The Relation Between Environmental Disclosures And Environmental Performance Accounting Essay


By and large, this research focused on how environmental public presentation may impact discretional environmental revelation. Since there were assorted treatment and decision about their relationship in the past surveies, research workers tried to retest the connexion between environmental public presentation and environmental revelation. They used comparable anticipations from economic experts ‘ voluntary revelation theory and socio-political theories as a tool for proving.

Harmonizing to the economic experts, under the voluntary revelation theory, there was a positive connexion between environmental public presentation and the grade of discretional environmental revelation. Companies that will voluntarily disclosed on environmental information for their investors and stakeholders were those with good environmental public presentation.

We will write a custom essay sample on
The Relation Between Environmental Disclosures And Environmental Performance Accounting Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

On the other manus, the socio-political theories predicted a negative connexion between the environmental public presentation and the grade of discretional environmental revelations. When the public presentation was hapless, the performing artists who faced force per unit areas and threatened legitimacy will seek to increase the revelations to alter stakeholder perceptual experiences about their existent public presentation.

In this paper, a content analysis index based on the Global Reporting Initiative ( GRI ) guidelines was developed to measure the grade of discretional environmental disclosed in environmental and societal duty studies. This index allowed investors, regulators and environmental stakeholder groups to acquire to cognize the houses ‘ true environmental committedness and related environmental exposures.

A research was done by trying 191 houses from 5 most polluting industries in the US ( Pulp and Paper, Chemicals, Oil and Gas, Metals and Mining, and Utilities ) to prove the viing anticipations of voluntary revelation and socio-political theories. This consequence agreed with the anticipations of the economic sciences revelation theory, but disagreed with the anticipations by the socio-political theories. There was a positive connexion between environmental public presentation and the grade of discretional revelations in environmental and societal studies.

Literature Review

The literature reappraisal largely discussed on the relation between environmental revelations and environmental public presentation. In the survey of Ingram and Frazier ( 1980 ) , it showed no connexion between environmental revelation and environmental public presentation. The same went to the paper by Freedman and Wasley ( 1990 ) , in which the consequence of the research showed none of the revelation indicated the signifiers ‘ existent environmental public presentation.

However, harmonizing to the paper by Bewley and Li ( 2000 ) , Hughes et Al. ( 2001 ) and Pattern ( 2002 ) , the consequences of their research showed a negative connexion between environmental public presentation and environmental revelations. Pattern ( 2002 ) , who doubted the dependability of the public presentation index by Council on Economic Priorities ( CEP ) and used TRI based informations, found that TRI/Sales showed a negative connexion between environmental public presentation and environmental revelations.

On the other manus, the research by Al-Tuwaijri et Al. ( 2004 ) showed a positive connexion between environment public presentation and environmental revelation. These research workers assessed the environmental public presentation as the per centum of entire waste generated that is recycled.

Last but non least, in the survey of Wiseman ( 1982 ) , he did non reference on the connexion between the environmental public presentation and revelations. Harmonizing to his paper, he developed an environmental revelation index which was used to analyze the grade of voluntary environmental revelations made by corporations in their one-year studies.

Hypothesis Development

Hypothesiss that were developed in the research included:

H1a: Environmental public presentation and the grade of discretional environmental revelations are positively connected, as implied by the economic experts ‘ voluntary revelation theories.

H1b: Environmental public presentation and the grade of discretional environmental revelations are negatively connected, as implied by the socio-political theories.

Research Design

Environmental public presentation indexs

In carry oning this research, 2 different steps were used within each industry as the indexs for environmental public presentation since the pollution leaning differs significantly.

The first 1 was the % recycled ranks. It measured by figure out the per centum of entire toxic waste that was recycled. This measuring could merely be used for houses which were heterogenous in footings of production procedures within the 5 industries mentioned.

The 2nd step was TRI/Sales ranks, the ratio of TRI to entire steadfast gross revenues. This measuring was used for homogeneous houses in the mentioned industries as it could straight compare the environmental public presentation across houses in the industry.

Environmental revelation index

The Global Reporting Initiative ( GRI ) was launched in 1997 to set up a global recognized coverage model to better the criterion, asperity and use of sustainability coverage. It was used in this research paper as the research workers found that it was consistent with the research workers ‘ intent to mensurate the extent of a house ‘s revelation in their sustainability study.

The research workers ‘ revelation index followed closely with the demands of the GRI guidelines. In the revelation index, at around 80 % of the points were related to “ difficult ” revelation steps compared to 20 % for the “ soft ” revelation points.

Difficult Disclosure points

Difficult revelation points in the research workers ‘ revelation index comprised of:

Firm ‘s administration construction and direction systems.

The Board of Directors will inform the stakeholders of their committednesss in the environmental commission.

Credibility of a house ‘s revelations in its environmental study.

Firms that obtained independent confirmation of their environmental studies will have higher tonss for this point as the studies were converting.

Environmental public presentation indexs.

The specific environmental public presentation indexs unwrap included houses ‘ current pollution emanations and their recycling attempts.

Environmental disbursement.

Disclosed were made on dollar nest eggs from bing environmental plans, and attempts spent to heighten future environmental public presentation.

Soft Disclosure points

Soft revelation points in the research workers ‘ revelation index comprised of:

Vision and environmental scheme claims.

They were considered to be “ soft ” as they were non convincing and could be easy imitated.

Environmental profile.

The environmental profile consisted of the bing and forth-coming environmental ordinances.

Environmental enterprises.

These enterprises included employee preparation in environmental direction, being of response programs for environmental accidents, internal environment awards and audit, community engagement through scholarship and contributions.

Econometric Model:

Model and variable descriptions

Research workers employed the following econometric theoretical account to prove the hypotheses:

VED = I?a‚ˆ + I?a‚? EP + I?a‚‚ J-F coefficient + I?a‚? FIN + I?a‚„ TOBIN Q + I?a‚… VOLAT + I?a‚† ROA + I?a‚‡ LEV +

I?a‚? SIZE + I?a‚‰ NEW + I?a‚?a‚ˆ CAPIN + Iµ

The variables in the arrested development are defined as follows:

VED – Voluntary environmental revelations

EP – Environmental public presentation ( TRI/Sales – the larger the step, the

better the environmental public presentation ; % recycled – the larger the recycling per centums, the better the environment public presentation )

J-F coefficient – Janis-Fadner coefficient of instability

FIN – sum of debt or equity capital raised by the house

TOBIN Q – ( market value of common equity + book value of preferable stock + book

value of long term debt + current liabilities ) / book value of entire assets

VOLAT – standard divergence of market adjusted monthly stock return

ROA – entire return on assets

LEV – purchase ratio, ( entire debt / entire assets )

SIZE – natural logarithm of the entire plus value

NEW – assets newness, ( Net PPE / gross PPE )

CAPIN – capital strength, ( capital disbursement / entire gross revenues gross )

I? – control variables included to avoid a correlative omitted variables menace

Benefits of voluntary revelation

There were rather a figure of voluntary revelation ‘s benefits. First, voluntary revelation enabled houses to lift funding in debt and equity markets at a lower cost of capital. This was because public will be more confident on the house and were volitionally to put in the house. Besides, through voluntary revelation, directors could take down the information dissymmetry. They will make a balance between information for both the director and stakeholders.

Furthermore, voluntary revelation may besides act upon houses ‘ public presentation. Firms will seek their best to execute good in market because when they were good in executing, they will be volitionally disclosed the “ good intelligence ” to the fiscal markets. Last, voluntary revelation besides benefits houses in term of purchase. As house ‘s debt additions, bureau costs of debts will increase. The demand for information addition will so increase the purchase and followed by the addition in voluntary revelations.

Cost of voluntary revelation

However, voluntary revelation may besides be dearly-won for house. In term of house ‘s size, most voluntary revelation surveies confine for house size depend on the premise of economic systems of graduated table sing the information production costs. Besides, voluntary revelation besides involved proprietary costs. It was the costs that were related to the director to uncover information to environmental regulators and other environmental militant groups.

Other control variables specific to environmental revelations

Besides costs and benefits, there were besides other control variables specific to environmental revelations. One of it would be equipment age and one-year capital disbursement. Firms with newer engineerings would probably to hold a better environmental public presentation step. Therefore, they most likely will desire to unwrap this to the stakeholders to maintain the assurance from stakeholders or to pull new investors.

Other than that, favourable media coverage besides influenced environmental revelations. As the lagged environmental legitimacy existed, there will be inclination for unfavourable imperativeness articles. The favourable of imperativeness articles was measured by utilizing Janis – Fadner coefficient of instability. This coefficient ranged from -1 ( unfavourable ) to +1 ( favourable ) , with zero connoting impersonal perceptual experiences about the house ‘s environmental legitimacy. This means that, if there is lagged environmental legitimacy, there will be unfavourable imperativeness articles and the degree for voluntary revelation will be low.

Empirical association = important and consistent relation

CEP= a non-profit organisation specialising in the analysis of corporate societal activities

future environmental public presentation = invest in new environmental engineerings, environmentally related R & A ; D and inventions


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out