N. ( 1997 ) Reflections on questioning adult females Mps. Sociological Research Online 2 ( 1 ) hypertext transfer protocol: //www.socre-
• Robson C. Real World Research, Blackwell, Oxford.
• Russell, L. ( 2005 ) It ‘s a inquiry of trust: equilibrating the relationship between pupils and instructors in ethnographic fieldwork. Qualitative Research 5 ( 2 ) 181-199
• Silverman, D ( 2007 ) A really short, reasonably intresting and moderately inexpensive book about qualitative reearch.
• Simsek, Z. and Veiga, J.F. ( 2000 ) “ The electronic study technique: an question and appraisal. Organisational Research Methods, 3: 92 -114
• Speer, S.A. ( 2002b ) ‘Natural and Contrived Data: A Sustainable Differentiation? ‘ Discourse Studies 4 ( 4 ) : 511-25.
• Spencer, G. ( 1982 ) Methodological issues in the Study of Bureaucratic Elites: a instance survey of West Point. In Burgess, R.G. ( ed. ) . Field Research: a Sourcebook and Field Manual. London: George Allen & A ; Unwin.
• Stapelton, M.G. ( 1984 ) ‘Education and Racism: A Study of the Teachers ‘ and Pupils ‘ Relationss in the Schooling of Black Boys ‘ . Unpublished PHD Thesis, Aston University, Birmingham.
• Thomas, R.J. ( 1995 ) Interviewing of import people in large companies. In Hertz, R. , Imber, J.B. ( explosive detection systems ) . Analyzing Elites
• Thrope, R. Holt, R. ( 2008 ) The sage lexicon of qualitative direction research. Sage Publications
• Troman, G. ( 2000 ) ‘Does Gender Make a Difference? A Male Researcher ‘s Automatic
• Wilkinson, I./Young, L./Welch, D. E./Welch, L. S. , ( 1998 ) Dancing to success: Export Groups as Dance Parties and the Implications for Network Development, The Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing, 13, 6, 1998, pp. 492 – 510
• Wolcott, H, F. ( 1995 ) . The art of fieldwork. Walnut Creek: AltaMira
• Wray, J. , Gates, B. ( 1996 ) Problems of Enrolling Participants for nursing research: a instance survey. Nurse Researcher, 1 ( 5 ) , 366-373.