What Happens When Personal Moral Codes Are Challenged Commerce Essay

In every society, there is a general perceptual experience of what is right or incorrect and this is provably based on assorted societal belief systems that permeate the cultural cloth of any society at any one clip. This sense of what is perceived “ good ” or “ bad ” in the eyes of members of a society shapes their personalities, it gives them their humanity, it guides them on the way of “ righteousness ” towards the ultimate ageless cloud nine referred to by different names – Eden, enlightenment, Eden, Promised Land among many others. Bing equipped with their moral armor, people go to different topographic points with sometimes different cultural backgrounds ; they find occupations in order to gain a life. Equally much as they have personal moralss, so make the administrations they join.

But what happens when those personal moral codifications are challenged by the civilization that permeates those administrations they join? How much of their ethical individuality do they compromise when the new cultural environment easy erodes theirs?

We will write a custom essay sample on
What Happens When Personal Moral Codes Are Challenged Commerce Essay
or any similar topic only for you
Order now

How much does the corporate individuality impact how ethical issues will be handled?

To what extent does an administration civilization influence its ethical clime and the ethical behavior of its employees?

In the first few paragraphs, we will look at how assorted writers define an administration civilization and its ethical clime. Then with a few illustrations, we will compare and contrast those different positions and pull from that, the apprehension that will direct this essay into replying the above-named inquiries.

Then in the last paragraph, hopefully, we will hold gathered adequate information in order to hold clear replies to the inquiries that are the driving force of this research. And in between these paragraphs and the last one, we will analyze relevant academic theories on the topic.

Main Body

Definition from different writers, my ain apprehension with illustrations

In order to map in an effectual manner, ( Pareek, 2006 ) it is of import that an administration understands the context in which it functions one of which is its ain civilization, the other two being current planetary tendencies and the civilization of the society in which the administration operates ( p. 100 )

Two societal surveies subjects, sociology and anthropology, hold given birth to assorted thoughts of civilization ; these thoughts have been used in organizational surveies within the past 30 old ages. Anthropology bears the interprevist position that civilization is really merely another word for an administration whereas sociology adopts the construct that it both administration and civilization are distinguishable and it is instead the former that possesses the latter ( York University, 2010 ) .

The most widely used definition of civilization is adopted by Edgar Schein who defines it as ( Schein, 1992 ) “ a basic set of premises that defines for us what we pay attending to, what things mean, and how to respond emotionally to what is traveling on, and what actions to take in assorted sorts of state of affairss ” ( p. 22 ) .

( Cox and Hopkins, 1996 ) An administration civilization is its personality which is made of values, premises, norms and artifacts ( touchable marks ) of administration members and their behaviors. Culture in a sense gives an administration a sense of individuality of what they stand for and who they are.

Deal and Kennedy ( 1982 ) argue that the individual most of import factor for an administration ‘s success or failure is its civilization.

Schein and Hopkins see civilization as something of individuality foremost and foremost “ … a sense of individuality… set of premises that defines for us… ” while Deal and Kennedy sees civilization from the point of position of how good an administration performs ; civilization being that set of codifications that will convey success or finally failure to how an administration operates. Underliing these apprehensions of what an administration civilization is, is the thought that civilization is some kind of intangible belief system or set of ethical codifications that form the really kernel of an administration ‘s individualism. Harmonizing to Deal and Kennedy, civilization pervading reactionary administrations such as the BNP will find whether its withstands the trial of clip and given the current planetary Zeitgeist, one can non assist but detect the failure of this party in procuring seats in the UK parliament during general election a few months ago.

On the other manus, an administration such as the RSPCA is reflecting an image of a defender and a savior of the zoology and this is because, harmonizing to Schein, that is what they stand for, coming to animal deliverance is their raison-d’etre and in a manner, gives them that individuality. We can see how they react emotionally when members of the public inflict inhuman treatment on pets for case. Recently, the instance of a adult female who threw a cat in a wheelie bin caused an indignation to charities that look after animate beings, chiefly the RSPCA ( The Sun, 2010 ) .

Relevant academic theories on the topic

There are different types of administration civilizations and each one will hold a different influence on its ethical clime every bit good as on how its employees should act at work.

There are rather a few typologies of organizational civilizations. Arthur F. Carmazzi, an expert on psychological applications to leading, identifies 5 types ( Carmazzi, 2007 ) :

The blasted civilization

This civilization as it says revolves around seting the load of incrimination on any member of the administration and as a consequence, really few or no enterprises are taken within the administration due to the fright of being incorrect. This type of civilization tends to stay conservative and really difficult to alter. The very nature of this civilization has some sort of absolute power over adherent members because of the thought that seeking to model it off from its bing form instils a sense fright upon its members.

Multi-directional civilization

This civilization promotes the atomization of the administration into about self-dependent sections which could badly weaken the unity of the administration. Members working in this cultural ambiance are much more loyal to their sections than the administration as a whole.

Live and unrecorded civilization

Complacency is the anchor that holds this civilization. The passion for great work in a unrecorded and allow unrecorded civilization has about faded. Peoples are so used to their work that they exhibit small or no vision and are content with the position quo of the administration. There is interaction on both the person and departmental degree and the administration will work but will seldom come up with advanced thoughts.

Brand Congruent civilization

In this civilization, the pride of the administration lies in the merchandise or service they are supplying. Members of this civilization will work largely on group degrees in order to accomplish the mark proviso of their merchandise and services. They come up with new thoughts on how to better further and cut a bigger piece of the market portion. Such a civilization might hold small influence on the ethical behavior of its members because the chief focal point will be selling.

Leadership-enriched civilization

Peoples working in this civilization are making so on the degree of the administration itself. Unlike the blasted civilization, employees are willing to demo leading and vision. They take upon themselves the decoration of honor in taking the administration towards a winning terminal.

It becomes clear that the influence of a civilization on the administration it permeates could change from one civilization to another. The influence of a “ blasted civilization ” on its ethical clime will be different to that of “ leadership-enriched civilization ” or “ Brand congruent ” civilization. There are surely a great figure of ethical do ‘s and don’ts in the blasted civilization so one has to invariably be watchful non to “ transgress ” against the administration and endure the effects of the “ whipping boy ” .

The Brand Congruent civilization will be given to overlook when a certain member of the administration stumbles on the ethical way every bit long as the agency justifies the terminal, ( at least from the administration ‘s position ) viz. in the signifier of a really moneymaking service or a large sale encouragement of the administration ‘s merchandise. Directors and employees of certain western or Asiatic companies will non be blamed by their executives for sealing trades with hapless and war-worn parts of the sub-Saharan African continent if that will hike the merchandises and services their companies provide. They will hold acted “ morally right ” for the involvement of the administration in which they belong, though they will hold acted otherwise in the eyes of anyone outside the company.

Person working in an administration where meeting clients face to face will hold been dictated by the administration ‘s codification of behavior to recognize, smiling and talk to clients even if they act impolitely to them. It will be “ right ” for the employee to make so even when if they would non usually recognize, smiling and talk to aliens outside the administration. They could follow a different ethical attack when covering with a vulgar alien on a public topographic point but within the administration, “ greet, smiling and talk ” to clients is the “ manner things are run around here ” , you either take it or go forth it.

A nurse in a infirmary in the United States might experience it is morally right to salvage person who ‘s enduring from a monolithic hemorrhage because possibly that was her call – to take attention and aid save people ‘s lives – but the manner the health care system in American tallies, the manner they do things around at that place to rephrase… one needs insurance in order to be treated so the civilization model of the health care system will act upon what the nurse feels it is the right thing to make and the right thing to make every bit far as the system is concerned, is to look after and handle person who has insurance! The effect of which moral codification to follow at work topographic point has had several serious and even fatal deductions n America. In 2007, a immature African American kid Deamonte ( BBC News, 2007 ) died because his female parent could non afford private insurance. Across the United States, 1000000s of Americans are without private insurances so where does that set staff members of infirmaries? Do they make what “ is ” right in their scruples or what their employers expect of them to make as portion of their occupation? After all, no insurance will intend no income for their employers and hence no wage for staff members.

There is a certain sum of hazard, the possible professional cost, attached to seeking to interrupt away from the cultural gum that binds the ethical clime of an administration and that is most likely unemployment.

What about an administration ‘s action that is non merely unethical but besides illegal? How does an employee behave in such a state of affairs? They either whistle blow or maintain quiet and witness what is unhealthy to their moral value system.

There are three points the whistle blower has to see:

Do they judge where they need to pull the line between acceptable illegal and unethical behavior?

Do they whistle blow with expectancy of a professional cost? Or

Do they let themselves to endure the “ bee-sting ” rule?


To the extent of an administration action, merchandise or policy making serious and considerable injury to the populace, an organisation civilization may hold small or no influence on the moral compass of its employees and as such, a whistle blower will be morally justified ( De George 1986 )

The influence an administration ‘s civilization has on its employees is arguably dependent on the type of civilization bequest the administration holds. As we have seen, different types of civilizations will hold different strengths of influence on the ethical clime. However, there are cases whereby top-ranking functionaries in an administration could in certain fortunes influence the civilization of the administration in order to follow an organisation-wide alteration.


Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Check it out