Traditional Management Accounting Systems Are Incompatible Accounting Essay

Back to the old clip, one could be really proud of having a Mobile phone which could be used to make anyone at anytime. However, the clip has changed. The progresss in engineering allow more than merely communicating but besides other maps, for case, images capturing and internet surfboarding. We can see that how fast is the engineering progressing and this rapid alteration has led us to a new concern environment.

Porter ( 1979 ) identifies five drive forces which, as followers, determine an industry ‘s competition and the resulted houses ‘ competitory schemes.

We will write a custom essay sample on
Traditional Management Accounting Systems Are Incompatible Accounting Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

The menace of new entrants into the new market ;

The menace of replacement merchandises or services ;

Rivalry among bing rivals in the industry ;

The bargaining power of providers ;

The bargaining power of clients.

Pulling from Porter ‘s Five Forces, one can see that the concern environment does non merely incorporate the menace from direct rivals but besides the other menaces from, for case, possible new entrants and clients. The menaces characterize the volatile and unsure nature of the new concern environment. This implies that concerns are now required to be more flexible and antiphonal to this altering concern environment.

Take the bargaining power of clients as an illustration, modern twenty-four hours clients demand a assortment of picks and houses must be able to react to and capture the clients ‘ penchants or gustatory sensations. Besides, powerful clients negotiate and force the monetary values to be reduced and demand higher quality or measure at the disbursal of houses. The menace arises when clients are free to exchange to other replacements at no cost, particularly in retail industry. ( Porter articles mention )

Very late, globalization besides plays an of import function in the changing concern environment. Firms have started to spread out their concerns into an international degree. This means that houses will now hold to confront a much more comprehensive concern environment, for illustration, a diverse work force with employees from different civilizations and imposts or even international rivals. On the other manus, multi-national houses have to take into history of assorted economic and political considerations as good, such as fluctuations in exchange rate or even licencing job.

Due to the above 5 menaces and globalization tendency, Johnson and Kaplan ( 1987 ) raise the thought of ‘relevance lost ‘ , stating that “ today ‘s direction accountant information, driven by the processs and rhythm of the organisation ‘s fiscal coverage system, is excessively late, excessively aggregated, and excessively distorted to be relevant for directors ‘ planning and control determinations. ” ( Johnson & A ; Kaplan, 1987 ) A

Johnson and Kaplan ( 1987 ) argue that traditional direction accounting information system is irrelevant as it does non supply up-to-date and exact information about natural stuffs costs, rivals ‘ merchandises and services, production engineering and clients ‘ penchants. The failure to make so could misdirect the directions and therefore incorrect determinations could be made at the disbursal of the houses. There are several dislocations of traditional direction accounting and 3 illustration issues are discussed as follows:

Planing and Control System

In footings of traditional planning and control system, inactive budgets are usually constructed and discrepancy studies are, as a public presentation measuring system, to be done afterwards. Inactive budget is intended for merely one peculiar degree of activity which is normally close to the estimated activity degree. The discrepancy is the difference between the existent production sum and budgeted sum. For illustration, the budgeted sum is $ 20,000 to bring forth 100,000pens. Inactive budget is merely utile when house is bring forthing at the exact expected production and therefore it is unable to supply right discrepancy analysis when the existent production degree is higher or lower than 100,000. Ultimately, the public presentation step system could be distorted if the public presentation is measured based on the discrepancy studies.

( Zimmerman, 2000 p.263 )

Costing techniques – Single Indirect Cost Pool System

Conventionally, it is believed that costs are driven by the measure produced and there is no strong designation of indirect costs. Indirect costs have no direct relationship to the merchandises or services so can non be traced to single units of production. Under traditional costing system, indirect costs are so aggregated and to be allocated to the merchandises or services by utilizing overhead allotment rate which is:

The overhead allotment rate uses a individual cost driver to apportion indirect costs to the merchandises. Hence, the jobs of under-costing or over-costing might emerge and therefore consequence in merchandise cross subsidisation, particularly when there are multiple productions. On the other manus, this cost pool system merely looks at the figures without farther look intoing how costs are influenced by the complexness of production procedures. ( Zimmerman )

Tax return on Investment ( ROI ) and Performance Measurement

Tax return on Investment ( ROI ) is a normally used investing centre public presentation step as it is compared with external market-based outputs in order to supply a benchmark for a division ‘s public presentation.

ROI has the trouble of happening an appropriate investing cost figure and therefore it may make the job of overinvesting or underinvesting. It is because ROI is really extremely subjected to directions ‘ use. Underinvestment job arises when directions are unwilling to put so that they can demo really high ROI as an semblance of good public presentation. As compared with the public presentation measuring of Net Income, ROI though is said to undertake the job of overinvestment job by keeping the investing centre director responsible for gaining a return on the capital employed in the centre. It might besides adversely consequence in overinvestment job because directions would seek to put every bit much as possible to turn the numerator which is net income and therefore increase the overall ROI. Consequently, utilizing ROI as a public presentation measuring system for investing centres could therefore consequence in inappropriate wages and penalty given to directors.

From the above illustration issues, it is shown that the traditional direction accounting system is non relevant for today competitory environment as claimed by Johnson and Kaplan ( 1987 ) . The thought of strategic direction accounting emerged, which is said to be a solution to the contentions of traditional direction accounting. It matches resources to its altering concern environment by following the way and range of an organisation over the long term. Furthermore, strategic direction history considers rivals ‘ places and therefore Acts of the Apostless as a tool to response to rivals ‘ action.

An effectual direction accounting system must supply seasonably and accurate information for planning and control on production and public presentation rating. Most significantly, it must be utile for decision-making in order to response to rivals ‘ pricing determinations. ( Johnson & A ; Kaplan, 1987 ) Most of the literatures have emphasized the decision-usefulness of, sing rivals ‘ programs and actions, strategic direction accounting. As Roslender and Hart ( 2003 ) say, strategic direction accounting is ”a generic attack to accounting for strategic placement as it is the procedure of supplying and analysing direction accounting informations about a concern and its rivals for usage in developing and monitoring concern scheme ” .

Additionally, it is pointed out by Lord ( 1996 ) that strategic direction accounting does non merely concentrate on the internal but is now farther extended to include external information about rivals.

It is the extension from the internal focal point of direction accounting to include external information about rivals.

SMA and techniques to work out the job

Narrow down which subjects would be focused in order to undertake the illustration issues mentioned aboved.



Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out