The effects of compulsory uniform on identity Essay

4. The effects compulsory uniform has on a person’s individuality

""The beliefs of the feminist motion were a big inspiration across society and women’s mandate. ( Moon, 2011 ) discusses the demand for equality within all humanity. “In add-on, in the sixtiess and early 1970s nursing was preponderantly a woman’s business, and as many adult females began to travel to businesss antecedently closed to them where they could happen higher wage and more advancement potency, the pool of possible nurses decreased.” This indicates that with the slope in enlisting of nursing, the apprehension that this business was one merely applicable to adult females would turn out to be unbeneficial to society due to the military’s changeless demand for nurses, an issue which could non be ignored. ( Figure 16 ) farther suggests women’s insignificance within this period.

We will write a custom essay sample on
The effects of compulsory uniform on identity Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

""“No professional male nurses were featured, though two male trefoils were. Recruitment booklets likewise portrayed male nurses in rare cases, most frequently in booklets where they demonstrated the uniforms male nurses wore.” ( Moon, 2011, p. 112 ) targets the consumers of unvarying straight, with discoursing that the representation of male gender would still be desirable but were clearly non the chief purpose of these promotional tools. In resistance, ( Parker, 1993, p. 4 ) states “The men’s willingness to follow the nurse’s instructions illustrated their credence of her as an authorization figure. The nurse’s uniform reinforced this image.” This analyzing the verification that these uniforms worn are able to portray control, irrespective of its wearer’s gender, although its contemplation determines masculine shapes instead than 1s related to females. A member of security within a infirmary answered “Patients cognize who you are, authorization and degree of hierarchy” when asked ‘What benefits does have oning uniform have, if any? ’ bespeaking that of recent, unvarying is of bigger significance in respects to experience secure and with gender being something which isn’t considered. ( see Appendix 3 ) . This allows the inquiry that ideas of diffidence in adult females are able to be partly answered and in this being a factor back uping change of a person’s individuality through the usage of these dresss. In farther support, 86 per centum of the populace answered “yes” to ‘Do you think that in people have oning uniform this allows them to alter their individuality whilst have oning it? ’ demonstrating that the alteration of individualities could be an occurring factor.

4.1 In holding diffidence about ourselves, does have oning uniform aid to conceal this?

“Even before sing the specific tactics used in recruitment stuffs, one can see through the Army’s disregard to aim male nurses that it wished to keep the traditional tie between nursing, peculiarly war nursing, and muliebrity. In fact, of the 28 different Army advertizements that appeared in nursing diaries and magazines between 1963 and 1972, merely one featured a male nurse pupil. Recruitment booklets likewise portrayed male nurses in rare cases, non frequently in booklets where they demanded the uniforms male nurses wore.” ( Moon, 2011, p. 118 )

""This suggests that the design of these uniforms is a immense effort at directing common stereotypes about male nursing or its nexus between nursing and muliebrity through the usage of these mandatory garments and the grounds why. It is an indicant that assurance or over-confidence is able to be perceived, with true feelings being adapted. Its chief purpose is to aim these types of occupation functions at the growing of males instead than a combination of the two through the angular cuts demonstrated on these garments with ( Figure 17 ) bespeaking this suggestion.

""( Parker, 1993, p. 8 ) provinces that “The FNS uniform reinforced the nurse-midwife as sense of individuality and intent, and promoted a feeling of integrity amongst the staff” proposing that personal individualities within these businesss would be absent and proposing that the effects these uniforms has on its wearer would be one of a alteration. Besides, ( Parker, 1993, p. 10 ) “Although stained, the outfit shows small impairment of the hardy cloth of its building. War deficits affected the handiness of unvarying fabric in the 1940s” farther sing that the thought of change, at this clip would be through its cloth and the quality available within this epoch. However, ( Moon, 2011, p. 114 ) describes that “Delegates were debating a declaration that would hold supported a bill of exchange and with no gender making specified in the declaration ; the ANA proposal supported outlining both male and female nurses” tie ining gender issues environing enlisting within this period.

4.2 Why do people utilize dressing in unvarying to make a concealed individuality instead than encompassing themselves as they are?

“Moreover, the demand for nurses was a job the ANC would hold to cover with itself, for while “physicians, tooth doctors, and other wellness forces which are predominately male were capable to the bill of exchange for procurement… the nursing Fieldss have traditionally been female and non capable to these procurement devices.” Female nurses were ne’er drafted during the Vietnam epoch, although the Selective Service developed a program to make so if called upon.” ( Moon, 2011, p. 113 )

“Army nursing besides provided chances for rational development that would increase each nurse’s value to the larger medical squad. She would be more than a nurse ; she would be a dedicated professional, equipped in a peculiar specialisation of nursing.” ( Moon, 2011, p. 125 ) describing that the distribution of businesss to a great extent depended on the applicant’s gender to boot supported by ( Parker, 1993, p. 12 ) saying “The reasonable, military-styled uniform reinforces the nurse’s authorization and reassured patients of having adept attention. The frock incorporate staff working towards a common end doing them experience like a household and squad. Wearing her uniform proudly, the decently attired nurse represented the high criterions and ideals of the Frontier Nursing Service.” This bespeaking a sense of dependability towards each gender within both occupation functions individually and non as 1s which could be common if desired.

4.3 How assurance can be seen as excessively confident, or as every bit self-assured to people

""“Occupational frock must besides be suited for the worker, every bit good as suited to the activity. Because of the nature of their occupation, nurses needed a reasonable uniform that conveyed the image of a self-confident, trained nurse. The uniform’s function in developing this image was every bit of import as its practicality.” ( Parker, 1993, p. 4 ) This saying that the professional and mandate of these figures are thought of as urgently in demand due to healthcare of people being of immense prominence and this able to be achieved through appropriate, yet traditional cloth with its possible restraints in head. With the angular cuts used within both military and healthcare subject, a more male-dominated unvarying theoretically able to let feelings and sentiments to be hidden behind this as shown in ( Figure 18 ) . With unvarying holding the ability to supply instant protection every bit good as subject for its wearer, its factors of value, symbolism and professionalism is able to give confidence and regard which asks the inquiry “Will military life do me ‘militarized, ’ less feminine? ” ( Moon, 2011, p. 132 ) and in presuming that these garments are of masculine cuts and cloths as stated, this literalizing women’s ability of being able to ‘hide behind this.’

""The high quality of these uniforms aids in showing a right presentation of the engagement of support given by both nurses and military businesss. Its saving of public image curtailing the usage of their uniforms by foreigners would hold been an happening in many services bespeaking the importance these dresss behold. ( Moon, 2011, p. 138 ) provinces “By naming adult females to wide, human-centered nursing during the Vietnam War, the ANC could basically lift supra political arguments about the war and still continue the traditional thought of service to country” ( Moon, 2011, p. 138 ) to boot back uping that traditionality bears no significance, with the freedom of people impacting non merely themselves but besides the society, perusing this as an unselfish act of kindness. “You’re needed. You’ve heard the intelligence. You know American soldiers are contending in Vietnam. Could you face yourself and the curse you took when you became a nurse if any of them suffered needlessly because they weren’t adequate nurses? Of class non. Fortunately, that won’t happen. Our state won’t allow it go on. You won’t allow it go on. No 1 who chooses a nursing calling lacks a sense of duty… or compassion.” This proposing that although struggle and uncomfortableness would happen, this finding specifies that the importance of a high figure of nurses would be required, and there would be no room for favoritism if this sector was traveling to execute, and thrive.

""( Parker, 1993, pp. 6–7 ) demonstrates the support to the soldiers through the act of nursing due to the usage of these uniforms and non to them as personalities saying that “The uniform’s represented a satisfaction in her achievements. Of class, it did non intend all nurses wore their unvarying right. Nurse-midwife Nancy O’Driscoll when asked the ground she carried, but ne’er wore, her service cap, replied: “Oh…I think the universe of my all right cap, I merely don’t want it on my head.”

""“Recruitment of Army nurses was nil new for wartime, but societal and gender alterations in the sixtiess and early seventiess posed new considerations in nurse enlisting for Vietnam” stated by ( Moon, 2011, p. 120 ) . Further back uping this statement “This connexion between the hurt male solider and the female nurse did more than suggest nursing as a function for adult females ; it besides suggested that female nurses provided of import benefits to the soldiers in add-on to medical attention, benefits that male nurses could non provide.” ( Moon, 2011, pp. 139–140 ) . This demonstrating that the development of uniform is able to make progresss within these industries, in utilizing gender to research how powerful these persons are with a alteration through the cut of these garments, ( Figure 19 ) farther back uping this.

“Meyer’s garments were constructed of “genuine whipcord, with echt buckskin supports and made to suit a woman.” ( Parker, 1993, p. 7 ) indicates that although normally constructed with strong influences of masculine aesthetics, these peculiar garments adopted a more feminine attack, through the eclectic usage of its cloth cardinal to plan typifying adult females. This supported by the 86 per centum of populace who answered “yes” to ‘Do you think that in people have oning uniform this allows them to alter their individuality whilst have oning it? ’ ( see Appendix 1 ) .

“Because the Army technically forbade adult females to function in combat countries, it wanted male nurses for peculiar locations and assignments such as forward combat medical units, infirmaries or surgical units in hostile countries, infirmaries where hostile action was anticipated, and med-evac choppers that transported the wounded from the field. Other than these specific assignments, the ANC had “no numerical procurance aim for male nurses, ” and refused to do gender-specific assignments. Males comprised a significantly larger proportion of military than of civilian nurses overall ; in 1966, males comprised less than 1 per centum of American nurses but about 20 per centum of Army nurses. This high per centum of male nurses in the military implies that a significantly greater proportion of male than female nurses viewed military nursing as a legitimate career.” ( Moon, 2011, pp. 118 )

“Colonel Harper stated that a male nurse who served in the ANC selected the profession as “a agencies by which he supports himself and finally his family—and which he will non alter by virtuousness of matrimony or raising a family.” She emphasized that this tendency was different from female nurses, who frequently were “not looking for a calling of 20 or 30 old ages in the Army, or in the field of nursing. They look at it strictly from the point of the immediacy…gaining an instruction and a capableness for an interim function for the most worthy profession of marriage.” ( Moon, 2011, pp. 118–119 )

""""""The enlisting stuffs would hold been designed to appeal to males, although this wouldn’t have been taken into history, instead for grounds of equality and favoritism with its chief concern being to pull female nurses. “An Army Nurse had added duty to assist her meet the added challenge. She is a leader and supervisor of valuable squad members.” While the text in itself emphasizes a progressive definition of nursing that imparts duty and leading to the nurse, puting the text straight beside a image of a unvarying links that duty and leading to the uniform. Any sort of equality that the nurses might hold found as officers was attributed to their uniform and non to them as individuals.” ( Moon, 2011, p. 137 ) reasoning that these traditional feminine functions are made up of achievement, societal acknowledgment and personal satisfaction, things that male species could non take away even after feminism’s battle for equality with ( Figure 20 ) supportive of this.

""Social debates refering gender functions have been able to go on the development of nursing and the ways in which adult females nurses are depicted with the promise of emotional and physical challenges to supply a good public presentation. ( Moon, 2011, p. 129 ) provinces that “Army nurses could so “concentrate on professional responsibilities merely, ” “work with your patients, non your pencils” showing that these specialized accomplishments which nurses obtained and have built on are of greater significance than gender penchant, ( Figure 21 ) .

With the duties and honor of an Army officer every bit good as a nurse, traditionally feminine functions are able to specify descriptions of gender functions within both the developed nursing and military profession. Community wellness, maternal and child wellness, runing room nursing, anaesthesiology, military nursing pattern and medical-surgical nursing are all elements within nursing are all illustrations of its specific countries demanded of them. ( Moon, 2011, p. 125 ) says that “These advertizements asserted that, because the demands of Army nursing were more ambitious and honoring than the “demands” of working in the quiet and controlled wards of civilian infirmaries, Army nurses were the most adept and dedicated nurses in the profession, a teasing claim to a nurse who wanted to lift above the stereotyped image of nurses as servants to doctors” which suggests that, unlike the physical sex of a individual, gender is a manner of building certain properties welcoming and valuing this, without connoting natural muliebrity even after fostering preparation and committedness to the occupation function.

“Being an “Officer” and a “Nurse” was shown as a progressive move for a adult female, even one who joined the traditionally masculine military. Bing an “Officer” was a manner to procure equal position with work forces, while being a “Nurse” promised calling promotion and respect.” ( Moon, 2011, p. 123 ) This specifying that the resourcefulness of adult females within this industry is a possibility with affecting leading accomplishments, regard and equality as a manner of confirming this. ( Moon, 2011, p. 127 ) farther suggests the humbleness of gender within these businesss through saying that “Thus, because the Army truly valued nurses, it made them officers and placed them on the same degree as males irrespective of traditional gender and health care hierarchies. America’s most traditionally masculine organisation and employer portrayed itself as on the cutting border of feminism’s battle for equal occupation chances, offering adult females a certain manner of being the type of professionals they wanted to be.” This proving that a women’s ability to asseverate herself in take parting every bit in all countries of society continued further than this capableness, gaining her as much duty for personal and national success as work forces.


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out