The building industry is characterised by a loosed, disconnected and differentiate system. Professionals and practicians runing within the industry posses ‘ accomplishments, trueness and orientation acquired in an environment of specialization, differing traditions and sometimes conflicting involvements. This ground makes integrating within the industry to be weak at present, therefore, new advanced methods of procurance and operation that would follow the best ways of presenting edifices to clip, budgeted cost and at the in agreement quality are required to assist Subdue the inhibitive tendencies posed by the complex nature of building.
Harmonizing to Pheng and Ke-Wei ( 1996 ) , research carried out in the UK by Building Research Establishment reveals that approximately 50 % of building mistakes were due to plan lacks ; 40 % were due to hapless craft and 10 % were due to merchandise failure. Due to the varying and complex nature of building undertakings, it is imperative for all buildings undertakings to be implemented by sing rational direction attack that would guarantee right design solutions, which would fulfill clients ‘ demands, and every bit good, enable sensible net income to be achieved by the provider of building services. In this regard, the functions of effectual execution of Entire Quality Management ( TQM ) can non be overemphasized.
Construction industry has been continuously criticized for its hapless public presentation and productiveness in relation to other industries since the past decennaries due to its failure to encompass modern technological and societal alterations. Unlike the building industry, TQM is non new to the fabrication sector ; the sector is widely recognised for tight looped system, with a well-instituted quality system. This is fundamentally due to its repetition production procedures. While in the building sector, building plants, e.g. edifices or Bridgess are undertaken as individual batches or undertakings, which basic procedures are repeated from occupation to occupation ( e.g. concreting and daubing ) , but particulars of application are ever altering.
Rowlinson and Walker ( 1995 ) province that building industry is characterised by its non-standardization due to its one-off merchandises, different production procedure and design item alterations, which make it hard to follow a cosmopolitan criterion or specification that can be applied to the merchandise, therefore, quality confidence is greatly affected. Even, the execution of TQM in building is a great challenge to Japan that is frequently referred to as the Centre for quality programmes and inventions. Therefore, it is no accident that the building industry has turned to the fabrication sector as a point of mention and beginning of invention.
The debut of Entire quality direction ( TQM ) to the building industry activities evolved pursuant to relentless force per unit area for alteration and improved quality in the building industry by intelligent clients in the industry and authorities. However, it is hapless that most building services suppliers in the industry ever reappraisal and assure their dedication to TQM rules proposed by TQM gurus like Deming, Crosby, Juran, Kaizen, and Taguchi, etc. during the conceptual phase of most building undertakings, but they ever fail to practically implement it efficaciously during the building stage. Then, they hope on miracle of quality to go on, a state of affairs which is hapless, uncalled for, and unprofessional ( Kabul 1994 ) .
There is no universally accepted definition of Total Quality Management ( TQM ) , because there are many choice gurus who gave their ain definitions of TQM, some of them have been mentioned above. However, irrespective of their different definitions of the subject, the underpinning facts of all TQM definitions are client satisfactions and acquiring the occupation done right at the first clip.
TQM definition given by Haigh and Morris ( 2001 ) has been adopted for this survey, because it suits the building industry activities. It states that:
“ TQM is a procedure which embraces the witting nisus for nothing defects in all facets of an administration activities ” ( Haigh and Morris 2001 ) .
Customer ‘s demands in building undertakings are growlingly complex and outlooks uncertain, the effectual execution of TQM will intentionally assist to accomplish the corporate end of all parties who are involved in a undertaking, and puting the meeting of the client ‘s demands as the ace ordinate end, which can be consistently achieved. Apart from run intoing the clients ‘ demands and all other parties in a undertaking, TQM will assist to efficaciously vie in the industry as most clients now give precedence to quality, cost, bringing clip, safety, and merchandise development in footings of time-to-market and inventions. The successful execution of TQM in building is greatly depending on a civilization of teamwork and cooperation among all organizational degrees and other parties involved.
The accomplishment of the effectual quality direction system that the fabrication sector ever boast about can besides be achieved in the building sector by effectual execution of TQM doctrine, which this piece of work intends to pronounce.
1.2 Research Aim
The purpose of this research is to analyze and critically analyse Total Quality Management ( TQM ) used in Construction Industry, in order to discourse effectual agencies of implementing TQM and besides highlight the possible impacts of effectual implemented Entire Quality Management ( TQM ) to the building concern.
1.3 Research Aims
To analyze and critically appraise rational for Entire Quality Management ( TQM ) system used in building industry.
To discourse the factors which affect building quality.
To discourse a systematic attacks for effectual execution of Entire Quality Management ( TQM ) in Construction Industry.
To foreground Potential positive impacts of effectual implemented Entire Quality Management ( TQM ) on Construction Industry concern public presentation.
1.4 Research Hypothesis
Effective execution of Entire Quality Management ( TQM ) , would better building concern public presentation with regard to quality of building merchandises, budgeted cost and clip off bringing, which are used as the pace stick for mensurating building undertaking success.
1.5 Scope and Restrictions
This survey fundamentally focuses on building houses in the United Kingdom, irrespective of their size and turnover. It emphasizes on how choice direction was perceived by chosen houses and the benefit they tend to deduce from effectual execution of TQM.
The restrictions of this survey include unaccessible to necessitate primary informations from building houses that have implemented TQM in their administration ; clip restraint, which makes it hard to develop a theoretical account for effectual execution of TQM for the building industry, trial it, and compare it with bing TQM theoretical accounts consistently adopted by different building administrations within the industry.
1.6 Structure of the Thesis
Chapter 1: This chapter gives brief background information about the building industry and how TQM is perceived in the industry, purposes and aims of the research, research hypothesis, range and restrictions of the research.
Chapter 2: This chapter presents the methodological attack and schemes to this research. Qualitative methods approach utilizing a instance survey is discussed in inside informations.
Chapter 3: This chapter discusses the construct of quality direction rules, quality confidence, quality control, and factors that affects building quality in inside informations.
Chapter 4: This chapter would concentrate on the rules and construct of TQM proposed by quality gurus ( Deming, Juran, Crosby, Feigenbaum, and Ishikawa ) . Existing constructions of TQM theoretical accounts adopted in the building industry, and its indispensable constituents would be critically appraised.
Chapter 5: This chapter would concentrate on tools and techniques used in choice direction.
Chapter 6: This chapter would show how TQM can be efficaciously implemented to better building concern public presentation. TQM possible positive impacts would besides be discussed in inside informations.
Chapter 7: This chapter would concentrate on instance survey analysis of three different building administrations that have implemented TQM in their procedure of operation.
Chapter 8: This chapter would show a brief sum-up of the research and gives overall decision base on the overall cognition gained from the survey, and besides make recommendations on countries that farther survey is required to turn to.
2.1 The Research Approach
A research methodological analysis is the overall method applied to accomplish the purposes and aims of a survey. A systematic research attack that would stipulate processs stairss and tools for investigation, roll uping, analyzing, and construing required information/data is needed to steer this undertaking from derailment from its purpose and aims.
The chief intent of this research is to discourse how TQM can be efficaciously implemented in building undertakings and their positive impacts. In order to accomplish the purposes and aims of this survey, it is necessary to see a holistic point of position on TQM of building administrations to be investigated, because available criterions demands are expressed from a generic point of position and most administrations have their different specific ways of run intoing the criterions.
Harmonizing to Remenyi et Al. ( 1998 ) , research methodological analysis to be adopted depends on some factors, which include the country of survey and the research hypothesis, i.e. the specific research inquiry. Qualitative and quantitative attack could be adopted to look into or analyze a research country. For the intent of this survey, it is of import to utilize qualitative attack, in order to derive holistic point of position and fact from selected building administrations that have successfully implemented TQM to their organizational activities. The procedures presented below had been set to steer this work consistently throughout the period of the survey.
Background readings about what old research workers have written or said about TQM would be one of the beginnings that would uncover the tendencies of execution of TQM in the building industry. The intent of literature reappraisal is to derive better cognition and apprehension of TQM adopted in the building industry. Literature reappraisal will place the broad country in which the work could be conducted, and give sufficient consciousness about the current province of cognition on the subject, reveal restrictions encountered by other research workers on the subject, and aid to streamline the research by restricting the range of the research to an accomplishable undertaking, and how the proposed research tends to add to what is known ( Gill and Johnson 2002 ) .
Hart ( 2005 ) conceived that a good literature reappraisal would exhibit proficient competency in seeking and choice of thoughts ; It possesses lucidity of look and consistently or logically analyses an statement of bing work, therefore, associate the proposed research to bing pools of cognition.
In add-on to deriving better cognition and apprehension on the topic, secondary informations could be acquired from literature reappraisal, which could be used for comparing intent with primary collected. Articles, research documents, professional diaries, magazines, text editions, and the cyberspace on TQM would be used to roll up of import information and related informations, which will help the accomplishment of the research intent.
Qualitative research attack can be used to look into or analyze a research work. It could take the signifier of interview or/and instance surveies. Qualitative attack is frequently regarded to as exploratory surveies, which its intent is non to roll up specific information or information for generalization, but to garner adequate information or information for better apprehension of the subject country. Exploratory research utilizing instance surveies on some administrations that have adopted TQM will give better apprehension and impacts of effectual execution of TQM on building undertakings.
2.3.1 Case Studies
Case survey is regarded to as qualitative research attack, because it is an empirical question that investigates a modern-day phenomenon within the context of a peculiar subject. It ever provides a systematic agencies of measuring events in deepness, roll uping informations, analyzing information and infering meaningful decisions. Case surveies could be used to supply a description ; to prove a theory ; and besides to bring forth theory. Case surveies of building administration that have implemented TQM on their building undertakings would be selected for a reappraisal, informations and every information gathered would be critically analysed to measure the impacts of effectual execution and benefits of TQM on building undertakings.
Harmonizing to Yin 1994, a individual instance survey on a subject would supply a hapless base for generalization. Consequently, in my capacity to avoid bias decision, critical observation and in-depth survey of three different instances of building administrations that have successfully implemented TQM on their building undertakings, would be reviewed and analysed to give a wider view/opinion, strengthen and formalize my concluding decision.
2.3.2 Interview and Open Questionnaire
A qualitative research attack could besides take the signifier of explorative research through an interview, treatment and unfastened questionnaires, which are subjective to the answering personal sentiment, perceptual experience or feelings about a subject. A structured interview could be conducted by inquiring inquiries sing execution and benefits of TQM on building undertakings with the range of examining responses by inquiring auxiliary inquiries to obtain more inside informations about TQM. This could likely be achieved by face-to-face or calling the respondent or unfastened questionnaire, which would give the respondents the opportunity to compose out their response, and the information or information expected to be gathered would be really helpful in turn outing the hypothesis of this research. However, qualitative attack method ( Interview and Open Questionnaire ) will non be carried-out for this survey due to the clip restraint associated with this research.
2.4 Conclusion and Recommendations
Premises and logical remarks would be made from the analysed instance surveies, and a valid concluding decision will be drawn as respects to the analysed information with the aims. Recommendations for future research would be proposed base on issues presented during the survey.
Objective 1: To analyze and critically appraise rational for Entire Quality Management ( TQM ) system used in building industry.
Objective 2: To discourse the factors which affect building quality.
Objective 3: To discourse systematic attack for effectual execution of Entire Quality Management ( TQM ) in Construction Industry.
Literature Review and Case Study.
Objective 4: To foreground Potential positive impacts of effectual implemented Entire Quality Management ( TQM ) on Construction Industry concern public presentation.
Literature Review and Case Study.
Figure 1: Research Model.
QUALITY MANAGEMENT IN CONSTRUCTION
Construction industry is a competitory industry, which organizations in the market demand to vie for market portions, due to the market construction that takes the signifier of competitory tendering, which does non let a possible contractor or provider of services in the market to take advantage of the market.
Oakland ( 1993 ) states that quality is likely one of the most of import competitory arms in today ‘s unpredictable and competitory markets. Consequently, organisations in the market demand to win concern by utilizing strategic arms that would give a competitory advantage or little competitory border over other rivals by converting possible clients or client that if given the opportunity, they would supply exact services required better than others in the market. In this regard, the debut of Entire Quality Management ( TQM ) on building undertakings is one of the critical strategic arms that could be used to derive competitory advantage in the industry.
‘Quality ‘ can be considered from a broad spectrum of countries, because it means different things to different people in a different context, therefore, it is regarded as elusive and indistinct ( Bank 2000 ) . Even, building quality is hard to specify base on the singularity of the building terminal merchandises – one time built, it is irreversible, and professional backgrounds of different parties who ever involve in the executing of building undertakings ( Chung 1999 ) .
However, “ Quality is defined as meeting to the full ( or transcending ) the outlooks of those to whom you are supplying a merchandise or services ” ( Thorpe and Sumner 2001, p.3 ) . Quality could be viewed from the facet of the features of a merchandise or services ( edifices ) that bears on its ability to fulfill stated demands or a merchandise or service ( constructing ) that conforms to demands, i.e. free of lacks. It is merely described by Crosby ( 1984, p.59 ) , as “ conformity to demands ” .
The monetary value that possible clients are willing to pay for a building undertaking is ever a contemplation quality outlook – there is a inclination that inferior stuffs would be likely settled for in the instance of a cheaper undertaking and frailty versa, since the purpose of building organisations in the market is to bring forth quality services in such a manner that would enable them to accomplish their ain concern aims, e.g. profitableness, return on investing or capital employed, and fulfilling their interest holders.
Most building organisations in the industry show their committedness to quality services by giving a quality direction statement ; nevertheless, the committedness to a quality direction system goes beyond mere statements. Therefore, criterions such as ISO 9001: 2000, has been put in topographic point to guarantee that merchandises or services meet client demands, with regard the terminal merchandise being delivered on clip, to budget, and at the in agreement quality.
Committedness to quality in daily concern is being appealed for continually, this made the international criterion organisation ( ISO ) , in their capacity to go on to update quality procedure public presentation demands in concern, e.g. the debut of ISO 9001: 2008 to run into the uninterrupted demand.
Figure 2: The Quality Hierarchy
3.2 QUALITY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM ( QMS )
A Quality Management System could be merely defined as a set of a structured system, which its purpose is to direct and command an organisation for continually betterment, effectivity and efficiency of its concern public presentation. Thorpe and Sumner ( 2001, P.3 ) define quality direction system ( QMS ) as “ a formal statement of an organisation ‘s concern policy, direction duties, procedures and their controls that affects the most effectual and efficient ways to run into ( or exceeds ) the outlooks of those it serves, whilst accomplishing its ain premier concern aims ” .
Harmonizing to CIRIA ( 1996 ) , BS 4778 defines a QMS as the company ‘s construction duties, activities, resources and events, which provide organized processs and method of execution to guarantee the capableness of the company to run into the quality demands expected by the client. A Quality Management System ( QMS ) is seen as an component of Entire Quality Management ( TQM ) , this is the footing why Oakland ( 1994 p.103 ) , defines QMS as “ an assembly of constituents, such as the organisational construction, duties, processs, procedures and resources for implementing entire quality direction.
Quality Management System ( QMS ) frequently takes all undertakings associated with the production procedure from the client ‘s demand ( both perceived and existent ) to the terminal merchandise, every bit good as, concern demands ( internal and external ) and objectives into consideration. It defines and ensures that methods of operations of an organisation are repeatedly used as laid down by an explicit, controlled, and documented system process. Puting up quality direction system ( QMS ) in organisations is really expensive. However, its importance can non be over emphasizes, since it helps to win concern from the competitory market, and assures organisations ‘ capableness to run into their client ‘s demands if implemented efficaciously.
Quality direction system ( QMS ) adopted in the building industry is fundamentally implemented to:
Produce a quality building merchandise that will fulfill the client demands.
Produce a building merchandises where quality is related to budgeted monetary value.
Produce a building merchandises to be delivered on clip.
Improve an efficient usage of resources.
Enhance communicating among project participants.
Prevent hazards and reworking of undertakings associated to a undertaking.
Improve transparence and answerability in manner of operations.
hypertext transfer protocol: //www.qec.co.uk/images/9000model.gif
Figure 3: Quality Management System – ISO 9000: 2000 Process Model
3.3 Choice ASSURANCE ( QA )
Quality Assurance ( QA ) is a mechanism strategizes to verify or find that building merchandise or services are discharged within the construct of QMS i.e. meet or transcend client outlooks ( Kietzman, 2010 ) . This implies that it is the organizational construction, undertakings and duties for the execution of quality direction through a process-driven attack that considers design, development, production, and services with specific stairss to assist specify and achieve organizational ends. The end to transcend client outlooks in a mensurable and accountable procedure is decidedly provided by quality confidence system, which verifies that client offering is produced and offered with the best possible stuffs in the most comprehensive manner, with the highest criterions.
The debut of Quality confidence ( QA ) came into spotlight during the World War II due to defects that were inspected and tested in ammo after they have been produced ( Techtarget, 2010 ) . Today, quality confidence is applied in the production processes of all economic aspects to track down defects in the procedure of production before they get into the terminal merchandise, therefore, meet or transcend client outlooks.
Harmonizing to Kietzman ( 2010 ) , choice confidence stairss is popularly determined by a tool known as ‘Shewhart Cycle ‘ or ‘ PDCA Cycle ‘ developed by Dr. Edward W. Deming, which consists of four stairss:
Plan: Establish aims and procedures required to present the coveted consequence ;
Bashs: Implement the procedure developed and mensurate its public presentation ;
Check: Proctor and measure the enforced procedure by proving the consequences against the preset aims ; and
Act: Apply actions necessary for betterment if the consequences require alterations.
hypertext transfer protocol: //www.knightfm.com/images/pdca-model.png
Figure 4: The Deming Wheel / Shewhart Cycle ( or PDCA Cycle )
Quality confidence required a high degree of item in its stairss for effectual execution. PDCA is an effectual measure to supervise quality confidence by analyzing bing conditions and methods used to bring forth merchandise or services required by the client.
Its primary purpose is to guarantee that excellence is built-in in every constituent of the production procedure, and the repetition of PDCA rhythm throughout the life-time of a merchandise or services helps to better a company internal efficiency ( Kietzman, 2010 ) . For illustration, be aftering measure may affect probe of building stuffs quality to be used ; look intoing may include client feedback, studies etc to determine whether client demands or demands are being exceeded, and sing replying the inquiries why they are or why they are non and moving could likely affect a entire alteration in the building procedure in order to rectify any proficient defect.
hypertext transfer protocol: //www.fupo.com.tw/images/QualityAssuranceSystem.jpg
Figure 5: Quality Assurance System
3.4 QUALITY CONTROL ( QC )
Quality control is a mechanism strategized to guarantee that merchandises or services to be delivered fitting certain degree of quality ( Madison, 2010 ) . Quality control ( QC ) activities involve necessary actions embarked upon by administrations for the control and confirmation of certain features of a merchandise or service for certain minimal degrees of quality. The primary purpose of quality control is to guarantee that merchandises, services or procedures provided meet specific demands and are reliable, satisfactory, and in fiscal matters sound ( Madison, 2010 ) .
Quality control ( QC ) and quality confidence ( QA ) are frequently confused with each other, though the two are similar, nevertheless, there are basic differences. Quality control is concerned with the merchandise or services by measuring the merchandise, activities, procedure, or services, while quality confidence is process-oriented chiefly designed to do certain procedures are sufficient to run into pre-determined aims.
In nutshell, quality confidence ensures that a merchandise or service is manufactured, implemented, created, or produced in the right manner ; while quality control evaluates whether or non the terminal consequence is satisfactory.
Quality control in building is ever a great concern to building administrations because defects or failure in portion or entirely in a building undertakings could be dearly-won due to re-construction that would likely take to increased in cost of put to deathing the undertaking, and holds that would impact bringing clip. Therefore, conformity to quality specified during the preliminary phases of design for constituent constellation, material specifications and functional public presentation must be purely adhered to. With the attending to conformity as the step of quality during the building procedure, the specification of quality demands in the design and contract certification becomes highly of import.
Harmonizing to Hendrickson and Au ( 1998 ) , Quality demands should be clear and verifiable, so that all parties in the undertaking can understand the demands for conformity.
Quality control in building activities is non limited to building merchandises or services entirely, but besides the people, base on the fact that building industry activities are human intensive. Therefore, success in the industry is partially depend on the quality of professionals, whether skilled or unskilled participating in the industry. When quality control is considered in footings of human existences, it concerns correctable issues ; nevertheless, it should non be confused with human resource issues.
Quality control squad is ever set-up to administrate production procedure and place merchandises or services that do non run into a company ‘s specified criterion quality. However, it is non the duty of quality control squad to rectify quality issues, there are designated professionals to detect the cause of quality issues and repair them suitably. Some of the building quality control review activities include:
Puting the choice criterion or quality of design required by client.
Ensure high quality building stuffs are used.
Planing how to accomplish the needed quality, building methods, equipments, stuffs and forces to be employed.
Construct the edifice right first clip by guaranting that architect programs and applied scientists demand are followed right.
Correct any quality lacks through designated accomplishment forces.
Supply for long term quality control through set uping systems and developing a quality civilization.
Produce care and defects lists for fix.
hypertext transfer protocol: //www.fupo.com.tw/images/QualityControlSystem.jpg
Figure 6: Quality Control System
3.5 QUALITY STANDARD IN THE CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY
The debut of Quality Management System ( QMS ) attack in the building industry has been dated back to 1979, ab initio due to the demands on atomic power Stationss ( Thorpe and Sumner 2001 ) . Most organisations in the industry fashioned their single QMS to accommodate their pattern, until the coming of the ISO 9001: 2000, which provide incorporate criterions for QMS attack in the industry, therefore, many building organisations have now converted their QMS ‘s by doing necessary accommodation to run into the demand of ISO 9001: 2000.
Low and Goh ( 1996 ) stated that there are legion factors that have consequence on the quality of building terminal merchandises, some of which are ranked in their order of importance:
Low stamp monetary values that trigger hapless craft by the contractor.
Discrepancies in working drawings and specifications, which ever result in hapless building co-ordination.
Contractor ‘s attitude to giving precedence to clip agenda and budgeted cost than the quality of the building work.
Poor co-ordination among the contractors, the subcontractor, and the nominative subcontractors.
Design ‘Buildability ‘ jobs from the interior decorator – deficiency of particular building methods to accomplish the tight tolerance caused by site restraints.
Lack of proper planning and work control by the contractor – lacking accomplishments to supply the building terminal merchandise in conformity with the design and specification given.
Unrealistic clip frame by the client and its adviser.
Unsatisfactory of relevant codifications and criterion by the design.
Poor stuffs specifications that do non fulfill the criterions or the Building Control Authority.
Absence of quality control system on building work.
Conclusively, the quality of building work is greatly dependent on the attitude of the contractors and advisers. Hence, it is imperative to follow a ‘Total Quality Approach ‘ in all building undertakings in order to extinguish all factors that could hold inauspicious consequence on the quality of building terminal merchandise.
Thorpe and Sumner ( 2001 ) took critical rating of quality control jobs or challenges being experienced or faced by the building industry to be:
What kind of quality aims is appropriate? – jobs of response clip to client questions, design alterations request ; bringing on clip, to budget and at the in agreement quality ; decrease in accident ; and decrease in internal failure or rework.
How can quality aims be communicated and implemented? – jobs of effectual briefing of staff to cascade down the quality aims desired ; placing timescale to accomplish agreed marks ; developing suited indexs to mensurate against.
How do we garner information on client ‘s positions, which will enable organisations to measure both satisfaction and dissatisfaction, therefore, supplying a step of QMS public presentation? – jobs of obtaining feedback from clients ; feedback studies from staff ; ailments ; guarantee claims ; review and audit studies from client ; cancelled work ; and market studies.
How do we implement a process for bar actions? – Problem of placing what to forestall during the pre-construction and building phases e.g. accident, waste stuffs etc.
This research work would extensively discourse how most of these jobs encountered in the building industry could be efficaciously and expeditiously managed for the intent of overall concern public presentation in the industry.